Source · IMB Annual Report
Durham
AI-generated report summary HMP Durham, a Category B reception and resettlement prison, faced significant challenges in the reporting year ending October 2024. The prison, operating at 98.9% of its operational capacity with 974 prisoners, saw a concerning decline in safety, marked by substantial increases in self-harm (34%), assaults (52%), and use of force (76%). Overcrowding and a deteriorating estate were persistent issues, alongside critical failures in healthcare provision, an inconsistent regime, and poor engagement in education, leading to an overall reduction in prisoners feeling safe.
Year: 2024
Published: 10 Apr 2025
Type: Prison · Cat B
Population: 974
Recommendations: 11
Key concerns
Positive findings
Safety statistics
| Indicator | This year | Previous |
|---|---|---|
| Deaths in custody | 4 | 8 |
| Self-harm incidents | 798 | 596 |
| ACCT cases opened | 1,007 | 1,083 |
| Prisoner assaults | 409 | 263 |
| Assaults on staff | 108 | 77 |
| Use of force | 882 | 500 |
| Drug finds | 1,786 | 1,145 |
Positive findings
AI-generated summaryThe Board commended the chaplaincy team for excellent faith and pastoral support and noted increasing links with external employers. Refreshments were available in the visits' hall, and the early days in custody worker and family support worker were highlighted as a positive force. Additionally, the Samaritans' postvention was effectively implemented after deaths in custody, and clinical and non-clinical DART members were observed working collaboratively to reduce harm from illicit substances. Improvements were also noted in CSU and I wing not being placed in patrol state and in healthcare screening on arrival.
Key concerns
14% of arrivals in Durham did not receive their first night healthcare assessment.
Prisoners failing the scanner in reception are taken to the segregation unit (also known as the care and separation unit, or CSU) under the Secreted Items Policy (SIP). These prisoners have complained that they do not receive a first night induction. The Board considers that this process needs to be more robust.
Self-harm incidents have increased by 34%, from 596 last year to 798 this year.
The prison was a cluster death site (CDS) at the beginning of the reporting period, ceased to be so in January 2024, then became a CDS again in July.
The Board continues to monitor the completion of the assessment, care in custody and teamwork (ACCT) documents, which are used to support prisoners at risk of self-harm or suicide. This year, there were omissions in 78% of those monitored, in contrast to 63% last year.
The results of our prisoner survey found that 80% of prisoners who responded said they feel safe in Durham compared with 92% in the previous reporting year.
Combined prisoner-on-prisoner and prisoner-on-staff assaults increased year on year by 52%.
The number of use of force incidents has shown an increase of 76%, from 500 to 882 in the reporting year.
Finds of illicit items were 33% higher than in the previous reporting year and drug finds were 50.5% higher.
The preponderance of psychoactive substances, commonly called, ‘Spice’, along with prisoners manufacturing drugs using everyday items such as shower-gel and toothpaste, is of concern to the Board.
The prison continues to be overcrowded, and the internal fabric is unsatisfactory.
At the inaugural decency meeting in April 2024, the prison confirmed that it was not compliant with the HM Prisons and Probation Service (HMPPS) National Standard for Cleanliness and Physical Decency of Prisons (October 2020).
In the Board’s view, the Head of Residence’s monitoring of the CSU needs to improve
The attendance of a healthcare professional at good order or discipline (GOoD) reviews (where it is determined if a prisoner should remain segregated) needs to improve, in the Board’s view.
The prison needs to improve its delivery of key working, which is an important aspect of staff and prisoner relationships.
In the Board’s opinion, delivery of secondary health screening within seven days of admission needs to improve.
The prison has failed to identify and correct the root causes of the high ‘did not attend’ (DNA) figures for healthcare appointments.
Cooperation between the healthcare and operational regimes needs to improve.
Throughout the year, the mental health team has reported poor availability of meeting rooms on the wings for private one-to-one, as well as, group meetings.
There has been no significant improvement in time out of cell or structured on-wing activities, despite the publication of a new core day, which theoretically would give increased time out of cell. The prison itself was non-compliant by virtue of the fact that it did not sustainably deliver the new regimes.
In the Board’s view, there was a lack cohesion in educational provision throughout the year.
There was poor attendance of prisoners at education classes.
There was a lack of motivation of non-mandated remand prisoners to engage in education or work.
The Board is concerned about issues with the social visits’ booking phone line and, in particular, the problems with booking in children over the age of 10.
The number of unplanned releases since 1 November 2023 has increased year on year and in the reporting year HMP Durham had 1170 unplanned releases.
The Board is concerned about the poor availability of accommodation for prisoner when they are released.
What investment do you intend to make within a reasonable time scale to improve prison experience for disabled prisoners?
