Recommendations & Conclusions
17 items
2
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
We are concerned that smart meters are not achieving the consumer benefits they are supposed to and are benefitting certain, often wealthier, consumers more than others. The Department’s most recent estimates of consumer energy savings are based on data from installations that took place between 2015 and 2018 (with consumption …
Read more
We are concerned that smart meters are not achieving the consumer benefits they are supposed to and are benefitting certain, often wealthier, consumers more than others. The Department’s most recent estimates of consumer energy savings are based on data from installations that took place between 2015 and 2018 (with consumption data up to 2019). These show energy reductions of 3.3% to 3.6% for electricity and 2.9% to 3.1% for gas. However, the Department needs more up- to-date data to be confident that smart meters are saving consumers money on their energy bills, as it anticipated. If consumers are older, male, on high incomes, or homeowners then they are more likely to have smart meters. Wealthier people are also more likely than less wealthy people to be able to purchase new replacement appliances (such as washing machines) if their smart meter suggests relatively high running costs of older appliances they may own. Previously, there special smart meter tariffs were available that offered lower prices, for example for off-peak consumption —owever, these have been withdrawn due to current conditions in the domestic energy market, thereby removing an incentive for smart meter installation. Recommendation 2: The Department should: • update its evidence base on the benefits consumers are actually receiving; and • carry out further assessment of how to maximise the benefits of the smart meter network for all consumers, particularly those groups currently less likely to have them to encourage them to apply for one. 6 Update on the rollout of smart meters
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and has published an independent evaluation in Summer 2023, which identified energy savings. They are also designing a new phase of program-wide evaluation and working on additional sources of evidence to supplement the existing data.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
3
Recommendation
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The Department has limited understanding of why smart meter coverage is lower in some areas—particularly London, rural and remote areas—compared to others. The extent of smart meter installation varies across Great Britain, from 5% in the Isles of Scilly to 69% in Chesterfield as at March 2023. Installation rates in …
Read more
The Department has limited understanding of why smart meter coverage is lower in some areas—particularly London, rural and remote areas—compared to others. The extent of smart meter installation varies across Great Britain, from 5% in the Isles of Scilly to 69% in Chesterfield as at March 2023. Installation rates in London are 43%, some way below the 57% being achieved across Great Britain. The Department thinks this is due to the challenges of installations in blocks of flats (where it is more difficult to place meters and in-home displays in sufficient proximity to each other), and also because installers cost more and are less available. Remote areas such as the Highlands and Islands of Scotland also have lower coverage, as do some rural areas such as the Cotswolds. The Department says that the Data and Communications Company, which operates the central communications and data platform for smart meters, is looking into options for the 0.75% of homes that sit outside its ‘wide area network’ coverage (known as “not-spots”) for smart metering. The Department referred to the ‘few hundred thousand’ homes in these areas as located in ‘not-spots’. However, we also note that some suburban areas such as the constituency of Richmond Park can have low coverage but have neither the characteristics of inner London nor rural or remote areas. Recommendation 3: The Department should set out in its Treasury Minute response how it will: a) increase its understanding of the reasons for variation in geographic coverage, and what it is doing to increase smart meter uptake in those areas that are lagging behind; b) set out how those households who are unable to install smart meters will be supported.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and will continue to publish annual geographic progress data (next in May 2024). They are also undertaking local activities with suppliers and local authorities to improve installation processes and are rolling out new communication technologies (dual band hubs, Alternative Home Area Network …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
4
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
Ofgem risks neglecting the importance of consumer engagement and behaviour change by focusing on penalising suppliers for missing targets. Energy suppliers have binding targets to install smart meters, which should be enforced by Ofgem, the energy regulator. However, energy consumers are not required to accept an offer of having smart …
Read more
Ofgem risks neglecting the importance of consumer engagement and behaviour change by focusing on penalising suppliers for missing targets. Energy suppliers have binding targets to install smart meters, which should be enforced by Ofgem, the energy regulator. However, energy consumers are not required to accept an offer of having smart meters installed and only one large supplier hit both its 2022 gas and electricity smart meter installation targets. Ofgem is in discussions with suppliers that did not meet their targets, and has previously used its enforcement powers to require an energy supplier to contribute more than £1m to a “redress fund”. It told us it is now considering more severe financial penalties than this. The Department and Ofgem are also in the process of reforming the energy retail market, to increase its resilience whilst enabling innovation that helps support achieving net zero. This may require Ofgem to adapt its regulatory approach, moving beyond merely considering performance against targets, to take account of suppliers’ investment in the innovation and consumer engagement that encourages consumer behaviour change in line with net zero. Recommendation 4: Ofgem should consider how its approach to regulating suppliers, on both the rollout and in relation to net zero more widely, takes account of the need for suppliers to engage their customers to promote behaviour change. Update on the rollout of smart meters 7
