Select Committee · Environmental Audit Committee

Water Quality in Rivers

Status: Closed Opened: 8 Dec 2020 Closed: 22 Oct 2023 51 recommendations 31 conclusions 1 report

The Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) is holding an inquiry into water quality in rivers. The EAC has previously inquired into nitrate pollution so this inquiry intends to focus on the water industry and urban diffuse pollution. For more information about this inquiry read the call for evidence . Read the interactive summary of the report … Show more

Clear

Reports

1 report
Title HC No. Published Items Response
Fourth Report - Water quality in rivers HC 74 13 Jan 2022 82 Responded

Recommendations & Conclusions

3 items
19 Recommendation Fourth Report - Water quality in rivers Rejected

We recommend that the Environment Agency work with DEFRA to intensify its work in the...

We recommend that the Environment Agency work with DEFRA to intensify its work in the inspection and, where necessary, remediation of large animal slurry stores. Where remediation is required, funding from the Slurry Investment Fund should be made available to support the work. Read more

Government response AI summary
The government does not accept the recommendation, and states that the Environment Act requires notification of spills occurring within 1 hour of the discharge and continuous monitoring of the environment.
Read full response →
37 Conclusion Fourth Report - Water quality in rivers Rejected

We have identified multiple potential points of failure in the regulatory arrangements for monitoring, governance...

We have identified multiple potential points of failure in the regulatory arrangements for monitoring, governance and enforcement of water quality. The Southern Water case has given rise to obvious and urgent questions about the system of operator self- monitoring and Environment Agency compliance monitoring. Given the duration of time when … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government does not agree that permitting is an appropriate response for highway drains, stating it would add an unjustified regulatory and resource burden, but will keep the need for different approaches under review.
Read full response →
60 Recommendation Fourth Report - Water quality in rivers Rejected

We are disappointed by the apparent lack of regulatory oversight of the risks of water...

We are disappointed by the apparent lack of regulatory oversight of the risks of water pollution from road run-off. We therefore recommend that the Environment Agency require discharge permits for all outfalls on roads with annual average daily traffic above 15,000 vehicles, establishing strict conditions for their management, so as … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government does not agree that permitting is normally an appropriate risk management response for highway drains and that it would add a regulatory and resource burden which is not justified.
Read full response →

Oral evidence sessions

6 sessions
Date Witnesses
13 Oct 2021 Heidi Mottram CBE · Northumbrian Water, Ian McAulay · Southern Water, Liv Garfield · Severn Trent Water, Sarah Bentley · Thames Water, Susan Davy · South West Water View ↗
15 Sep 2021 Kirstin Green · Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Rebecca Pow · Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Richard Bramley · National Farmers Union (NFU), Simon Gallagher · Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, Susan Twining · CLA (Country Land and Business Association) View ↗
23 Jun 2021 David Black · Ofwat, Nick Harris · National Highways, Sir James Bevan · Environment Agency View ↗
26 May 2021 Alastair Chisholm · Chartered Institution of Water and Environmental Management, Bronwyn Buntine · Kent Council, Daniel Johns · Anglian Water Services Ltd, Ian Titherington · Cardiff Council, Jo Bradley · Stormwater Shepherds, Lila Thompson · British Water View ↗
21 Apr 2021 Feargal Sharkey · Amwell Magna Fishery, Jane Nickerson · Swim England, Mr Ben Seal · British Canoeing, Pete Lloyd · Environment Agency, Professor Peter Hammond · University College London (UCL), Professor Rebecca Malby · Ilkley Clean River Group View ↗
10 Mar 2021 Amy Slack · Surfers against Sewage, Dr Michelle Jackson · Oxford University, Dr Rob Collins · The Rivers Trust, Guy Linley-Adams · Salmon and Trout Conservation, Professor Nigel Watson · Lancaster University, Professor Steve Ormerod · Cardiff University View ↗

Who gave evidence

31 witnesses
WitnessOrganisationSessions
Alastair Chisholm · Director of Policy Chartered Institution of Water and Environmental Management 1
Amy Slack · Head of Campaigns & Policy Surfers against Sewage 1
Bronwyn Buntine · Sustainable Drainage Team Leader Kent Council 1
Daniel Johns · Head of Public Affairs Anglian Water Services Ltd 1
David Black · Chief Executive Ofwat 1
Dr Michelle Jackson · Associate Professor of freshwater/marine ecology,… Oxford University 1
Dr Rob Collins · Head of Policy and Science The Rivers Trust 1
Feargal Sharkey · Chairman Amwell Magna Fishery 1
Guy Linley-Adams · Solicitor Salmon and Trout Conservation 1
Heidi Mottram CBE · Chief Executive Northumbrian Water 1
Ian McAulay · Chief Executive Southern Water 1
Ian Titherington · Lead drainage officer Cardiff Council 1
Jane Nickerson · Chief Executive Swim England 1
Jo Bradley · Director of Operations UK Stormwater Shepherds 1
Kirstin Green · Deputy Director, Water Quality Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs 1
Lila Thompson · Chief Executive British Water 1
Liv Garfield · Chief Executive Severn Trent Water 1
Mr Ben Seal · Places to Paddle Manager British Canoeing 1
Nick Harris · Chief Executive National Highways 1
Pete Lloyd · Retired water quality expert Environment Agency 1
Professor Nigel Watson · Professor of Geography and Environmental Manageme… Lancaster University 1
Professor Peter Hammond · (retired) Professor of Computational Biology University College London (UCL) 1
Professor Rebecca Malby · Co-founder Ilkley Clean River Group 1
Professor Steve Ormerod · Professor of Ecology/Co-Director Water Research I… Cardiff University 1
Rebecca Pow · Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Minister … Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs 1
Richard Bramley · Environment Forum Chair National Farmers Union (NFU) 1
Sarah Bentley · Chief Executive Thames Water 1
Simon Gallagher · Planning Director Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government 1
Sir James Bevan · Chief Executive Environment Agency 1
Susan Davy · Chief Executive South West Water 1
Susan Twining · Chief Land Use Policy Adviser CLA (Country Land and Business Association) 1

Correspondence

15 letters
DateDirectionTitle
23 Oct 2023 To cttee Letter from the Chief Executive of Ofwat regarding their Water Company Performa…
22 Sep 2022 To cttee Letter from the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, rel…
6 Jan 2022 To cttee Letter from the Leader of Chichester District Council, relating to the Water Qu…
6 Jan 2022 To cttee Letter from National Highways, relating to the Water Quality in Rivers inquiry,…
25 Nov 2021 To cttee Letter from the Interim Chief Executive of Ofwat, relating to the Water quality…
25 Nov 2021 To cttee Letter from the Wastewater Director of Northumbrian Water Limited, relating to …
4 Nov 2021 To cttee Letter from the Northumbrian Water Chief Executive, relating to the 13 October …
4 Nov 2021 To cttee Letter from the Severn Trent Plc Chief Executive, relating to the 13 October Wa…
26 Oct 2021 To cttee Letter from the Chair to the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural…
14 Oct 2021 To cttee Letter from the Leader of Herefordshire Council, concerning water quality in ri…
16 Sep 2021 To cttee Letter from the Minister of State for Housing, relating to the Water quality in…
9 Sep 2021 To cttee Letter from the Environment Agency Chief Executive, relating to the Water quali…
9 Sep 2021 To cttee Letter from the Acting CEO of Highways England, relating to the Water quality i…
9 Sep 2021 To cttee Letter from the Interim Chief Executive of Ofwat, relating to the Water quality…
21 Jul 2021 To cttee Letter from the Acting CEO of Highways England, relating to the Water quality i…