Source · Recommendations & oversight

National Audit Office

NAO value-for-money reports examining the economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of government spending. Recommendations are tracked against government responses and, where a PAC hearing followed, linked to the committee's own recommendations and Treasury Minute responses.

2,824 reports 2,175 recommendations 1,827 confirmed by NAO 61% implementation rate

Reports

2,824 matching reports · newest published first

Care leavers’ transitions to adulthood

Published 17 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care · Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

The government has made a commitment to improve support for young people leaving foster or residential care in England but the system is not working effectively.

Strategic financial management in the Ministry of Defence

Published 17 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Defence

The Ministry of Defence’s strategy for improving its financial management has put its finances on a sounder footing and is delivering results, but there are still considerable challenges ahead, including delivering the savings already removed …

Ministry of Defence 2014-15 accounts

Published 16 Jul 2015 Financial Audit No recommendations indexed

Amyas Morse, the Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG), has qualified his audit opinion on the MOD’s accounts for the sixth year running.

Department for Work and Pensions 2014-15 accounts

Published 16 Jul 2015 Financial Audit No recommendations indexed

The Comptroller and Auditor General, Amyas Morse, has qualified his audit opinion on the regularity of the 2014-15 accounts of the DWP, owing to the unacceptably high level of fraud and error in benefit expenditure.

Managing disallowance risk

Published 13 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs

Since 2005, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has incurred a total of £642 million in financial penalties relating to the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) in England.

Devolving responsibilities to cities in England: Wave 1 City Deals

Published 9 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

Wave 1 City Deals encouraged cities to develop capacity to manage devolved funding and increased responsibility. It is too early to tell what impact they will have on growth.

General Practice Extraction Service – Investigation

Published 2 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

Mistakes in the original procurement and contract management of an IT system, designed to extract data from GP practices, contributed to losses of public funds, through asset write-offs and settlements with suppliers.

Open-book accounting and supply-chain assurance

Published 1 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Cabinet Office

The NAO has called for government to negotiate greater access to information about how much outsourced public services are actually costing suppliers and therefore how much profit they are making.

Open-book accounting and supply-chain assurance: case studies

Published 1 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Cabinet Office

The NAO has called for government to negotiate greater access to information about how much outsourced public services are actually costing suppliers and therefore how much profit they are making.

Funding for disadvantaged pupils

Published 30 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Education

While the impact of the Pupil Premium will take time to become clear, it has the potential to bring about a significant improvement in outcomes. However, the Department for Education and schools have more to …

Equality, diversity, and inclusion in the civil service

Published 25 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Cabinet Office

The civil service must build on the progress it has made in managing equality, diversity and inclusion and place greater emphasis on departments’ valuing and maximizing the contribution of every member of their staff. This …

Disposal of public land for new homes

Published 24 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

A programme to sell enough government land by March 2015 to build a potential 100,000 homes did not collect information on the amount of money raised or how many homes have actually been built. In …

Public service markets: Putting things right when they go wrong

Published 17 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Culture, Media & Sport

Over 10 million people who used public services (about 1 in 5) in the UK last year faced problems with the services. Detriment can and does occur. But users find the complaints and redress systems …

Military flying training

Published 12 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Defence

The new military flying training is 6 years delayed and there is much to do if the MoD is to get the planned benefits from its contractor.

Care Act first-phase reforms

Published 11 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

The first phase of the Care Act has been implemented well, but this places new responsibilities on local authorities whose core funding is being significantly reduced.

Local government new burdens

Published 11 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

The Department for Communities and Local Government has taken steps since November 2014 to improve its understanding of new burdens on local authorities.

Exploiting the UK brand overseas

Published 5 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Business & Trade · Department for Culture, Media & Sport · Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office

The GREAT campaign enables government organisations to adopt consistent and effective brand management. To date, Cabinet Office has reported a return of £1.2 billion on its £113.5 million GREAT campaign investment. This is based on …

Central government staff costs

Published 5 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Staff numbers and costs have reduced significantly in the last five years. Not enough planning, however, has gone into making sure that the reductions are sustainable.

Financial sustainability of police forces in England and Wales

Published 4 Jun 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Devolved administrations · Home Office

Police forces have successfully reduced costs since 2011, but do not have a clear understanding of the demands placed upon them or of the factors that affect their costs.

Diversity and inclusion strategy 2015-2018

Published 1 Apr 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

This strategy sets out how the NAO will achieve a more diverse and inclusive workforce and ensure that our work helps improve diversity and inclusion across the public sector, and reports on our diversity progress …

Modelling of maternity services in England

Published 27 Mar 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

This series of papers summarises the methodological approaches we have taken in carrying out innovative or novel analysis. Such analysis is conducted under our statutory authority to examine and report to Parliament on the economy, …

Response and delivery evidence

2,175 recommendations tracked

Across the NAO recommendation corpus. Response, implementation and NAO confirmation are separate measures; the categories below overlap.

Status Recommendations Share
Implemented 1,320 61%
Accepted 1,718 79%
Partially accepted 200 9%
Work in progress 503 23%
Rejected 41 2%
Confirmed by NAO follow-up 1,827 84%
Methodology: status determined from departmental responses, Treasury Minute responses, PAC follow-up hearings, and NAO own progress tracking.

Departments named in NAO reports

Departments named in NAO reports · all years
Department of Health and Social Care (126 reports) HM Treasury (95 reports) Cabinet Office (88 reports) Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy (81 reports) Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (76 reports) HM Revenue and Customs (74 reports) Department for Work and Pensions (66 reports) Ministry of Defence (63 reports) Department for Education (63 reports) Department for Transport (62 reports) Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (56 reports) Devolved administrations (56 reports) Home Office (53 reports) Ministry of Justice (39 reports) Department for Culture, Media & Sport (30 reports)