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees, stating that Ofgem already considers consumer detriment, priority, and Net Zero obligations in its enforcement processes. They also expect energy suppliers to engage customers effectively and that this is factored into Ofgem's consideration of supplier performance against targets.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
6
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The smart meters programme has been going for more than a decade and it is not clear how the Department takes important decisions relating to its future, including how it will decide when to bring the Programme to a close. The government first announced its intention to mandate suppliers to …
Read more
The smart meters programme has been going for more than a decade and it is not clear how the Department takes important decisions relating to its future, including how it will decide when to bring the Programme to a close. The government first announced its intention to mandate suppliers to install smart meters in 2008, and energy suppliers have been rolling out smart meters since
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and commits to sharing cost and benefit information for the smart metering rollout with Parliament annually. They have also defined the criteria for program closure and will share transition plans once matured.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
1
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
On the basis of a Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, we took evidence from the Department for Energy Security & Net Zero (the Department) and Ofgem on progress with the Smart Metering Implementation Programme (the Programme).1 We also took evidence from Energy UK, a senior analyst at the …
Read more
On the basis of a Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, we took evidence from the Department for Energy Security & Net Zero (the Department) and Ofgem on progress with the Smart Metering Implementation Programme (the Programme).1 We also took evidence from Energy UK, a senior analyst at the Climate Change Committee and Citizens Advice.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government describes existing efforts, stating that DESNZ has set Smart Energy GB statutory objectives for consumer engagement, and Smart Energy GB continuously evolves its multi-channel campaign strategy, focusing on different consumer segments and vulnerable circumstances to drive smart meter demand.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
7
Recommendation
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The Department told us that Ministers have a role in promoting the benefits of smart meters and the Programme to consumers.21 The responsibility for consumer engagement primarily rests with Smart Energy GB, a company funded by mandatory contributions from energy suppliers.22 However, the Department told us it plays a role …
Read more
The Department told us that Ministers have a role in promoting the benefits of smart meters and the Programme to consumers.21 The responsibility for consumer engagement primarily rests with Smart Energy GB, a company funded by mandatory contributions from energy suppliers.22 However, the Department told us it plays a role in the policy around convincing groups of people to have a smart meter installed, to help ensure installations progress across all energy consumer groups.23 EDF the energy company told us that there are clear opportunities for government departments to work more closely together to support the programme and for the policy environment around smart meters to be more favourable. These include, for example, requiring smart meters to be installed in new build homes, or in social housing, and incentivising smart meters as a credit for a property’s Energy Performance Certificate.24 Consumer benefits and their distribution among different groups
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the recommendation and states it has been implemented. It describes how DESNZ works closely with Smart Energy GB to evolve consumer engagement strategies and expects energy suppliers to innovate incentives to drive take-up, but does not specifically address the suggested policy …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
9
Recommendation
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
These energy reductions show a slight improvement on earlier estimates included in the Department’s 2019 cost benefit analysis.26 The Department told us it considers the expected percentage reduction in energy use is being maintained and that in a ‘much higher energy price world’, the actual monetary benefits will have significantly …
Read more
These energy reductions show a slight improvement on earlier estimates included in the Department’s 2019 cost benefit analysis.26 The Department told us it considers the expected percentage reduction in energy use is being maintained and that in a ‘much higher energy price world’, the actual monetary benefits will have significantly increased.27 However, the Department needs more up-to-date data to be confident that smart meters are saving consumers money on their energy bills, in line with its expectations.28 It does not plan a full evaluation, including assessment of the impacts on consumers, until the completion of the rollout.29
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the recommendation and sets a target implementation date of February 2025. It describes its ongoing data collection and evaluation programme, including recent published evidence on energy savings, and commits to designing a new phase of programme-wide evaluation and exploring additional data …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
10