What investment does the Prison Service intend to make to replace temporary and failing boilers so that prisoners are guaranteed heat and hot water when required?
How will you ensure that prisoners are offered the minimum kit they are entitled to?
How will you ensure that staff fully understand the eligibility and process for clothing parcels to be handed in/delivered to the prison so that consistent guidance is given to prisoners?
Recommendations
Yet again, the Board has raised concerns about the levels of overcrowding and its impact on the dignity of prisoners. Yet again, we have received answers offering no hope of improvement. When will the Minister this issue actually resolve this issue?
Government response
It is regrettable that overcrowding continues to be a concern. This is not a simple issue and that is why on 12 July 2024, the Lord Chancellor announced a package of measures aimed at addressing prison capacity issues and preventing the collapse of the criminal justice system. Further, on 11 December 2024, we set out our long-term plan for prison capacity through the publication of the 10-year Prison Capacity Strategy. This sets out our plans to deliver 14,000 new prison places and create a resilient prison estate that includes the construction of four new prisons as well as expansion and refurbishment of the existing prison estate. Whilst this does not address the immediate crowding and cell sharing issues at HMP Durham, the strategy underlines our commitment to improving the overall estate and future direction.
Recommendation 2
Could the Minister let the Board know how many additional Tier 2 (CAS2) and Tier 3 (CAS3) bed spaces are planned for the northeast and Cumbria in 2025?
Government response
As mentioned in last year’s response, the Community Accommodation Services (CAS) Tier 2 service provides short-term accommodation for individuals on bail or Home Detention Curfew. The CAS Tier 2 provision in the North East region is at 88 bed spaces, with a further four bed spaces planned to be opened in 2025. There are currently no further expansion plans in the North East for 2025/2026. However, 55 of the 88 bed spaces were opened in 2024/25, which represents a 167% increase in North East CAS Tier 2 provision in the last twelve months. In neighbouring Cumbria, eight new CAS Tier 2 bed spaces were opened in March 2025 (previously there was no CAS Tier 2 provision in Cumbria). There are currently 110 beds overall in the North West CAS Tier 2 provision and will continue to expand into 2025/2026 by a further ten bed spaces.
CAS Tier 3 supports prison leavers who are at risk of being released from prison homeless and will be subject to probation supervision upon release. As the Board will be aware, the CAS Tier 3 contract in the North East Probation region is for 124 bed spaces. These are dispersed across the region and the contract ensures that 50% of these are for sole occupancy. Individuals will be offered up to twelve weeks of basic, temporary accommodation to provide a stable base on release. Cumbria’s CAS Tier 3 contract is for 285 bedspaces. There are currently thirty CAS Tier 3 beds provided within the Cumbria area of the North West region, which is proportionate to the remaining area. There are not currently any plans to further expand the CAS Tier 3 provision in these regions during 2025/2026.
CAS Tier 3 supports prison leavers who are at risk of being released from prison homeless and will be subject to probation supervision upon release. As the Board will be aware, the CAS Tier 3 contract in the North East Probation region is for 124 bed spaces. These are dispersed across the region and the contract ensures that 50% of these are for sole occupancy. Individuals will be offered up to twelve weeks of basic, temporary accommodation to provide a stable base on release. Cumbria’s CAS Tier 3 contract is for 285 bedspaces. There are currently thirty CAS Tier 3 beds provided within the Cumbria area of the North West region, which is proportionate to the remaining area. There are not currently any plans to further expand the CAS Tier 3 provision in these regions during 2025/2026.
Recommendation 3
Last year we asked, ‘What plans does the Prison Service have to improve the number of accessible cells for ageing or disabled prisoners?’ What investment do you intend to make within a reasonable time scale to improve prison experience for disabled prisoners?
Government response
HMPPS is investing £2.3 billion in prison buildings for the financial years 2024/2025 and 2025/2026, and £500 million over two years in prison and probation service maintenance to improve conditions across the estate. The aims and intentions of the 20,000 prison place programmes are to build a modern, efficient prison estate that is safe and productive to live and work in. This involves improving the physical design and structures of the sites to encompass the safety of all individuals.
In new prisons such as HMPs Five Wells, Fosse Way and Millsike, and in the expansion projects that use the new houseblock design, HMPPS has catered for a growing number of elderly and/or disabled prisoners by providing a larger number of accessible cells including low mobility cells, wheelchair accessible cells, and medical cells for a range of accessibility needs associated with older prisoners. Amenities have been designed to ensure that there is equality of access for all prisoners through their locations on ground floor levels, ensuring lifts are available and by building technology infrastructures that enable the use of hearing loops and other technology that can support access and care for elderly prisoners. Specific activity spaces will be provided that would enable older prisoners to engage in age-appropriate activities, and décor designed to aid a person’s wayfinding and accounts for needs around dementia and other cognitive impairments prevalent within the older prisoner cohort.
