Select Committee · Business and Trade Committee

Post Office Horizon scandal: fast and fair redress

Status: Closed Opened: 29 Oct 2024 Closed: 16 Dec 2025 17 recommendations 1 report

We are running a short inquiry on financial redress in the Post Office Horizon scandal, focused on “fast and fair redress” for victims of what has been described as the biggest miscarriage of justice in UK history. In a scandal reaching back over two decades, postmasters who run individual post office branches experienced difficulties with … Show more

Clear

Reports

1 report
Title HC No. Published Items Response
1st Report - Post Office and Horizon scandal redress: Unfin… HC 341 1 Jan 2025 17 Responded

Recommendations & Conclusions

3 items
4 Recommendation 1st Report - Post Office and Horizon sc… Accepted

Instruct Post Office Ltd and Herbert Smith Freehills to simplify and accelerate claims settlement.

The gold-plated legalistic process of the Horizon Shortfall Scheme is not best value for the public purse. The Government should therefore ensure that Herbert Smith Freehills and Post Office Ltd are instructed to use best endeavours to simplify and accelerate the settlement of claims. (Recommendation, Paragraph 18) Read more

Government response AI summary
The government agreed with the recommendation, stating they have already advised the Post Office and HSF to simplify and accelerate claims and continue to reiterate this importance through governance.
Read full response →
Department for Business and Trade
6 Recommendation 1st Report - Post Office and Horizon sc… Accepted

Establish an empowered case facilitator role for Horizon Shortfall Scheme claimants.

Claimants under the Horizon Shortfall Scheme lack the same access to authoritative facilitation and case management direction available to claimants in other schemes. This can be remedied by introducing an empowered case facilitator similar to the role played by the Sir Gary Hickinbottom for Overturned Convictions. We recommend that the … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government accepted the recommendation, stating the Post Office is committed to exploring the appointment of a case manager for the HSS, and the government will appoint one for the HSS Appeals process and remaining HSS Dispute Resolution Process cases.
Read full response →
Department for Business and Trade
17 Recommendation 1st Report - Post Office and Horizon sc… Accepted

Publish clear, regular transparency report detailing external legal costs across all redress schemes.

The Department should publish a regular transparency report detailing external legal costs incurred under all schemes. It is important that the report is produced in a manner that minimises the potential for wider confusion about the basis under which legal costs are billed, distinguishing the cost of disbursements incurred by … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government commits to publishing a quarterly transparency report detailing external legal costs on gov.uk, building on previous updates provided to the Committee.
Read full response →
Department for Business and Trade

Oral evidence sessions

2 sessions
Date Witnesses
19 Nov 2024 Alan Watts · Herbert Smith Freehills, Carl Creswell · Department for Business and Trade, Ed Lidington · Ministry of Justice, Gareth Thomas MP · Department for Business and Trade, Heidi Alexander · Ministry of Justice, Mark Chesher · Addleshaw Goddard, Nigel Railton · Post Office Ltd, Rob Francis · Dentons, Simon Recaldin · Post Office View ↗
5 Nov 2024 David Enright · Howe & Co Solicitors, Dewi Lewis, Dr Neil Hudgell · Hudgell Solicitors, James Hartley · Freeths, Jill Donnison, Sir Alan Bates · Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance, The Rt. Hon. Sir Gary Hickinbottom PC · Post Office Overturned Convictions Independent Pecuniary Assessment Panel View ↗

Who gave evidence

16 witnesses
WitnessOrganisationSessions
Alan Watts · Partner Herbert Smith Freehills 1
Carl Creswell · Director of Post Office Policy Department for Business and Trade 1
David Enright · Partner Howe & Co Solicitors 1
Dewi Lewis 1
Dr Neil Hudgell · Director Hudgell Solicitors 1
Ed Lidington · Director, Courts, Criminal and Family Justice Dir… Ministry of Justice 1
Gareth Thomas MP · Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports Department for Business and Trade 1
Heidi Alexander · Minister of State Ministry of Justice 1
James Hartley · Partner Freeths 1
Jill Donnison 1
Mark Chesher · Partner Addleshaw Goddard 1
Nigel Railton · Chair Post Office Ltd 1
Rob Francis · Partner Dentons 1
Simon Recaldin · Remediations Unit Director Post Office 1
Sir Alan Bates · Founder Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance 1
The Rt. Hon. Sir Gary Hickinbottom PC · Chair Post Office Overturned Convictions Independent Pecuniary Assessment Panel 1

Correspondence

16 letters
DateDirectionTitle
15 Oct 2025 To cttee Letter from Minister for Small Business and Economic Transformation relating to…
23 Jul 2025 To cttee Letter from the Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports relating to t…
15 Jul 2025 To cttee Letter from the Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports relating to t…
8 Jul 2025 From cttee Letter to the Secretary of State relating to publication of the Post Office Hor…
12 Jun 2025 From cttee Letter to the Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports relating to imp…
6 May 2025 To cttee Letter from the Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports relating to a…
22 Apr 2025 To cttee Letter from the Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports relating to H…
10 Apr 2025 From cttee Letter to the Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports relating to Pos…
25 Feb 2025 To cttee Letter from the Post Office relating to the Committee's first report of session…
7 Jan 2025 To cttee Letter from Herbert Smith Freehills LLP relating to Post Office redress, 17 Dec…
7 Jan 2025 To cttee Letter from the Director of the Courts, Criminal and Family Justice Directorate…
7 Jan 2025 To cttee Letter from the Minister for Services, Small Business and Exports relating to a…
10 Dec 2024 To cttee Letter from the Remediation Unit Director at the Post Office relating to issues…
19 Nov 2024 To cttee Letter from the Interim Chair of the Post Office relating to the future of the …
30 Oct 2024 To cttee Letter from the Secretary of State relating to the launch of the Horizon Convic…
30 Oct 2024 To cttee Letter from the Secretary of State relating to Post Office Horizon compensation…