2nd Report – Jagged Justice: Prisons, Probation and Rehabilitation in Wales

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice engage and co-ordinate with the Welsh Government and its associated agencies as early as possible when formulating policy, adopting co-design and co-commissioning approaches where feasible, so as to ensure that policy meets the … Read more We recommend that the Ministry of Justice engage and co-ordinate with the Welsh Government and its associated agencies as early as possible when formulating policy, adopting co-design and co-commissioning approaches where feasible, so as to ensure that policy meets the needs of Welsh offenders and is sensitive to Wales’ unique delivery landscape. The Department should seek to replicate the collaborative approach displayed in the design of the Women’s and Youth Justice Blueprints, as well as in the recent agreement for the two governments to develop a Memorandum of Understanding for probation and youth justice in Wales. (Recommendation, Paragraph 12) Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the UK and Welsh Governments continue to develop innovative ways of co-operating, collaborating and co-commissioning, drawing on feedback from stakeholders and officials as to where closer collaboration may be needed. As part of this work, we call … Read more We recommend that the UK and Welsh Governments continue to develop innovative ways of co-operating, collaborating and co-commissioning, drawing on feedback from stakeholders and officials as to where closer collaboration may be needed. As part of this work, we call on the UK 65 Government to co-author a Memorandum of Understanding to place bodies such as the Criminal Justice Board for Wales on an established footing, thereby ensuring that this effective model of collaboration endures for the future. (Recommendation, Paragraph 17) Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the UK Government continues to prioritise bringing stability to the prisons and probation service, but that this be balanced with meeting its manifesto commitment to explore and consider the devolution of probation and youth justice to the … Read more We recommend that the UK Government continues to prioritise bringing stability to the prisons and probation service, but that this be balanced with meeting its manifesto commitment to explore and consider the devolution of probation and youth justice to the Welsh Government. The UK Government should include in its response to this report a checklist of measures and steps that need to be taken—with accompanying timelines—in order for a final decision to be reached as to whether to devolve these aspects of the justice system. (Recommendation, Paragraph 26) Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice to continue its engagement with the Wales Governance Centre and the Welsh Government regarding the publication of Wales-specific justice data. As part of this work, the Department should provide us with annual written … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice to continue its engagement with the Wales Governance Centre and the Welsh Government regarding the publication of Wales-specific justice data. As part of this work, the Department should provide us with annual written updates—aligned with the date of the annual Welsh Justice Data releases—regarding its 66 progress in publishing the remaining datasets that have been identified as necessary by the Wales Governance Centre and the Welsh Government. (Recommendation, Paragraph 34) Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice and the Welsh Government co-commission a joint academic review to investigate what is driving the relatively high imprisonment rate in Wales. The findings of this review should be shared with us in twelve … Read more We recommend that the Ministry of Justice and the Welsh Government co-commission a joint academic review to investigate what is driving the relatively high imprisonment rate in Wales. The findings of this review should be shared with us in twelve months’ time. (Recommendation, Paragraph 38) The Welsh Prison Estate: Oversight, Capacity, and Staffing Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice to work with the Independent Monitoring Board’s National Chair to prioritise the sustainability of IMBs across Wales by undertaking a targeted recruitment campaign—with a focus on bilingual Welsh speakers—to ensure that each of … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice to work with the Independent Monitoring Board’s National Chair to prioritise the sustainability of IMBs across Wales by undertaking a targeted recruitment campaign—with a focus on bilingual Welsh speakers—to ensure that each of Wales’ IMBs is fully resourced and able to undertake its statutory obligations. We expect the Department to outline the staffing levels of each of Wales’ IMBs in its response to this report, noting current figures as well as full complement target figures. (Recommendation, Paragraph 45) Show less

