Source · Recommendations & oversight

National Audit Office

NAO value-for-money reports examining the economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of government spending. Recommendations are tracked against government responses and, where a PAC hearing followed, linked to the committee's own recommendations and Treasury Minute responses.

2,824 reports 2,175 recommendations 1,827 confirmed by NAO 61% implementation rate

Reports

2,824 matching reports · newest published first

Impact of funding reductions on fire and rescue services

Published 5 Nov 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

Fire and rescue authorities have managed funding reductions well. The Department for Communities and Local Government should, however, seek greater assurance that authorities are maintaining service standards and delivering value for money locally.

Automatic enrolment to workplace pensions

Published 4 Nov 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Work and Pensions

The Department for Work and Pensions has successfully introduced automatic enrolment to workplace pensions for large and medium-sized employers. Significant risks remain.

Investigation: the government’s funding of Kids Company

Published 29 Oct 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Cabinet Office

Kids Company, a children’s charity, received at least £46m of public funding. Officials raised concerns about the charity’s cash flow and financial sustainability at least 6 times between 2002 and 2015 but the charity never …

Major Projects Report 2015 and the Equipment Plan 2015 to 2025

Published 22 Oct 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Defence

The MoD’s Equipment Plan appears more stable than last year and progress has been maintained, but the Department will need to remain vigilant with regard to future cost increases.

The management of adult diabetes services in the NHS: progress review

Published 21 Oct 2015 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

Progress has been made to reduce the additional risk of death for people with diabetes. However, 22,000 are still estimated to be dying each year from diabetes related causes.

Confirmed impacts: Achieving value for money for the sale of government shares

Published 16 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy

This impacts case study shows how our review of the government’s sale of shares in Royal Mail led to the appointment of an expert panel that made recommendations about the whole system of Initial Public …

Confirmed impacts: Malaysian peer review highly praised

Published 16 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office

This impacts case study shows how our international work can help improve the independence and financial audit standards of other countries’ audit offices. It is one example of financial or non-financial benefits realised in 2014 …

Impacts from our work, 2014

Published 16 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

This interactive publication summarises examples of ways our work has led to financial and non-financial impacts.

Confirmed impacts: New UN resolution achieved with NAO support

Published 16 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

This impacts case study shows how our work helped give Supreme Audit Institutions a clear role in reporting on progress towards the international development goals. It is one example of financial or non-financial benefits realised …

Confirmed impacts: Improving the British Council’s financial management

Published 16 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office

This impacts case study shows how our identification of accounting errors kick-started a number of actions to improve financial management processes and training. It is one example of financial or non-financial benefits realised in 2014 …

Confirmed impacts: Helping Defra to better manage its facilities contract

Published 16 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs

This impacts case study shows how our investigation of a contract in which Defra appeared to have been overcharged gave greater impetus and legitimacy to Defra’s approach to negotiating a settlement. It is one example …

Confirmed impacts: Helping to improve strategic management of debt owed to government

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Cabinet Office · HM Treasury

This impacts case study shows how Cabinet Office and HM Treasury have actioned our recommendations through updated guidance and strategies, establishing consistent cross-government monitoring measures and creating the company ‘Debt Market Integrator’ to provide debt …

Confirmed impacts: Managing reductions in local authority government funding

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

This impacts case study shows how central government has responded to our identification of the need to have a better understanding of the implications on local service delivery when making funding decisions, and how local …

Confirmed impacts: Helping to ensure an effective strategic centre of government

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Cabinet Office · HM Treasury

This impacts case study shows how our demonstration of the need for a more effective, coherent and consistent approach to cross-government collaboration helped motivate action to strengthen the role and improve the effectiveness of the …

Confirmed impacts: Helping to improve accountability in the health system

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

This impacts case study shows how our frequent highlighting of the need for consistent and reliable data and clearer accountability has improved reporting and data assurance in the health system. It is one example of …

Confirmed impacts: Securing better progress on nuclear decommissioning

Published 15 Oct 2015 Other No recommendations indexed

Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy

This impacts case study shows how reports by NAO and PAC resulted in the Nucelar Decommissioning Authority terminating its existing management contract and announcing a new approach, expected to improve management and reduce costs. It …

Response and delivery evidence

2,175 recommendations tracked

Across the NAO recommendation corpus. Response, implementation and NAO confirmation are separate measures; the categories below overlap.

Status Recommendations Share
Implemented 1,320 61%
Accepted 1,718 79%
Partially accepted 200 9%
Work in progress 503 23%
Rejected 41 2%
Confirmed by NAO follow-up 1,827 84%
Methodology: status determined from departmental responses, Treasury Minute responses, PAC follow-up hearings, and NAO own progress tracking.

Departments named in NAO reports

Departments named in NAO reports · all years
Department of Health and Social Care (126 reports) HM Treasury (95 reports) Cabinet Office (88 reports) Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy (81 reports) Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (76 reports) HM Revenue and Customs (74 reports) Department for Work and Pensions (66 reports) Ministry of Defence (63 reports) Department for Education (63 reports) Department for Transport (62 reports) Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (56 reports) Devolved administrations (56 reports) Home Office (53 reports) Ministry of Justice (39 reports) Department for Culture, Media & Sport (30 reports)