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The Department told us that real-time data offered by a smart meter means that all types of consumer can benefit from having a smart meter installed, and that its early learning project identified that people with smart meters who were fuel-poor were benefiting similarly to people who were not.30 Smart …
Read more
The Department told us that real-time data offered by a smart meter means that all types of consumer can benefit from having a smart meter installed, and that its early learning project identified that people with smart meters who were fuel-poor were benefiting similarly to people who were not.30 Smart Energy GB has a duty to ensure consumers in vulnerable circumstances are not ‘left behind’ and conducts surveys to identify smart meter uptake by demographic characteristics.31 Its recent data show consumers that are older, on higher incomes, male, and homeowners are more likely to have smart meters. Consumers that are young, female, on low salaries, and private renters are less likely to have smart meters.32 Wealthier consumers are also more likely than others to be able to replace inefficient appliances (such as washing machines), for example if their smart meter 21 Q 65 22 C&AG’s Report, Figure 3 23 Q 65 24 URM0005 25 Q 98; C&AG’s Report, para 2.8 26 C&AG’s Report, para 2.10 27 Q 88 28 C&AG’s Report, para 17 29 C&AG’s Report, para 2.11 30 Qq 119–120 31 C&AG’s Report, para 1.13, Figure 8 32 C&AG’s Report, Figure 8 12 Update on the rollout of smart meters suggests an older washing machine has relatively high running costs.33 In correspondence to the Committee after the session, Smart Energy GB told us that it has a specific team focused on vulnerable consumers who also lead on working with a range of local and national partners who are trusted voices for vulnerable customer segments, including Carers UK.34 Smart meter coverage by geography
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the committee's observations on consumer benefits and uptake patterns, detailing its ongoing programme of data collection, monitoring, and evaluation of smart meter benefits, including for consumers experiencing barriers in the energy market, and plans for further evaluation.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
11
Recommendation
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
Smart meter coverage across Great Britain in 2023 varies by local authority from 5% in the Isles of Scilly to 69% in Chesterfield. Installation rates in London are only 43%, which the Department considered is due to the challenges of installing smart meters in a densely populated city, particularly in …
Read more
Smart meter coverage across Great Britain in 2023 varies by local authority from 5% in the Isles of Scilly to 69% in Chesterfield. Installation rates in London are only 43%, which the Department considered is due to the challenges of installing smart meters in a densely populated city, particularly in inner-London. The Department told us that technical issues have posed a problem when installing smart meters in blocks of flats (where it is more difficult to place meters and in-home displays in sufficient proximity to each other).35 The Department said progress has been made in resolving this issue and it was piloting a solution.36 However, the Department told us it was piloting this technology in only tens of properties (rather than tens of blocks of flats). It nevertheless expects that number to increase over time, subject to the outcome of the pilot, and particularly from the end of July.37 The Department also said that supplier recruitment of engineers in London is more difficult as installers cost more and are less available.38 Remote areas such as the Highlands and Islands of Scotland also have lower coverage, as do some rural areas such as the Cotswolds.39
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the recommendation and states it has been implemented. It outlines ongoing efforts to monitor geographic progress and share data annually, instigate local activities to improve installations in challenging areas, and deploy new technologies like dual band communications hubs to address technical …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
12
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The Committee noted that some suburban areas, including the constituency of Richmond Park situated to the south-west of London, can have low coverage but have neither the characteristics of inner London nor rural or remote areas. The Department acknowledged that at 40% installation coverage, Richmond Park was below average (although …
Read more
The Committee noted that some suburban areas, including the constituency of Richmond Park situated to the south-west of London, can have low coverage but have neither the characteristics of inner London nor rural or remote areas. The Department acknowledged that at 40% installation coverage, Richmond Park was below average (although it did not offer an explanation as to why this was the case).40 The Department said that in London more generally there is a much higher proportion of people in privately rented housing than in the rest of Great Britain. Tenants can be hesitant about having a smart meter installed because they are not sure they are allowed to. The Department’s understanding is that landlords are in support of having smart meters installed because accurate timely bills are less likely to lead to future problems.41
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the committee's observation on low smart meter coverage in certain suburban areas, explaining that it proactively monitors geographic distribution, collects and publishes data, and has instigated local activities and deployed new technologies to address installation challenges and improve coverage.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
13
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The Department told us that the Data and Communications Company, the central communications and data platform that provides the network ecosystem for smart meters, is looking into options for ‘not-spots’ which the Department considers applies to only 0.75% of homes.42 These ‘few hundred thousand homes’ sit outside the ‘wide area …
Read more