View Details →

The Ministry of Justice must maintain its focus on reducing the prison population pressures across the prison estate. We welcome the introduction of the Sentencing Act 2026, which has been described as a vehicle to do this. With this in … Read more The Ministry of Justice must maintain its focus on reducing the prison population pressures across the prison estate. We welcome the introduction of the Sentencing Act 2026, which has been described as a vehicle to do this. With this in mind, we recommend that in 18-months’ time, once the Act has had time to bed in, the Department conduct a review of its approach to prisoner placement across the estate, focusing particularly on the placement of Welsh prisoners, and that the findings of this review be shared with us. As it stands, far too many prisoners are serving sentences far from home: this poses challenges for the prisoner, their family, and the staff working to support them. A prison estate with greater capacity offers the potential for the Department to change its current approach. (Recommendation, Paragraph 52) Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice meet with the Welsh justice unions representing prison staff in Wales to identify the main barriers to recruiting and retaining staff. These concerns should be addressed as soon as possible through investment in … Read more We recommend that the Ministry of Justice meet with the Welsh justice unions representing prison staff in Wales to identify the main barriers to recruiting and retaining staff. These concerns should be addressed as soon as possible through investment in the people who work hard to keep prisons operational and prisoners—as well as the public—safe. (Recommendation, Paragraph 57) Far from Home: Welsh Women’s Experiences of the Criminal Justice System Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice and Welsh Government redesign the Female Offending Blueprint for Wales to take account of the policy changes since it was published in 2019, drawing on the recommendations contained within the Women’s Justice Board’s … Read more We recommend that the Ministry of Justice and Welsh Government redesign the Female Offending Blueprint for Wales to take account of the policy changes since it was published in 2019, drawing on the recommendations contained within the Women’s Justice Board’s report. Additionally, we recommend that the training for magistrates across England and Wales be enhanced, with a greater emphasis on alternatives to custody, especially in Wales. As part of this training, magistrates should be required to visit women’s prisons in order to better understand the implications of handing down short sentences to women. (Recommendation, Paragraph 69) Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice to confirm its plans for the Swansea Residential Women’s Centre as soon as possible. These plans should confirm whether the site will be opening, and, if so, when it will open. Additionally, it … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice to confirm its plans for the Swansea Residential Women’s Centre as soon as possible. These plans should confirm whether the site will be opening, and, if so, when it will open. Additionally, it should confirm its admissions criteria so that expert stakeholders and lived experience groups can confirm that the centre is indeed providing a genuine alternative to custody before any further sites are introduced across England and Wales. (Recommendation, Paragraph 74) Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice to record the nationality of offenders— with Welsh provided as a separate identity to English—so that it can measure the number of self-harm incidents by nationality. We recognise that the Department may not … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice to record the nationality of offenders— with Welsh provided as a separate identity to English—so that it can measure the number of self-harm incidents by nationality. We recognise that the Department may not be able to publish some of this data due to the risk of individuals being identified, however the data should still be collected so as to provide the Department with some clarity on the potential link between self-harm and distance from home. Additionally, we call on the Department to accelerate its work in reducing the costs of phone calls for both male and female prisoners and it should expand its collaboration with third sector partners who support Welsh families to visit relatives held in prisons in England. (Recommendation, Paragraph 79) Meaningful Sentences: Purposeful Activity, Education and Employment Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice to support prison leaders in designing and delivering regimes that prioritise time out of cell and engagement with purposeful activity alongside safety and order. The Department must work with prisons to ensure that … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice to support prison leaders in designing and delivering regimes that prioritise time out of cell and engagement with purposeful activity alongside safety and order. The Department must work with prisons to ensure that they have sufficient staffing levels to unlock prisoners, facilitate purposeful activity, and ensure prisoners are attending classes. As the population pressures facing prisons begin to ease, we expect to see improvements in the purposeful activity scores received by each Welsh prison at their next inspection. (Recommendation, Paragraph 86) Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice to immediately reverse its real-term cuts to the prison education budget in England and to ensure that future funding grows in line with inflation and is aligned with the true costs of delivery. … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice to immediately reverse its real-term cuts to the prison education budget in England and to ensure that future funding grows in line with inflation and is aligned with the true costs of delivery. The Department should also work with the Welsh Government to come to an agreement about the publication of education data for Welsh prisons, using that which is available for prisons in England as a guide. (Recommendation, Paragraph 92) Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice supports prison leaders in their engagement with local employers—identifying what skills and experience they would like to see from prospective hires—and ensures that employment provision within prisons is tailored accordingly. This should be … Read more We recommend that the Ministry of Justice supports prison leaders in their engagement with local employers—identifying what skills and experience they would like to see from prospective hires—and ensures that employment provision within prisons is tailored accordingly. This should be balanced against the need for provision across the prison estate to have a degree of uniformity, so that prisoners are not disadvantaged by transfers to other parts of the estate, where courses may not be available and they are unable to continue their progress. (Recommendation, Paragraph 97) Healthy and Housed: Healthcare and Post- release Accommodation Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the Ministry of Justice and the Welsh Government co- commission an independent review of the provision of healthcare services in prisons in Wales. This review should specifically investigate the effectiveness of the current health board model and … Read more We recommend that the Ministry of Justice and the Welsh Government co- commission an independent review of the provision of healthcare services in prisons in Wales. This review should specifically investigate the effectiveness of the current health board model and should consider the potential merits 71 and demerits of moving to a national oversight model overseen by NHS Cymru. In the meantime, we suggest that health boards in Wales commit to making prisoner healthcare a standing item in their governance agendas and to publishing regular data releases on individual healthcare provision in prisons compared with the community. We also call on the UK Government and Welsh Government to collaborate on the production of a Memorandum of Understanding between NHS Cymru and the Department for Health and Social Care to standardise processes for health record transfers, medicines reconciliation, and continuity of care for prisoners moving between England and Wales. (Recommendation, Paragraph 108) Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice and prison leaders to prioritise timely notification of upcoming releases to local authorities and other relevant stakeholders, giving them the best chance to identify suitable accommodation among an already limited stock of options. … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice and prison leaders to prioritise timely notification of upcoming releases to local authorities and other relevant stakeholders, giving them the best chance to identify suitable accommodation among an already limited stock of options. Additionally, we call on the UK Government to review its decision to freeze Local Housing 72 Allowance Rates until 2027. As part of this review, it should conduct a Wales-specific impact assessment that should be submitted to this committee. (Recommendation, Paragraph 126) Changing Course: Probation and Youth Justice Show less