In new prisons such as HMPs Five Wells, Fosse Way and Millsike, and in the expansion projects that use the new houseblock design, HMPPS has catered for a growing number of elderly and/or disabled prisoners by providing a larger number of accessible cells including low mobility cells, wheelchair accessible cells, and medical cells for a range of accessibility needs associated with older prisoners. Amenities have been designed to ensure that there is equality of access for all prisoners through their locations on ground floor levels, ensuring lifts are available and by building technology infrastructures that enable the use of hearing loops and other technology that can support access and care for elderly prisoners. Specific activity spaces will be provided that would enable older prisoners to engage in age-appropriate activities, and décor designed to aid a person’s wayfinding and accounts for needs around dementia and other cognitive impairments prevalent within the older prisoner cohort.
Recommendation 4
What investment does the Prison Service intend to make to replace temporary and failing boilers so that prisoners are guaranteed heat and hot water when required?
Government response
Boiler replacements in A, B, C, D, and E wings were completed in April 2025. A bid has also been submitted for replacement boilers in the gymnasium and workshops and is currently awaiting confirmation of funding approval for the current financial year. The Board will appreciate there are budgetary pressures and whilst all requests from the establishment will be considered, demands for maintenance are much greater than the available funding. Therefore, once a bid for a project is received, HMPPS must prioritise works very carefully to make best use of that funding, focusing on risk to life and risk to capacity and decency.
Recommendation 5
The prison was, again, designated as a cluster death site in July. What urgent steps will the Prison Service take to prevent deaths in custody?
Government response
HMPPS provides individualised support through the case management process for people assessed as at risk of suicide and self-harm. This approach places a strong emphasis on identifying individual risks, triggers and protective factors and having effective care plans in place to record, address and mitigate risks. All new members of staff with prisoner contact receive training on suicide and self-harm prevention. All staff who undertake key roles relating to risk assessment and case management also receive specific training relating to these roles. HMPPS has created a quality assurance tool to help establishments understand how effectively they are using the case management process to support those at risk of self-harm or suicide. We continue to work with Samaritans to provide support in the period following a self-inflicted death to reduce the risk of further deaths and for the delivery of the Listener scheme, through which selected prisoners are trained to provide emotional support to their fellow prisoners. During 2023 Samaritans volunteers and Listeners offered emotional support to 2,675 prisoners and 55 staff following 43 incidents of self-inflicted deaths. Locally at HMP Durham, all PPO recommendations following a death in custody during the reporting year due to natural causes have been completed with assurance of compliance provided via the Prison Group Director safety team. No recommendations were made by the PPO following the self-inflicted deaths. Significant changes have been implemented at the prison to improve safety outcomes and prevent further deaths in custody. Reception opening hours have been extended to 22:00hrs, which is matched by the health providers. This has contributed to a significant decrease month on month in the number of prisoners not receiving a first night health screen. Figures for March 2025 show that only 2.6% of arrivals did not receive a health screen (2.1% excluding those refusing to undergo a screening). Assurance has been introduced on the completion of enhanced first night welfare checks, and the recent reprofiling exercise has increased the night staffing complement to bolster early days work. The Local Safety Strategy was launched in January 2025, aligned with the National Safety Strategy, which sets out strategic actions to support reductions in self-harm, violence and debt. An Early Days in Custody working group, chaired by the Deputy Governor, now drives and monitors progress across all elements of the first night and induction. This includes changes to reception processes to reduce the time prisoners spend there before locating to the First Night Centre; ensuring all Spectrum staff have access to the digital personal escort records and Suicide and Self-Harm (SASH) warning forms; Samaritans trained Listeners being available on first night in custody; putting in place a comprehensive second-day induction, and improvements to quality around defensible decisions made for prisoners arriving with SASH warning forms where an Assessment, Care in Custody and Teamwork (ACCT) document is not opened. A quality assurance process for ACCT documents has been implemented in line with national expectations and standards, enabling feedback and learning for case coordinators.
Recommendation 6
What are the Governor’s plans to reduce violence, self-harm and assaults in the prison?