The Department told us that the Data and Communications Company, the central communications and data platform that provides the network ecosystem for smart meters, is looking into options for ‘not-spots’ which the Department considers applies to only 0.75% of homes.42 These ‘few hundred thousand homes’ sit outside the ‘wide area network’ of coverage across Great Britain for smart meters.43 The Department said that one solution the Data and Communications Company is considering involves piggybacking on a 33 Qq 113, 120 34 Correspondence submitted by CEO, Smart Energy GB dated 30 June 2023 35 Q 85; C&AG’s Report, para 1.8, Figure 7 36 Qq 58–59, 85 37 Q 59; C&AG’s Report, para 1.20 38 Qq 87–88; C&AG’s Report, para 1.8 39 Qq 57, 85; C&AG’s Report, para 1.8, Figure 7 40 Q 86 41 Q 87 42 Qq 57, 110 43 Q 57 Update on the rollout of smart meters 13 consumer’s home broadband service. However, the Department advised that this solution will take some time to develop, and is one of a number of solutions being considered.44 Regulatory approach
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the committee's observation regarding 'not-spots' and claims the recommendation is implemented, stating it proactively identified this for monitoring, publishes data, instigates local activities, and is deploying dual-band communications hubs and other technologies to improve coverage.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
14
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
Energy suppliers have binding targets to install smart meters, enforced by Ofgem, the energy regulator. However, energy consumers are not required to accept an offer of having smart meters installed. The Department told us that it chose a voluntary, demand- led approach to the smart meters rollout because it wanted …
Read more
Energy suppliers have binding targets to install smart meters, enforced by Ofgem, the energy regulator. However, energy consumers are not required to accept an offer of having smart meters installed. The Department told us that it chose a voluntary, demand- led approach to the smart meters rollout because it wanted to engage consumers in the way they use energy. It said that in countries that had chosen either a mandatory or semi- mandatory approach it had led to resistance and a lack of engagement with consumers.45 However, in 2022, only one large supplier hit both its gas and electricity smart meters installation targets. This large supplier had a less than one per cent share of total actual installations by all large suppliers.46 Energy UK told us that one supplier considered that in order to meet its targets it would need to convert all consumers who had previously said no to a smart meter.47
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the committee's observation and states it has already implemented measures through Smart Energy GB to build consumer demand and acceptance, evolving campaign strategies, and expects energy suppliers to invest in innovative incentives, claiming the recommendation is already implemented.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
15
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
Ofgem believes that the missed 2022 targets were nevertheless achievable, even for large suppliers with ‘lots of incumbent customers’.48 It considers the role it can play in suppliers meeting their installation targets is to provide a clear signal and an incentive to suppliers to invest appropriately and take meeting their …
Read more
Ofgem believes that the missed 2022 targets were nevertheless achievable, even for large suppliers with ‘lots of incumbent customers’.48 It considers the role it can play in suppliers meeting their installation targets is to provide a clear signal and an incentive to suppliers to invest appropriately and take meeting their targets seriously.49 It is now in discussions with the majority of those suppliers that did not meet their targets, and has previously used its enforcement powers for smart meters to require one energy supplier, OVO Energy, to contribute more than £1 million to a ‘redress fund’.50 It is considering more severe financial penalties, but does not want enforcement action to force or lead to supplier failures.51
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the committee's findings regarding Ofgem's approach to missed smart meter targets, reiterating Ofgem's existing enforcement guidelines and plans to continue its considered approach to non-compliance, and stating that the department already considers supplier engagement in target setting.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
16
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The Department and Ofgem are also in the process of introducing reforms to the energy retail market, in part to increase resilience and enable innovation. This reform comes at a time when new and innovative technologies are being developed, including those that contribute to or encourage consumer behaviour change in …
Read more
The Department and Ofgem are also in the process of introducing reforms to the energy retail market, in part to increase resilience and enable innovation. This reform comes at a time when new and innovative technologies are being developed, including those that contribute to or encourage consumer behaviour change in line with net zero.52 The Department highlighted that some innovative energy suppliers were able to offer tariffs, to consumers with smart meters, that could save up to two-thirds of the costs of charging their electric vehicles if they do so at certain times of day when the energy price is cheaper.53 Ofgem also told us about how, in winter 2022–23, the National Grid ran a demand response exercise with some smart meter consumers, by paying them to turn down their demand temporarily. In future this could be used to help manage demand at peak times.54 The Climate Change Committee analyst told us that smart meters broadly sit on the critical path to net zero and while delays in the rollout do not directly slow things down, the slower than expected progress ‘definitely does not make things easier’. It sees 44 Q 110 45 Q 76 46 C&AG’s Report, para 1.15, Figure 9 47 Q 17 48 Q 99 49 Q 69 50 Q 73; C&AG’s Report, para 1.17 51 Qq 3, 99 52 Q 112; C&AG’s Report, para 2.14; Ofgem, Ofgem launches new proposals to strengthen energy market and protect consumers, 25 November 2022 53 Qq 112–113 54 Q 97 14 Update on the rollout of smart meters smart meters as important in bringing consumers along—paving the way to educating consumers about their energy use, how energy is wasted and changes that are coming, including low carbon heating.55 55 Q 19 Update on the rollout of smart meters 15 2 Replacing non-functioning smart meters, and the future of the Programme Replacing non-functioning smart meters