View Details →

We call on the Ministry of Justice to increase its support for the staff of the Probation Service in Wales. The upcoming strategic review of probation should be accompanied by a review of the service’s staff numbers, pay and working … Read more We call on the Ministry of Justice to increase its support for the staff of the Probation Service in Wales. The upcoming strategic review of probation should be accompanied by a review of the service’s staff numbers, pay and working conditions so that the Department can best realise its ambition to increase its use of community alternatives to custodial sentences. (Recommendation, Paragraph 133) Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the UK and Welsh Governments build on the existing success of the youth justice system in Wales, working in lockstep to support children, provide funding certainty to youth justice services, and ensure that the welfare of children … Read more We recommend that the UK and Welsh Governments build on the existing success of the youth justice system in Wales, working in lockstep to support children, provide funding certainty to youth justice services, and ensure that the welfare of children underpins decision-making in this area. The committee is of the view that the UK Government should consider the benefits that might accrue from the devolution of youth justice with a focus on delivering better outcomes through a more localised and granular focus on provision to the benefit of young people in Wales. As part of this work, both governments should review the case for embedding speech and language therapists within all Youth Offending Teams in Wales, as well as for utilising smaller modular units across Wales that would allow children in the secure estate to maintain their family connections. The findings of this review should be shared with this committee. (Recommendation, Paragraph 144) Just Talk: Welsh Language Rights Show less

View Details →

We recommend that the UK Government work with the Welsh Government to subject Crown agencies to the Welsh Language Standards Regulations 2023. (Recommendation, Paragraph 154)

View Details →

We call on HMI Prisons to work with the Welsh Language Commissioner to design an additional survey for Welsh-speaking prisoners, with questions specifically designed to gather information about the quality and availability of Welsh language services in Welsh prisons. The … Read more We call on HMI Prisons to work with the Welsh Language Commissioner to design an additional survey for Welsh-speaking prisoners, with questions specifically designed to gather information about the quality and availability of Welsh language services in Welsh prisons. The information gathered through this survey should inform a dedicated section—designed to be uniform and consistent, to allow for effective comparison—on the Welsh language within all of the inspectorate’s future reports for Welsh prisons. (Recommendation, Paragraph 161) 75 Show less

View Details →

We heard mixed evidence when it came to ensuring that Ministry of Justice policy reflected the specific needs of Wales and Welsh people. While some witnesses told us that there was a disconnect between policymakers in Whitehall and service users in Wales—especially when it came to commissioning services—we also saw …

View Details →

We are pleased to hear that there is a positive, productive and effective working relationship between the UK and Welsh Governments as it relates to supporting and managing offenders in Wales, and we welcome the development of initiatives, such as the use of secondments among officials, to align and harmonise …

View Details →

We recognise that the justice system in Wales has been under immense strain in recent years—peaking in the summer of 2024 when demand for prison places came concerningly close to exceeding supply—and agree with Minister Timpson that it is best to wait until the system has stabilised before introducing further …

View Details →

We, like our predecessors, have long called for the publication of Wales- specific justice data and we welcome the Department’s decision to publish an annual Wales-specific justice data release, as well as its commitment to publish further datasets relating to homelessness and the Welsh language. Now that some disaggregated justice …

