Recommendations & Conclusions
9 items
12
Recommendation
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
The Government has committed to respecting devolved competence where they are touched upon in this Bill. If this were to change, we expect the Committee and the House to be notified of the reasons for such a change in advance of a final vote on the Bill. One of the …
Read more
The Government has committed to respecting devolved competence where they are touched upon in this Bill. If this were to change, we expect the Committee and the House to be notified of the reasons for such a change in advance of a final vote on the Bill. One of the effects of the Bill would be to create further divergence between the rules for how elections are conducted in different parts of the UK. This is of concern as while some small differences can be accommodated and understood by the UK’s electorates, the increasing number of differences will add to the complexity and potentially to confusion for voters, electoral campaigners and electoral administrators. We are clear that this is not an issue caused by the UK Government alone. The four Governments of the UK should seek to develop a more coordinated approach to electoral policy and law.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government stated its commitment to working constructively and coordinating with devolved administrations, highlighting existing regular meetings and official engagement. It welcomed the Scottish and Welsh Governments' consideration of comparable legislation and committed to close collaboration on future proposals.
Read full response →
15
Recommendation
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
There appears to be potential for a contradiction in the drafting of Schedule 1 as the provisions setting out both the Voter Card and the Anonymous Voter Card leave open the possibility of a limited period of validity. However, the rules for the documents which can be accepted as forms …
Read more
There appears to be potential for a contradiction in the drafting of Schedule 1 as the provisions setting out both the Voter Card and the Anonymous Voter Card leave open the possibility of a limited period of validity. However, the rules for the documents which can be accepted as forms of identification at a polling station state that such identification will be accepted “regardless of expiry date”. If this is a drafting error the Bill should be amended. If this is not a drafting error, a clearer 66 The Elections Bill explanation needs to be provided as to how a period of validity could work for a Voter Card if an expiry date is not a bar to it being used for its sole purpose at a polling station.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government clarified that expired documents remain valid if the photo is a good likeness, and that Voter Cards will not have an expiry date except for temporary ones. The Bill was amended to give EROs flexibility for issuing temporary Voter Cards valid for a …
Read full response →
16
Conclusion
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
The process of carrying out elections in the UK, the ease with which members of the electorate can cast their vote, and the trust that is shown in and by the electorate in general is an admirable and crucial tenet of our democratic process. These arrangements should be cherished and …
Read more
The process of carrying out elections in the UK, the ease with which members of the electorate can cast their vote, and the trust that is shown in and by the electorate in general is an admirable and crucial tenet of our democratic process. These arrangements should be cherished and protected, and great care must be taken whenever consideration is given to altering them. Introducing a compulsory voter ID requirement risks upsetting the balance of our current electoral system, making it more difficult to vote and removing an element of the trust inherent in the current system.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it has given due regard to its Public Sector Equality Duty, conducted an impact assessment, and designed its voter identification policy with accessibility in mind, including a wide range of accepted IDs and free Voter Cards, to mitigate the risks raised by …
Read full response →
20
Recommendation
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
We are pleased to see that the Government has included a monitoring and reporting requirement for voter ID in the Bill. We recommend that close attention is given not only to the number of people who arrive without appropriate ID, but also the demographics of these people. In addition to …
Read more
We are pleased to see that the Government has included a monitoring and reporting requirement for voter ID in the Bill. We recommend that close attention is given not only to the number of people who arrive without appropriate ID, but also the demographics of these people. In addition to this, the Committee recommends that parallel research is carried out to assess the number of people who are deterred from even attending a polling station due to the voter ID requirement. This will enable the wider impact on voter participation to be understood and assessed.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government accepts the recommendation, committing to carry out thorough research to assess the implementation and impacts of the voter identification policy, stating it will not be limited solely to mandated data collection.
Read full response →
25
Recommendation
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
The Government’s reasons for making these changes to the laws on postal voting appear valid and justified to the Committee. The Committee recommends that the Government sets out regulations to the effect that local authorities must notify people in advance of the expiry of a postal vote to ensure that …
Read more
The Government’s reasons for making these changes to the laws on postal voting appear valid and justified to the Committee. The Committee recommends that the Government sets out regulations to the effect that local authorities must notify people in advance of the expiry of a postal vote to ensure that they do not accidentally find themselves unable to vote at an election.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government accepted the recommendation, stating that Electoral Registration Officers will be required to notify electors of their postal vote expiry date and how to reapply, with similar provisions intended for new applicants via regulations.
Read full response →
30
Conclusion
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
The Committee reiterates the importance in upholding the actual and/or perceived independence of the regulator and considers that effective scrutiny of the Electoral Commission’s work by the UK’s Parliaments is essential to ensuring the Commission is held to account in the discharge of its statutory duties. A regulatory framework which …
Read more
The Committee reiterates the importance in upholding the actual and/or perceived independence of the regulator and considers that effective scrutiny of the Electoral Commission’s work by the UK’s Parliaments is essential to ensuring the Commission is held to account in the discharge of its statutory duties. A regulatory framework which achieves this balance is crucial for upholding public confidence in the regulator and in electoral outcomes.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees on the importance of parliamentary scrutiny and the Electoral Commission's independence, stating that existing ministerial statements and the Elections Bill's section 4B(2) already ensure the Commission considers the Strategy and Policy Statement while maintaining operational independence.
Read full response →
32
Recommendation
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
The Committee considers that the proposed consultation procedures require further clarification to ensure a transparent and meaningful consultation process.
Government response AI summary
The government explains that the consultation mechanism for the Strategy and Policy Statement is already detailed in sections 4C, 4D, and 4E of PPERA, specifying consultees, review frequency, and revision procedures, thereby providing the requested clarification.
Read full response →
35
Recommendation
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
At a minimum, under the affirmative procedure, the Government should set a precedent for any future governments by committing to find time for a debate on the Floor of the House of the Statement once laid in draft for approval.
Government response AI summary
The Government committed to ensuring that parliamentary time is made available for debates in both Houses of Parliament to scrutinise the Strategy and Policy Statement under the affirmative resolution procedure.
Read full response →
49
Recommendation
Fifth Report - The Elections Bill
Accepted
Acknowledging the need for legislation to keep pace with rapid technological changes, the Government should commit to monitoring and conducting regular reviews of the digital imprints scheme, to ensure effectiveness in the monitoring and enforcement of the legislation and to prevent any unintended consequences or loopholes. (Paragraph 224) Simple majority …
Read more
Acknowledging the need for legislation to keep pace with rapid technological changes, the Government should commit to monitoring and conducting regular reviews of the digital imprints scheme, to ensure effectiveness in the monitoring and enforcement of the legislation and to prevent any unintended consequences or loopholes. (Paragraph 224) Simple majority system to be used in elections for certain offices
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government committed to monitoring the impact of digital imprints and conducting a formal evaluation as part of the wider Bill evaluation process. It also noted existing regulation-making powers to adapt the regime to technological changes.
Read full response →