Source · Recommendations & oversight

National Audit Office

NAO value-for-money reports examining the economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of government spending. Recommendations are tracked against government responses and, where a PAC hearing followed, linked to the committee's own recommendations and Treasury Minute responses.

2,824 reports 2,175 recommendations 1,827 confirmed by NAO 61% implementation rate

Reports

2,824 matching reports · newest published first

Confirmed impacts: Helping to improve accountability in the health system

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

This impacts case study shows how our frequent highlighting of the need for consistent and reliable data and clearer accountability has improved reporting and data assurance in the health system. It is one example of …

Confirmed impacts: Securing better progress on nuclear decommissioning

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy

This impacts case study shows how reports by NAO and PAC resulted in the Nucelar Decommissioning Authority terminating its existing management contract and announcing a new approach, expected to improve management and reduce costs. It …

Confirmed impacts: Helping to improve strategic management of debt owed to government

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Cabinet Office · HM Treasury

This impacts case study shows how Cabinet Office and HM Treasury have actioned our recommendations through updated guidance and strategies, establishing consistent cross-government monitoring measures and creating the company ‘Debt Market Integrator’ to provide debt …

Confirmed impacts: Improving the procurement of consumables by NHS trusts

Published 14 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

This impacts case study shows how our work motivated the Department for Health to develop a tool and coding system that standarised and reduced consumables procurement costs in the NHS. It is one example of …

The economic regulation of the water sector

Published 14 Oct 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy

Since privatisation, Ofwat and Defra have overseen major improvements in water quality and service quality. Customers have seen a marked rise in bills but not the benefits of companies’ unexpected financial gains.

Confirmed impacts: Learning from the experience of welfare reform

Published 14 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department for Work and Pensions

This impacts case study shows how DWP has responded to our reviews of several welfare reform programmes, including by improving financial controls, contract management, and the way it manages its portfolio of change programmes. It …

Confirmed impacts: Developing the capability needed to deliver the rail strategy

Published 14 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department for Transport

This impacts case study shows how our reports pointing to the need for Department for Transport staff to improve their skills in managing complex procurements helped DfT to develop a Commercial Capability Strategy, increase leadership …

Confirmed impacts: Driving improvements in NHS stroke care

Published 14 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

This impacts case study shows how our work prompted a national strategy for stroke care and NHS adoption of clinical best practice more widely, leading to considerable cost reductions. It is one example of financial …

Confirmed impacts: Increasing the effectiveness of tax collection

Published 14 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

HM Revenue and Customs

This impacts case study shows that HM Revenue & Customs has implemented more than 80% of our 130 recommendations since 2010, leading to significant reduction in tax avoidance and improvements in accountability and governance regarding …

Confirmed impacts: Shining a spotlight on contract management

Published 14 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Justice

This impacts case study shows how our work has led to reform of contract management across government, including improved accountability and governance, information management and performance management. It is one example of financial or non-financial …

The art of spending public money wisely

Published 7 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

HM Treasury

An interactive summary of the NAO’s presentations at Civil Service Live events, 2015, on four pervasive issues blocking public service improvement.

Investigation into the Cancer Drugs Fund

Published 17 Sep 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

The Cancer Drugs Fund has improved access to cancer drugs not routinely available on the NHS, but all parties agree it is not sustainable in its current form.

Managing conflicts of interest in NHS clinical commissioning groups

Published 11 Sep 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

The Department recognizes the potential for conflicts of interest in the new system for NHS commissioning. Public confidence that conflicts are well managed will be vital.

Financial institutions landscape

Published 10 Sep 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

HM Treasury

The government is selling assets on an unprecedented scale but, given the equally large scale of its new loans and other initiatives, the overall projected net effect is a £200m increase in borrowing.

Care Act first-phase reforms – local experience of implementation

Published 3 Aug 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

This report highlights the issues our case study areas told us were important to them in carrying out the Care Act. Local authorities may find their experience informative as they continue to develop their own …

Care Quality Commission

Published 22 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

The CQC, the independent regulator of health and adult social care in England, has made substantial progress but needs to recruit and train staff and build a new organisational culture.

HM Treasury’s 2014-15 Annual Report and Accounts

Published 21 Jul 2015 Financial Audit No recommendations indexed

HM Treasury

This is the fifth report on HM Treasury’s Annual Report and Accounts. It details the Comptroller and Auditor General’s assessment of audit risk arising from the Treasury’s major financial stability and wider economic support schemes. …

Overseeing financial sustainability in the further education sector

Published 20 Jul 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

With the number of further education (FE) colleges in financial difficulty expected to rise rapidly, there are fundamental structural problems which might require decisions at a regional or sector-wide level.

Response and delivery evidence

2,175 recommendations tracked

Across the NAO recommendation corpus. Response, implementation and NAO confirmation are separate measures; the categories below overlap.

Status Recommendations Share
Implemented 1,320 61%
Accepted 1,718 79%
Partially accepted 200 9%
Work in progress 503 23%
Rejected 41 2%
Confirmed by NAO follow-up 1,827 84%
Methodology: status determined from departmental responses, Treasury Minute responses, PAC follow-up hearings, and NAO own progress tracking.

Departments named in NAO reports

Departments named in NAO reports · all years
Department of Health and Social Care (126 reports) HM Treasury (95 reports) Cabinet Office (88 reports) Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy (81 reports) Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (76 reports) HM Revenue and Customs (74 reports) Department for Work and Pensions (66 reports) Ministry of Defence (63 reports) Department for Education (63 reports) Department for Transport (62 reports) Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (56 reports) Devolved administrations (56 reports) Home Office (53 reports) Ministry of Justice (39 reports) Department for Culture, Media & Sport (30 reports)