Key concerns 18 items
Key concerns were extracted from the report text by an AI model.
Key concern 1
Estate/Conditions · Repeated from a previous year
The totally unsatisfactory conditions in the Care and Separation Unit (CSU) have not changed since the last Board report, and the plan to build a new CSU has been approved but funding has not yet been secured.
Key concern 2
Safety
The dated construction and fabric of the prison’s buildings make it intrinsically unsafe, having already contributed to one major incident (B wing riot).
Key concern 3
Safety
HMP/YOI Winchester has one of the highest rates of prisoner-on-prisoner assault, and assaults on staff, despite some reductions, are still high.
Key concern 4
Equality/Diversity · Repeated from a previous year
Prisoners with physical disabilities are still disadvantaged because they cannot always gain access to facilities. Although the situation has improved, sometimes they are still lodged on landings above ground level, meaning that they cannot easily access exercise yards, serveries or even showers if those on their landing are out of action. Reception and main first floor education classrooms are still inaccessible to those with mobility problems because there are no lifts. Only one cell door on the main wings is wide enough to allow wheelchair entry. In some cases, disabled prisoners have to be helped by staff or fellow prisoners to shower, receive food, enter their cells and get into bed. This is unacceptable.
Key concern 5
Estate/Conditions · Repeated from a previous year
Despite the best efforts of the motivated staff who run the unit, the CSU has no place in the 21st century management of prisoners. It is dungeon-like and not conducive to the care and rehabilitation of the prison’s most challenging prisoners. The Board stated in last year’s annual report that, ‘the building of a new CSU has been agreed and it is anticipated that this should begin in late 2019’. Regrettably, this has not happened and we understand that funds for this project have not been approved for the year 2020/21; this, despite the then Minister of Justice stating in writing, in response to our last year’s report, that she envisaged work starting on-site in May 2020. This repeated delay is outrageous and shameful, permanently causing major operational and safety difficulties for the Governor and staff, which have multiplied with the extra pressure of COVID-19 restrictions. The failure to deliver this is a clear dereliction of duty of the Department of Justice’s obligation to ensure the care and wellbeing of the prisoners committed to its care.
Key concern 6
Healthcare
Making sufficient escorts and runners reliably available remains a considerable challenge, causing medical provision to be 'hit-and-miss' and contributing to high 'did not attend' (DNA) rates for appointments.
Key concern 7
Healthcare
The lack of decent and appropriately located clinical space creates a barrier to providing high-quality and safe clinical care.
Key concern 8
Resettlement/Release
There are still instances of prisoners being released from prison onto the street with nowhere to go.
Key concern 9
Equality/Diversity
One vulnerable prisoner, an immigration detainee, has been held in the CSU for a considerable period. His short sentence for a non-violent crime has been served and he is now held on an IS91. Since March 2019, he has served 395 days in prison, 330 of them in the CSU. A complex individual, reluctant to engage, who has assaulted staff when moved to a prison wing, he prefers being in the CSU as this is where he feels the safest. Prison mental health services believe that he has suffered previous trauma and may be suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder. This individual has no documents and cannot or will not take part in the asylum process. A 35-page application for asylum has recently been sent to him, but it is in English, a language he can barely speak, with no legal representation to assist. Moreover, if he continues to refuse to cooperate, the Home Office has stated that he will be refused asylum on the grounds of non-compliance. He has no address in the community, so cannot be released. The efficient and caring CSU prison officers do their very best to encourage his progress, but this is not a situation of the prison’s making, or in its control. The Board highlights the lengthy incarceration of this prisoner in the most unpleasant conditions in the prison, even though by his own choice, and asks the Home Office, which is responsible for this issue, to resolve it.
Key concern 10
Safety
Vulnerable prisoners (those convicted of sexual offences, under threat of violence or bullying, and those finding prison life particularly difficult to cope with) are housed on A wing. Their work, education and exercise take place separately from other prisoners. Their outdoor facilities are overlooked by the general population in B and C wings, who sometimes threaten and verbally abuse them and have apparently poured urine onto the yard. As a result, a significant number of vulnerable prisoners refuse to take outside exercise, which affects their mental and physical health.
Key concern 11
Safety
The Emergency Cell Bell (ECB) system remains prone to abuse by prisoners, and a number of calls were not answered for over 30 minutes, with some response times alarmingly high.
Key concern 12
Substance Misuse
Drugs entering the prison are still a major problem, with reports of increased cannabis use, drug parcels thrown over walls, and letters soaked in new psychoactive substances.
Key concern 13
Overcrowding
Many of the cells designed for single occupancy contain two prisoners, leading to cramped conditions, lack of privacy for ablutions, and insufficient room for two chairs.
Key concern 14
Estate/Conditions
Furniture within cells is a constant problem due to regular vandalism, leading to frequent replacement needs and shortages of essential items like televisions, kettles, and pillows.
Key concern 15
Mental Health
This unpleasant environment has an impact on prisoners housed on the unit over long periods, sometimes for more than 50 days at a stretch, and they often appear listless. There are increasing incidents of prisoners who refuse to engage with the Board even turning hostile because they see it as ineffectual in remediating their poor conditions; a perception that is sadly all too accurate.
Key concern 16
Staffing
Administrative recruitment and retention are difficult; the Board is regularly told that such resource is insufficient to provide the agreed range of clerking support. The prison is competing for staff with the county council, with offices nearby. The council pays considerably more for similar roles and offers better conditions. A market force supplement is needed to boost the prison’s chances of full administrative resourcing.
Key concern 17
Regime/Time Out of Cell
Staff are often reluctant to place prisoners on report, as some adjudication awards do not reflect the seriousness of the offence, compounded by inconsistent enforcement of the Incentives and Earned Privileges (IEP) system.
Key concern 18
Healthcare
The security of medicines remains a concern, following the ease with which prisoners accessed drugs from a wing dispensary during a cell break.