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the committee's observation on market reforms and innovative smart meter technologies, outlining Smart Energy GB's statutory objectives and ongoing campaign strategy to build consumer demand and encourage behaviour change, alongside expectations for energy suppliers to develop innovative incentives.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
19
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
According to the Department and Energy UK, the third category included around 1.4 million meters that were working at the point of installation but had since lost communication.59 This includes first generation meters, known as SMETS1, that needed to be ‘enrolled’ (in effect, connected) to the central data and communication …
Read more
According to the Department and Energy UK, the third category included around 1.4 million meters that were working at the point of installation but had since lost communication.59 This includes first generation meters, known as SMETS1, that needed to be ‘enrolled’ (in effect, connected) to the central data and communication platform infrastructure to continue functioning when consumers switch suppliers. In June 2023, the Department told us it might not be possible to enrol 500,000 of these SMETS1 meters, in which case they might ultimately need to be replaced.60 Suppliers’ regulatory framework only requires them to take ‘all reasonable steps’ to replace non-functioning smart meters and doing so does not count towards their binding targets, which only cover new smart meters.61 Suppliers consider this leads them to prioritise installation of new smart meters over replacing non-functioning ones they have previously installed. The Department disagrees, suggesting the existence of a regulatory requirement for replacing a non-functioning meter means there is no practical incentive for suppliers to prioritise meeting their binding targets to install new smart meters over replacing non-functioning meters.62 However, Ofgem acknowledges that ‘all reasonable steps’ (to replace non- functioning meters) is a harder regime to enforce than a binding target to install meters.63 56 C&AG’s Report, Key facts, para 13 57 C&AG’s Report, para 23 58 Q 48 59 Q 48; Correspondence submitted by Head of Future Retail Markets, Energy UK, dated 6 July 2023 60 Q 48 61 Qq 15, 34 and 35 62 C&AG’s Report, para 1.16 63 Q 72 16 Update on the rollout of smart meters Energy UK told us that despite the differentiation between requirements suppliers have processes in place to address metering issues and getting meters working is critical to a positive consumer experience. There are also commercial incentives to want to keep meters working. When smart meters are not working the upfront cost of the meter, i
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the committee's observation on non-functioning smart meters, agreeing that suppliers should monitor and maintain their metering estate, and highlighting the department's ongoing work to develop good practice, track performance, and Ofgem's role in regulating existing licence conditions. It also mentions seeking agreement …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
21
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
The Department also estimates that 7 million communications hubs (a modular component of the smart meter set) will need to be replaced in the South and Central regions ahead of 2033, when 2G and 3G communications networks are closed. These will be replaced with an equivalent module which communicates using …
Read more
The Department also estimates that 7 million communications hubs (a modular component of the smart meter set) will need to be replaced in the South and Central regions ahead of 2033, when 2G and 3G communications networks are closed. These will be replaced with an equivalent module which communicates using the 4G network.67 The Department told us that it considers this replacement exercise will cost ‘about’ £2 for each household.68 However, Citizens Advice indicate these costs may be very significant and ultimately borne by consumers or taxpayers.69 The future of the Programme
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the committee's observation on 4G communications hub replacement, stating that suppliers have an existing obligation to prevent loss of connection, and that the government is already facilitating and supporting suppliers in developing their replacement plans, which will culminate in detailed plans by …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
25
Conclusion
Seventy-Second Report - Update on the r…
Accepted
As well as the approach to the rollout there are other significant issues for the Department to consider after 2025, including the re-licensing of the DCC (the central communications and data platform), and reform of the industry code governance. Ofgem has a key role to play in both of these.80 …
Read more
As well as the approach to the rollout there are other significant issues for the Department to consider after 2025, including the re-licensing of the DCC (the central communications and data platform), and reform of the industry code governance. Ofgem has a key role to play in both of these.80 The Department told us it still aspires to get as close to 100% smart meter coverage as possible, but only has a plan to 2025. It is developing a framework for after 2025 but does not know when it will be in a position to close the programme.81 75 Qq 106, 109 76 Qq 64 77 URM0014 78 Q 75 79 Qq 47, 75, 94–95 80 Q 109 81 Qq 106, 108–109 18 Update on the rollout of smart meters
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees to share matured plans for the smart metering programme's transition and closure with the Committee by Summer 2024, once major risks are managed and critical activities are transferred to an enduring operating state.
Read full response →
HM Treasury