Source · Prevention of Future Deaths
Lewys Crawford
Ref: 2020-0046
Date: 28 Feb 2020
Coroner: Graeme Hughes
Area: South Wales Central
Responses identified: 0 / 1
View PDF
A&E consultants and agency nurses lacked adequate training in paediatric sepsis identification and management, including using risk stratification tools and appropriate terminology. Failures were noted in considering alternative antibiotic administration methods.
Date
28 Feb 2020
56-day deadline
26 Apr 2020
Responses identified
0 of 1
Coroner's concerns
A&E consultants and agency nurses lacked adequate training in paediatric sepsis identification and management, including using risk stratification tools and appropriate terminology. Failures were noted in considering alternative antibiotic administration methods.
View full coroner's concerns
(1) A potential deficiency in the knowledge and understanding of A & E Consultants covering in the paediatric A & E Department (whilst there is no on site consultant in paediatric emergency medicine) in the identification/diagnosis of sepsis in babies and very young children. Whilst it is appreciated that the quest to recruit further consultants in paediatric emergency medicine to provide more comprehensive cover in the Department continues, until such time as a sufficient complement is in place, and A & E Consultants provide some of the cover, the Health Board must ensure that those that do, are urgently and adequately trained to a competent standard to deliver the care required. It cannot be simply left to the individual consultants to determine their own requirements in this regard. As their employers, the Health Board, has an overarching obligation to ensure that competent staff are employed and to maintain high professional standards.
(2) There needs to be a greater understanding of, and reference to the NICE Sepsis risk stratification tool: children aged under 5 years in hospital by Clinicians and Nurses in both the A & E & Paediatric depts. Whilst it is appreciated that the finalisation of a bespoke sepsis tool, based upon the UK Sepsis Trust’s Tools and Pathways is awaited, until such time as its adopted, the Health Board needs to address apparent lapses in the understanding of what is required upon diagnosis of a potentially septic baby/child, particularly in the period between triage and admission to the ward. Specifically, the importance of stabilising the patient prior to transfer by completing a full septic screen. Furthermore, the Inquest highlighted gaps in the understanding and knowledge of agency nurses as to the septic screen and the steps to be followed. The Health Board needs a clear policy (and to ensure this is implemented & followed) to ensure that agency nurses are up to date with their training and understanding in this area of practice.
(3) Guidance and instruction to both clinicians and nurses as to the appropriate use (and recording) of terminology should be considered in suspected sepsis patients. There was a degree of confusion in both the A & E & Paediatric Departments caused by the interchangeable use of sepsis and bacterial infection as to what treatment should be initiated/progressed depending on which description was used. If sepsis is suspected, that clear and continuing reference ought to be maintained, if, and until it is superseded by an alternative diagnosis.
(4) In suspected sepsis patients, particularly babies, guidance and instruction needs to be emphasised to clinicians & nurses as to alternative methods of administration of antibiotics. Evidence at Inquest demonstrated that there were failures to consider alternatives to cannulation for IV antibiotics, such as intra-muscularly or intra-osseously.
(2) There needs to be a greater understanding of, and reference to the NICE Sepsis risk stratification tool: children aged under 5 years in hospital by Clinicians and Nurses in both the A & E & Paediatric depts. Whilst it is appreciated that the finalisation of a bespoke sepsis tool, based upon the UK Sepsis Trust’s Tools and Pathways is awaited, until such time as its adopted, the Health Board needs to address apparent lapses in the understanding of what is required upon diagnosis of a potentially septic baby/child, particularly in the period between triage and admission to the ward. Specifically, the importance of stabilising the patient prior to transfer by completing a full septic screen. Furthermore, the Inquest highlighted gaps in the understanding and knowledge of agency nurses as to the septic screen and the steps to be followed. The Health Board needs a clear policy (and to ensure this is implemented & followed) to ensure that agency nurses are up to date with their training and understanding in this area of practice.
(3) Guidance and instruction to both clinicians and nurses as to the appropriate use (and recording) of terminology should be considered in suspected sepsis patients. There was a degree of confusion in both the A & E & Paediatric Departments caused by the interchangeable use of sepsis and bacterial infection as to what treatment should be initiated/progressed depending on which description was used. If sepsis is suspected, that clear and continuing reference ought to be maintained, if, and until it is superseded by an alternative diagnosis.
(4) In suspected sepsis patients, particularly babies, guidance and instruction needs to be emphasised to clinicians & nurses as to alternative methods of administration of antibiotics. Evidence at Inquest demonstrated that there were failures to consider alternatives to cannulation for IV antibiotics, such as intra-muscularly or intra-osseously.
Report sections
Investigation and inquest
On 28th March 2019 I commenced an investigation into the death of Lewys Ryan Aidan CRAWFORD. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest 14th February 2020. The conclusion of the inquest was Natural causes contributed to by neglect - gross failure up to and including 11:30pm on 21/03/2019.
Cause of Death recorded as:-
1a. Meningococcal Septicaemia (Group B)
Cause of Death recorded as:-
1a. Meningococcal Septicaemia (Group B)
Circumstances of the death
These were recorded as :-
It is likely Lewys was in early stages of Meningococcal disease when he was admitted to A&E at University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff on 21/03/2019 at 08:15pm. There were multiple opportunities missed before 11:30pm to identify Lewys as having one or more high risk factors for Sepsis. There was a failure to treat Lewys with antibiotics before 11:30pm and this significantly contributed to Lewys' death on 22/03/2019 by which time he had been transferred to the Paediatric Critical Care Unit.
The Inquest focused upon numerous issues. However, at its core was the appropriateness, timeliness, and causative significance of the care provided to Lewys following his presentation to A & E. Particularly in the early stages of his treatment between triage and around 11.30pm on 21.3.19
It is likely Lewys was in early stages of Meningococcal disease when he was admitted to A&E at University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff on 21/03/2019 at 08:15pm. There were multiple opportunities missed before 11:30pm to identify Lewys as having one or more high risk factors for Sepsis. There was a failure to treat Lewys with antibiotics before 11:30pm and this significantly contributed to Lewys' death on 22/03/2019 by which time he had been transferred to the Paediatric Critical Care Unit.
The Inquest focused upon numerous issues. However, at its core was the appropriateness, timeliness, and causative significance of the care provided to Lewys following his presentation to A & E. Particularly in the early stages of his treatment between triage and around 11.30pm on 21.3.19
Similar PFD reports
Related inquiry recommendations
Infected Blood Inquiry
Thalassaemia Society Support
Infected Blood Inquiry
Haemophilia Centre Resources
Morecambe Bay Investigation
Establish partner Trust buddying arrangement
Bristol Heart Inquiry
Implement joint inter-professional courses in healthcare professional education and training
Bristol Heart Inquiry
Increase opportunities for multi-professional teams to learn and train together
Bristol Heart Inquiry
Create shadowing opportunities for managers and clinicians to understand roles
Bristol Heart Inquiry
Focus NHS leadership investment on joint, multi-professional training for all staff
Waterhouse Inquiry
Ensure foster carers receive continuing support and access to specialist services
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Training for IPC professionals engineers and clinicians
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
IPC role specifications and staffing levels
Report details
- Reference
- 2020-0046
- Date of report
- 28 February 2020
- Coroner
- Graeme Hughes
- Coroner area
- South Wales Central
Responses identified
Responses identified
0 of 1
1 response not yet linked
Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 26 Apr 2020.
Sent to
- Cardiff and Vale University Health Board