Select Committee · Public Accounts Committee

The condition of school buildings

Status: Closed Opened: 24 May 2023 Closed: 8 Mar 2024 2 recommendations 40 conclusions 1 report

In March 2022 the Public Accounts Committee reported on the risks to schools’ financial sustainability , including wide variations in the condition of individual schools and their funding. The school estate in England comprises some 22,000 schools, with the majority overseen by the responsible body in control of the school, usually the relevant local authority …

Clear

Reports

1 report
Title HC No. Published Items Response
Second Report - The condition of school buildings HC 78 19 Nov 2023 42 Responded

Recommendations & Conclusions

5 items
13 Conclusion Second Report - The condition of school… Acknowledged

DfE unable to report total number of temporary RAAC classrooms supplied to schools

We asked DfE about the temporary classrooms it was providing for schools unable to use some of their space because of RAAC. It told us that it had three central contracts in place to supply temporary classrooms, but in general they would initially be provided to schools where the presence …

Government response. The government states it is funding emergency capital works, including temporary buildings, and provides dedicated support to schools with confirmed RAAC to ensure face-to-face education. However, it does not provide the specific number of temporary classrooms supplied, which the committee …
HM Treasury
14 Conclusion Second Report - The condition of school… Acknowledged

DfE's central temporary classroom contracts proving ineffective for some responsible bodies

DfE explained that it hoped to use the central contracts to enable speedier delivery of temporary classrooms to all RAAC-affected schools who needed them, and to pay for them centrally—including for specialist equipment within the classroom where 17 September 2023 session, Qq 117, 140–141 18 September 2023 session, Qq 121, …

Government response. The government states it is funding emergency works, including temporary buildings, and has assigned caseworkers to support schools with bespoke plans. It highlights efforts to process requests quickly, ensure processes are not burdensome, and arrange urgent payments, implying improvements to …
HM Treasury
17 Conclusion Second Report - The condition of school… Acknowledged

DfE lacks specific figures on RAAC impact, hindering timely public transparency

We asked DfE some questions intended to shed light on the latest position with RAAC at the time of our evidence session on 11 September, such as the number of pupils who were unable to start the school year as normal, and the number of specialist surveys that were outstanding. …

Government response. The government agrees with the observation but commits only to writing to the Committee alongside the publication of the Treasury Minute, without specifying a strategy for regular public information on RAAC.
HM Treasury
18 Conclusion Second Report - The condition of school… Acknowledged

Number of RAAC-affected educational settings continues to increase across the estate

On 19 September, the Secretary of State issued an updated statement on RAAC. It detailed that: DfE had received questionnaire responses in relation to 98.6% of schools with blocks built in the target era; every school that was awaiting a specialist survey when the previous statement was made on 4 …

Government response. The government agrees with the observation but commits only to writing to the Committee alongside the publication of the Treasury Minute, without offering further specific updates or actions.
HM Treasury
31 Conclusion Second Report - The condition of school… Acknowledged

Funding constraints prevent rebuilding non-hazardous schools, despite better long-term value for money

We asked DfE about longer-term risks to value for money. It described a set of schools that pose no safety risks and can be maintained to a reasonable condition. However, when considering the work needed to keep these schools in good condition over a five- to ten- year timeframe, DfE …

Government response. The government agrees with the committee's observation and, while citing existing guidance and support for estate management, states it is considering how to further clarify roles and support responsible bodies to manage estates effectively for the long-term, with a target …
HM Treasury

Oral evidence sessions

1 session
Date Witnesses
13 Jul 2023 Jane Balderstone · Department for Education, Jane Cunliffe · Department for Education, Susan Acland-Hood · The Department for Education View ↗

Correspondence

2 letters
DateDirectionTitle
26 Feb 2024 Correspondence from Susan Acland-Hood, Permanent Secretary, Department for Educ…
19 Sep 2023 Correspondence from Susan Acland-Hood, Permanent Secretary, Department for Educ…