Source · Prevention of Future Deaths
Isa Mushtaq
Ref: 2014-0423
Date: 24 Sep 2014
Coroner: Sara Lewis
Area: Manchester (City)
Responses identified: 0 / 3
View PDF
A critical lack of detailed national guidance for antepartum CTG assessment, interpretation, and intervention, leading to inconsistent and potentially unsafe management of high-risk pregnancies.
Date
24 Sep 2014
56-day deadline
19 Nov 2014 est.
Responses identified
0 of 3
Coroner's concerns
A critical lack of detailed national guidance for antepartum CTG assessment, interpretation, and intervention, leading to inconsistent and potentially unsafe management of high-risk pregnancies.
View full coroner's concerns
_ In clinical practice the fetal CTG continues to be a source of problems, both in interpretation and in what degree of action should be taken: This is particularly the case for antenatal (non labour) CTG's since there has not been the same clarification that was provided for electronic intrapartum fetal monitoring by specific NICE guidance: Currently there is no detailed national guidance on antepartum CTG assessment and therefore no guidance as to the circumstances in which CTG changes or abnormalities require urgent delivery: For example, the following problems with antenatal CTG interpretation may arise: - Should change of position or intravenous fluids be used in the same way as in labour (ii) What role can be given to iced water drinks or dietary intake to stimulate fetal changes (iii) At what stage should intervention should be made and with what urgency in the absence of decelerations_ What significance should be attached to reduced variability and what action should be taken in the absence of decelerations (v) What significance should be attached to the absence of accelerations where there is reduced variability: Reliance on the NICE guidance for intrapartum CTG monitoring to interpret antenatal CTG features is of limited value because: It is not intended for such use and therefore such practice is arguably not evidence based (ii) It is much more common for fetal heart traces not to look normal during labour (in the region 20 -30 % outwith normal parameters) therefore the significance of such abnormal traces may not be the same in labour as compared to when identitied antenatally_ iii) Only a very small percentage of antenatal CTG's are not normal: There is no recourse to fetal blood sampling for an antenatal CTG, so that if suspicions persist about lack of fetal well-being there is no way of assessing fetal acid-base balance: St Mary's Hospital has now developed its own local guidance for the management of suspected abnormal antenatal CTG in order to mitigate risk. In the absence of uniform, detailed national guidance on antepartum CTG abnormalities St Marys hospital has implemented a procedure of early consultant involvement where there are persisting features of unusual CTG There should be a review to consider whether national guidance on antepartum CTG monitoring and interpretation where there are abnormalities or unusual features would lead to sater__evidence based management of such cases
Report sections
Investigation and inquest
On 5 June 2013 an inquest was opened into the death of Isa Riaz Mushtaq aged 3 days old and who died on 29 May 2013. inquest concluded on September 2014. The medical cause of death was: Ia. Hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy, myocardial ischaemia The death of Isa Mushtaq was due to Natural Causes.
Circumstances of the death
The mother of the deceased became pregnant in August 2012. Her estimated date of delivery was 18 June 2013. On 29 May 2013 at 13.25 hours the mother of the deceased attended the ante natal unit at 37 weeks and gestation with a history of reduced fetal movement over the previous two days. A cardiotocograph (CTG) was commenced: She was reviewed by a registrar at approximately 1510 hours and reported that she had felt no fetal movement during the CTG. The CTG was classed as suspicious with reduced variability: The mother was advised to eat and drink as this may stimulate fetal movement; with a plan to review the CTG after 30 minutes. At 15.40 it was noted by the midwife that the variability was still reduced and the registrar was asked to review: The registrar attended at 15.50 hours when it was noted that the variability was still reduced and the plan was t0 give intravenous fluids and transfer her to the labour ward: At 16.00 there was a fetal bradycardia: The emergency buzzer was pulled. The fetal heart was 70 beats per minute. At 16.03 hours, two consultants arrived. It was noted that the CTG demonstrated reduced variability for over 50 minutes and a prolonged deceleration: A decision was made for a grade caesarean section. At 16.15 a midwife noted that she was unable to auscultate the fetal heart; Isa Mushtaq was delivered at 16.18 hours_ There was no heart rate for 7 minutes but then resuscitation succeeded_ It became evident that Isa Mushtaq had not recovered from the bradycardia asystole episode and demonstrated severe hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy. He died on the third neonatal An internal investigation of the incident noted that clinicians were _to some extent relying The Riaz day Riaz day: on NICE guidelines as to how to categorise CTG during (abour: There is no equivalent NICE guidance in relation to antenatal CTG interpretation and therefore there is no rigorous system for antenatal monitoring of fetal heart trace. This is a national issue rather than a local one.
Action should be taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you and your organisation have the power to take such action:
Similar PFD reports
Related inquiry recommendations
Bristol Heart Inquiry
Examine Distinction Awards for consultants to incentivise quality care and extend to juniors
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Training for IPC professionals engineers and clinicians
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
IPC role specifications and staffing levels
Southport Inquiry
Autism spectrum disorder police training
Southport Inquiry
Prevent training on online activity assessment
Southport Inquiry
Neurodiversity training for Prevent practitioners
Southport Inquiry
Balancing vulnerability with professional curiosity
Southport Inquiry
Sharing information about closed Prevent referrals
Southport Inquiry
Prevent Supervisor training on closure decisions
Southport Inquiry
Prevent referral training for organisations
Report details
- Reference
- 2014-0423
- Date of report
- 24 September 2014
- Coroner
- Sara Lewis
- Coroner area
- Manchester (City)
Responses identified
Responses identified
0 of 3
3 responses not yet linked
Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 19 Nov 2014 (estimated).
Sent to
- Department of Health and Social Care
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence
- Royal College of Gynaecologists and Obstetricians