Government response
HMPPS provides individualised support through the case management process for people assessed as at risk of suicide and self-harm. This approach places a strong emphasis on identifying individual risks, triggers and protective factors and having effective care plans in place to record, address and mitigate risks. All new members of staff with prisoner contact receive training on suicide and self-harm prevention. All staff who undertake key roles relating to risk assessment and case management also receive specific training relating to these roles. HMPPS has created a quality assurance tool to help establishments understand how effectively they are using the case management process to support those at risk of self-harm or suicide. We continue to work with Samaritans to provide support in the period following a self-inflicted death to reduce the risk of further deaths and for the delivery of the Listener scheme, through which selected prisoners are trained to provide emotional support to their fellow prisoners. During 2023 Samaritans volunteers and Listeners offered emotional support to 2,675 prisoners and 55 staff following 43 incidents of self-inflicted deaths. Locally at HMP Durham, all PPO recommendations following a death in custody during the reporting year due to natural causes have been completed with assurance of compliance provided via the Prison Group Director safety team. No recommendations were made by the PPO following the self-inflicted deaths. Significant changes have been implemented at the prison to improve safety outcomes and prevent further deaths in custody. Reception opening hours have been extended to 22:00hrs, which is matched by the health providers. This has contributed to a significant decrease month on month in the number of prisoners not receiving a first night health screen. Figures for March 2025 show that only 2.6% of arrivals did not receive a health screen (2.1% excluding those refusing to undergo a screening). Assurance has been introduced on the completion of enhanced first night welfare checks, and the recent reprofiling exercise has increased the night staffing complement to bolster early days work. The Local Safety Strategy was launched in January 2025, aligned with the National Safety Strategy, which sets out strategic actions to support reductions in self-harm, violence and debt. An Early Days in Custody working group, chaired by the Deputy Governor, now drives and monitors progress across all elements of the first night and induction. This includes changes to reception processes to reduce the time prisoners spend there before locating to the First Night Centre; ensuring all Spectrum staff have access to the digital personal escort records and Suicide and Self-Harm (SASH) warning forms; Samaritans trained Listeners being available on first night in custody; putting in place a comprehensive second-day induction, and improvements to quality around defensible decisions made for prisoners arriving with SASH warning forms where an Assessment, Care in Custody and Teamwork (ACCT) document is not opened. A quality assurance process for ACCT documents has been implemented in line with national expectations and standards, enabling feedback and learning for case coordinators.
Recommendation 7
How will you ensure that prisoners are offered the minimum kit they are entitled to?
Government response
We now have a monthly decency walk that all managers participate in to ensure standards are being met and, when not, we address the issue. Now a decency meeting is in place to ensure that we meet the minimum standards of providing the right kit and cell contents for all prisoners. Cell marshals will be introduced to ensure cells are clean and fit for purpose before a prisoner moves into the cell. The E wing custody manager (CM) will ensure that kit packs are in place for all new prisoners to ensure they receive the right clothing and bedding on their first night in custody. A new painting party is starting on E wing to bring the standard of cells up and ensure they are clean and decent.
Recommendation 8
How will you ensure the alignment of operational and healthcare regimes?
Recommendation 9
What does the Governor intend to do to make sure that the key worker scheme is meaningful to prisoners, with a guaranteed time investment for staff so that key working becomes high profile and relevant?
Recommendation 10
What does the Governor intend to do to secure a consistent and coherent approach to diversity across the prison?
Recommendation 11
How will you ensure that staff fully understand the eligibility and process for clothing parcels to be handed in/delivered to the prison so that consistent guidance is given to prisoners?
Applications to the IMB
| Category | Current | Previous |
|---|---|---|
| Accommodation (including transfers) | 45 | 38 |
| Chaplaincy | 0 | 0 |
| Discipline | 28 | 22 |
| Discrimination | 30 | 21 |
| Education | 8 | 13 |
| Food | 14 | 21 |
| General | 38 | 39 |
| Healthcare | 29 | 22 |
| IPP | 3 | 5 |
| Legal | 11 | 11 |
| Others | 153 | 94 |
| Parole/Release | 0 | 1 |
| Property | 44 | 61 |
| Regime | 43 | 47 |
| Safety | 27 | 16 |
| Staff conduct | 20 | 27 |
| TOTAL | 536 | 494 |
| Visits | 15 | 16 |
| Work/Pay/Employment | 9 | 13 |
Related inspections & investigations
Safety 2
· Respect 2
· Activity 1
· Release 3
Jamie Graham · Other non-natural
Robert Barry · Natural causes
Charlie Todd · State Custody related deaths | Suicide (from 2015)
Matthew Hamilton · Alcohol, drug and medication related deaths; State Custody related deaths
Derek Thomas · State Custody related deaths
Edward Devlin · State Custody related deaths
Other reports for Durham
Population 961
· Self-harm 461
· Concerns
Population 981
· Self-harm 596
· Concerns
Population 976
· Self-harm 486
· Concerns
Population 974
· Self-harm 589
· Concerns
· Self-harm 522
· Concerns