View Details →

The imprisonment rate in Wales has consistently been shown to be higher than that seen in England, as well as in most of Western Europe. This is a concerning trend that needs to be understood and addressed. While we appreciate the candour of the Department regarding its lack of understanding …

View Details →

Independent Monitoring Boards play a vital role in ensuring that prisoners are safe, healthy and engaged in effective regimes. However, the lack of oversight provided by IMBs during a significant period of turmoil and unrest at HMP Parc causes us great concern. Recruiting public appointees to staff IMBs in the …

View Details →

The prison capacity crisis in England and Wales reflects a trend of inflating sentences and insufficient investment in the prison estate by successive governments. While population pressures are facing both England and Wales, we are concerned by reports of particular pressures in Wales as a result of higher recall rates, …

View Details →

For prisons to be safe settings conducive to rehabilitation—where prisoners can spend time out of their cells, build relationships with staff, and take part in purposeful activity—there must be enough staff with the right experience to operate effectively. This requires investment in staff and ensuring that their concerns around pay …

View Details →

The number of Welsh women receiving custodial sentences in Wales is rising, as is the number of those offenders receiving short sentences. This is despite longstanding and ever-increasing evidence that prison—and short sentences—pose particular harm to women and do little to reduce reoffending. The establishment of the Women’s Justice Board—and …

View Details →

The Residential Women’s Centre in Swansea was due to open its doors two years ago; however, the previous UK Government reallocated the funding and we are still waiting on the current UK Government to decide whether the project will be going ahead at all. These delays are unacceptable, as is …

View Details →

The self-harm rates at HMP Eastwood Park and HMP Styal, which hold the vast majority of Welsh women offenders, are deeply concerning. While we recognise that the self-harm rates are higher in the women’s estate than the men’s estate generally, the fact that there are such high rates at the …

View Details →

Engaging with purposeful activity, such as education and skills provision, is vital to reducing reoffending rates among prisoners. While the situation in Wales appears to be slightly better than in England, there are too many prisoners in Wales who are spending too long in their cells, unable to partake in …

View Details →

We were encouraged by what we heard regarding education provision in Welsh prisons. Governors in Wales are able to benefit from a more flexible approach to contract, in which contracts are managed individually— rather than through lots—and governors are afforded a greater degree of autonomy. However, we are deeply concerned …

View Details →

When it comes to supporting prisoners into employment, both during and following their sentence, Welsh prisons are performing well when compared with the average figures for England and Wales. We were encouraged by the positive experiences described to us by businesses working with prisoners and prison leavers in Wales, as …

View Details →

Prisoners in Wales should not be disadvantaged when it comes to healthcare provision just because they are in prison, nor should they expect better or worse service depending on the prison they are held in. As it stands, the current health board-led model for healthcare provision in Welsh prisons is …

View Details →

Prisoner populations in Wales have higher, more complex and more concentrated healthcare needs than those seen in the community. In this context, it is concerning that the UK Government’s recurrent transfer to the Welsh Government to support healthcare provision in HMPs Cardiff, Swansea, and Usk & Prescoed has not changed …

View Details →

The UK Government must revise its funding formula for the recurrent transfer it has sent to the Welsh Government to support prisoner healthcare services at HMPs Cardiff, Swansea and Usk & Prescoed. The transfer amount should be uplifted in line with inflation to maintain the recurrent funding in real terms. …

View Details →

We were impressed by the large network of partners—including multiple UK and Welsh Government funded housing advisors as well as third sector providers—working hard to ensure Welsh prisoners were released into suitable accommodation and not released into homelessness. However, we are concerned by the multiple reports we heard of prison …

View Details →

The Probation Service in Wales is performing well under exceptionally challenging circumstances, and we were proud to hear of its status as the ‘vanguard of change’ in the system. The tools being piloted across the service in Wales promise to alleviate some of the pressure on an overworked and understaffed …

View Details →

The youth justice system in Wales is evidently an example of strong partnership working between two governments who are focused on securing the best possible outcomes for children in Wales, and who wish to see children diverted away from the secure estate wherever possible. We welcome the recent reforms to …

View Details →

Welsh-speaking prisoners should be able to exercise their rights to speak Welsh no matter where they are held in the prison estate: not just for the sake of the language, but for the sake of their rehabilitation. Reports of HMPPS failing to protect and respect the rights of Welsh-speakers are …

View Details →

His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons is responsible for inspecting the conditions and treatment of prisoners in England and Wales, with one of their inspection ‘expectations’ explicitly highlighting the importance of prisoners interacting with staff who are able to implement culturally competent practices. The Inspectorate has said that one way of …

View Details →