Source · Select Committees · Home Affairs Committee

Fourth Report: Home Office preparedness for COVID-19 (Coronavirus): institutional accommodation

Home Affairs Committee HC 562 Published 28 July 2020
Report Status
Government responded
Conclusions & Recommendations
54 items (38 recs)
Government Response
AI assessment · 54 of 54 classified
Accepted 18
Accepted in Part 6
Acknowledged 8
Deferred 1
Not Addressed 14
Rejected 7
Government response
Fifth Special Report: Home Office preparedness for COVID-19 (coronavirus): institutional accommodation: Government Response to the Committee’s Fourth Report · published 13 Nov 2020
Read the government response ↗ Response on the Index
Filter by: Clear

Recommendations & Conclusions

14 items
2 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 29

We are deeply concerned that there was so little early access to testing for Covid-19...

Recommendation
We are deeply concerned that there was so little early access to testing for Covid-19 for asylum seekers housed in shared facilities, whether IA or dispersal, given the higher risk of spreading infection in accommodation where it is often difficult … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government's response is a truncated title and provides no substantive information regarding early access to Covid-19 testing for asylum seekers in shared facilities.
Home Office
View Details →
3 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 30

At this point in the response, testing is widely available: any symptomatic person can apply...

Conclusion
At this point in the response, testing is widely available: any symptomatic person can apply for a test, including a home test kit, and live translation services are now available in more than 200 languages including British Sign Language to … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government provided no substantive response to the committee's concern regarding the lack of readily accessible online guidance for local health managers on COVID-19 testing in asylum accommodation.
Home Office
View Details →
4 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 31

The Government must urgently publish a clear policy on residential testing if there are outbreaks.

Recommendation
The Government must urgently publish a clear policy on residential testing if there are outbreaks. This must be put in place immediately to ensure that accommodation providers are prepared for all potential scenarios in the next phase of the pandemic. Read more
Government Response Summary
The government provided no substantive response to the recommendation to urgently publish a clear policy on residential testing for outbreaks.
Home Office
View Details →
6 Recommendation Not Addressed

Vulnerable people such as pregnant women, victims of abuse and people with PTSD should never...

Recommendation
Vulnerable people such as pregnant women, victims of abuse and people with PTSD should never be placed in accommodation in which they have to share a room with an unrelated adult, nor should they be required to use shared bathroom/toilet … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response is a page reference and does not address the recommendation that vulnerable people should not be placed in shared accommodation or facilities.
Home Office
View Details →
7 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 45

We recognise that once the lockdown started in March it was more difficult to move...

Conclusion
We recognise that once the lockdown started in March it was more difficult to move people into alternative accommodation, both because of public health requirements and because of the increased demand overall for accommodation. However, that only makes resolution of … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response was a reference to another document and did not address the committee's conclusion regarding the pressing need for resolution of accommodation issues due to the potential for a second COVID-19 outbreak.
Home Office
View Details →
8 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 46

Our predecessor Committee recommended that shared accommodation should be phased out across the estate as...

Conclusion
Our predecessor Committee recommended that shared accommodation should be phased out across the estate as a whole. While we welcome the progress towards ending this practice, we are extremely disappointed that the Home Office did not take the opportunity of … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government provided no substantive response to the committee's concerns regarding the continued use of shared accommodation for unrelated adults in asylum dispersal contracts.
Home Office
View Details →
12 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 54

All Home Office contracted housing providers must ensure that any vulnerable adults are accommodated appropriately.

Recommendation
All Home Office contracted housing providers must ensure that any vulnerable adults are accommodated appropriately. Where the Home Office has explicitly authorised an individual to have a single room, this must be implemented without question or delay. To ensure that … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government outlined its expectations for contractors and existing measures for supporting vulnerable individuals during the pandemic, including the Migrant Help service, but did not commit to writing to the Committee within 4 weeks to detail provider accountability mechanisms for individual cases.
Home Office
View Details →
18 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 68

Following the National Audit Office’s report that asylum seekers are now expected to remain in...

Recommendation
Following the National Audit Office’s report that asylum seekers are now expected to remain in initial accommodation for up to five weeks, with many staying for nearly three months, the Home Office must urgently reconsider the provision of medical services, … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government acknowledges that extended stays in initial accommodation are not a long-term solution and they prioritize moving vulnerable service users. They are monitoring stays and inviting local authorities to collaborate on increasing dispersal accommodation, but do not commit to reconsidering medical services, subsistence payments, or children's educational support during the extended stays.
Home Office
View Details →
37 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 144

The Government said that it would review its policy of temporarily pausing all evictions from...

Conclusion
The Government said that it would review its policy of temporarily pausing all evictions from asylum accommodation and continuing the provision of asylum support before the end of June. In a Parliamentary debate on 17 June, a number of MPs … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government stated that following careful discussion and planning, cessations of support resumed in a phased approach starting in August, with those granted refugee status moving first, and cessations for refused claims to follow later.
Home Office
View Details →
39 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 155

We welcome the substantial reduction in the number of individuals detained in IRCs since the...

Conclusion
We welcome the substantial reduction in the number of individuals detained in IRCs since the beginning of the lockdown. This was a sensible response to Covid-19 and will have helped prevent infections.
Government Response Summary
The government response provides only a reference number and does not address the committee's observation or welcome regarding the reduction in individuals detained in IRCs.
Home Office
View Details →
41 Recommendation Not Addressed

It is troubling that nearly 40% of those remaining in immigration detention should have been...

Recommendation
It is troubling that nearly 40% of those remaining in immigration detention should have been categorised as meeting Levels 2 or 3 of the Adults at Risk policy indicating significant vulnerability and, potentially, that they are at high risk from … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government welcomes the committee's recognition and cites a High Court ruling endorsing its existing COVID-19 precautionary measures within immigration detention centres. It details various measures already in place to protect detainees, but explicitly states "no change" has been made to the Adults at Risk policy, thus not addressing the recommendation to seriously consider moving vulnerable individuals back into the community.
Home Office
View Details →
43 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 185

The Home Office and its providers must communicate timely and accurate information to NGOs as...

Recommendation
The Home Office and its providers must communicate timely and accurate information to NGOs as well as to service providers working to support people in immigration detention.
Government Response Summary
The government's response details measures taken in immigration detention regarding COVID-19, including detainee numbers and health precautions, but does not address the recommendation to communicate timely and accurate information to NGOs and service providers.
Home Office
View Details →
44 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 187

Some of the temporary measures introduced by the Government in response to Covid-19 hold open...

Recommendation
Some of the temporary measures introduced by the Government in response to Covid-19 hold open the prospect of future improvements in the operation of both the asylum and immigration removal processes. Among these, the decision to extend asylum support for … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government provides a generic response about its ongoing work during the pandemic to support people in asylum accommodation and immigration removal centres, but does not address the specific recommendation to make the extension of asylum support permanent.
Home Office
View Details →
54 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 207

As part of this Covid-19 strategy, the Home Office should publish the Public Health England...

Recommendation
As part of this Covid-19 strategy, the Home Office should publish the Public Health England guidance that it has taken to inform its decisions about ending the current 62 Home Office preparedness for COVID-19 (Coronavirus): institutional accommodation measures to support … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government rejects the premise of a single COVID-19 strategy across different institutional settings and refers to general availability of PHE guidance. It does not commit to publishing the *specific* guidance that informed its decisions for asylum seekers or provide detailed confirmation of PSED adherence for those decisions, offering only a general statement.
Home Office
View Details →