Recommendations & Conclusions
5 items
3
Recommendation
5th Report - Protection not permission:…
Not Addressed
We recommend that the UK Government takes the lead in efforts to reach a consensus on the use of autonomous weapon systems and artificial intelligence on the battlefield and the creation of an international instrument on their use. (Recommendation, Paragraph 10) 48
Read more
We recommend that the UK Government takes the lead in efforts to reach a consensus on the use of autonomous weapon systems and artificial intelligence on the battlefield and the creation of an international instrument on their use. (Recommendation, Paragraph 10) 48
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government response discusses diplomatic influence, multilateral engagement, and enhancing IHL adherence for humanitarian access, but it does not address the recommendation regarding autonomous weapon systems and artificial intelligence on the battlefield.
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
5
Conclusion
5th Report - Protection not permission:…
Not Addressed
The UK armed forces have a strong and proud history of supporting IHL. They have experience of operating within the spirit and letter of IHL in extremely challenging environments, and of complying with accountability mechanisms when there have been allegations against them. At a time of increasing global tensions and …
Read more
The UK armed forces have a strong and proud history of supporting IHL. They have experience of operating within the spirit and letter of IHL in extremely challenging environments, and of complying with accountability mechanisms when there have been allegations against them. At a time of increasing global tensions and rising military spending, the world needs examples to follow. (Conclusion, Paragraph 17)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government response discusses mitigating sanctions impact on humanitarian aid and monitoring IHL adherence generally, but does not address the committee's specific conclusion regarding the UK armed forces' history and role as an example in upholding IHL.
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
6
Recommendation
5th Report - Protection not permission:…
Not Addressed
We recommend that the Government prioritises military-to-military training on IHL in line with the increase in defence spending. It should make full use of the range of resources it has at its disposal to support foreign militaries to understand not only their obligations under IHL, but the benefit of adherence …
Read more
We recommend that the Government prioritises military-to-military training on IHL in line with the increase in defence spending. It should make full use of the range of resources it has at its disposal to support foreign militaries to understand not only their obligations under IHL, but the benefit of adherence to IHL for their own populations in a time of conflict. (Recommendation, Paragraph 18)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government response outlines the UK's general support for IHL and calls on all parties to comply, but does not address the specific recommendation to prioritise and make full use of military-to-military training on IHL for foreign militaries.
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
7
Conclusion
5th Report - Protection not permission:…
Not Addressed
The FCDO appears to be repeating the same approaches to overcoming access challenges whilst expecting different results. Successful records of traditional forms of public diplomacy in promoting unimpeded access to aid are patchy at best. Polarisation within bodies such as the UN Security Council limit the opportunities to overcome barriers …
Read more
The FCDO appears to be repeating the same approaches to overcoming access challenges whilst expecting different results. Successful records of traditional forms of public diplomacy in promoting unimpeded access to aid are patchy at best. Polarisation within bodies such as the UN Security Council limit the opportunities to overcome barriers to aid delivery. A radically new approach is needed. (Conclusion, Paragraph 23)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government response discusses protecting aid workers, IHL, and countering disinformation, but does not address the committee's observation that the FCDO is repeating approaches to access challenges and needs a radically new strategy.
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
9
Conclusion
5th Report - Protection not permission:…
Not Addressed
The UK is well placed to ensure the voice of local organisations is heard in negotiations over access for humanitarian aid. This input is vital for effective and sustainable aid delivery as well as maximising the safety of 49 those delivering it. Moreover, the UK is well positioned to make …
Read more
The UK is well placed to ensure the voice of local organisations is heard in negotiations over access for humanitarian aid. This input is vital for effective and sustainable aid delivery as well as maximising the safety of 49 those delivering it. Moreover, the UK is well positioned to make good its commitments to localisation and to realise the benefits that this can bring. (Conclusion, Paragraph 26)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government response discusses risk management for aid workers, programme guidelines, and budget lines for security, but does not directly address the committee's conclusion that the UK is well placed to ensure local organisations' voices are heard in access negotiations.
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office