Source · Prevention of Future Deaths

Sufia Begum

Date: 19 Sep 2018 Coroner: Louise Hunt Area: Birmingham and Solihull Responses identified: 2 / 2 View PDF

Many doctors are unaware of the BNF mobile app, a crucial tool for identifying potential drug interactions, risking preventable deaths from unknown medication interactions.

Date 19 Sep 2018
56-day deadline 14 Nov 2018 est.
Responses identified 2 of 2
Community health care and emergency services related deaths

Coroner's concerns

AI summary
Many doctors are unaware of the BNF mobile app, a crucial tool for identifying potential drug interactions, risking preventable deaths from unknown medication interactions.
View full coroner's concerns
During the course of the inquest the evidence revealed matters giving rise to concern. In my opinion  there is a risk that future deaths will occur unless action is taken. 1. I heard evidence at the inquest that the most useful tool to identify potential drug interactions  was the BNF mobile device APP. The author of the RCA confirmed that not all doctors were  aware of the APP. An alert to all NHS Trusts and GPs would provide this valuable information  which may prevent a future death from an unknown drug interaction.

Responses

2 respondents
Sufia Begum Response2
19 Sep 2018 PDF
Action Planned

• Sandwell and West Birmingham CCG confirmed that awareness will be raised among all local GPs about the existence of the BNF App by 31 December 2018. (AI summary)

View full response
Dear Ms Hunt Re: Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths – Sufia Begum Thank you for your Regulation 28 Report (“Report”) dated 19/09/2018 concerning the death of Sufia Begum on 24/04/2018. Firstly, I would like to express my deep condolences to Ms Begum’s family. Your Report concludes Sufia Begum’s death was a result of an unrecognised drug reaction. Following the inquest you raised concerns in your Report to NHS England and the Clinical Commissioning Group (“CCG”) regarding unrecognised drug reactions and that not all doctors may be aware of the British National Formulary (“BNF”) mobile device application (“APP”) in identifying potential drug interactions. You stated that an alert about this APP should be sent to all NHS Trusts and General practitioners (“GPs”) to assist in preventing future deaths from unknown drug interactions. The present position is that all hospital doctors have access to the BNF tool via an electronic prescribing system which will alert prescribers to potential serious drug interactions. All GPs and hospital doctors therefore have access to the online BNF and/or app, however not all may be aware of it. In addition, GPs also have access to alert systems which alerts prescribers to potential reactions when prescribing any drug to a patient. In hospitals, such electronic prescribing is not yet universally available. Some clinicians continue to utilise the hardcopy paper version of the BNF. Both GPs and hospital consultants do have access to pharmacy expertise to support prescribing concerns. Therefore, there are mechanisms to protect patients but these did not function sufficiently to protect Ms Begum. High quality care for all, now and for future generations

[Page 2] The following actions will therefore be taken to reduce the risk of reoccurrence and to protect other patients going forwards.
1. Sandwell and West Birmingham CCG have confirmed that awareness will be raised to all local GPs by December 31st 2018, about the existence of the APP for use when checking drug interactions via the CCG Protected Learning Time (“PLT”) events, CCG Clinical Chair’s communications, and existing clinical leadership groups that includes membership across the CCG footprint.
2. NHS England will ensure the details of this case are anonymised and distributed across all GPs in the West Midlands via its regular appraisal newsletter.
3. NHS England has already distributed learning across all CCGs and Providers in the West Midlands via shared learning at the West Midlands Mortality group meeting held on 16th October 2018.
4. Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust confirm the following actions have either occurred or are due to occur:
1) The case was reviewed in pharmacy in September 2018 and lessons learnt from this was shared
2) Trust wide communication in October 2018 has occurred about the use of the BNF mobile app for checking drug interactions. This went to all staff who prescribe or administer medication
3) Trust wide email to all trainees from the Clinical Tutor in October 2018 about the incident, lessons learnt, encouraging use of mobile BNF app for checking interactions, the situations to be particularly careful in and the importance of co-working with pharmacists
4) Trust wide email to all Consultants and middle grade staff in October 2018 to emphasise drug interaction safety checks and encourage use of the BNF app.
5) Other actions from the SI report due over the next 4 months:
a. Medical Director to audit the use of the app amongst trainees in December 2018 to confirm its continued use and confirm that communication has got to non-medical prescribers as well.
b. Trust Alert to all staff via the “Microguide” system (an electronic portal which hosts guidance) regarding potential interactions (November 2018)
c. Introduction of electronic prescribing and ensuring that “incompatibility alerts” are not disabled on Unity (Patient Information System, February 2019)
d. Review of antibiotic prescribing for patients with cardiovascular disease by the clinical lead for microbiology (February 2019)
e. Remind all prescribers to follow prescribing guidelines fully (Director of Governance 30 September) Overall I am satisfied the CCG, Trust and NHS England have taken the issue seriously in order to help to prevent a reoccurrence. High quality care for all, now and for future generations

[Page 3] Thank you for bringing this important patient safety issue to my attention and please do not hesitate to contact me should you need any further information.
Sufia Begum
15 Nov 2018 PDF
Action Taken

• The CCG contacted Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals Trust to seek assurance that actions have been taken to prevent reoccurrence. • The CCG wrote to all contracted NHS providers and primary care providers to notify them of the need to avoid drug interactions. • The CCG included an alert about the BNF App and its drug interactions checker in its monthly Medicines Newsletter. (AI summary)

View full response
Dear Louise Re: Regulation 28 Report to Prevent Future Deaths – Sufia Begum I am writing in response to the notification of a regulation 28 regarding Sufia Begum. In considering our response, we have reviewed the investigation carried out by Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust, and we have used the opportunity to reflect on this incident to consider the risks of medicines interactions across our local healthcare system, particularly in the urgent care arena. The CCG had been alerted to Mrs Begum’s death through its serious incident reporting process, which requires care providers to report serious incidents in accordance with NHS England Serious Incident Reporting Framework (2015). In response to that report the CCG has contacted Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals Trust to seek assurance that actions have taken to prevent a reoccurrence of this situation, and we continue to work with the Trust to ensure that these actions are completed. The CCG wrote, at the end of October, to all of its contracted NHS providers to notify them of the need to avoid drug interactions and to seek assurance that this has been addressed. This was followed on 2nd November by a letter to primary care providers of walk in centres and urgent care treatment centres notifying the same. 1

[Page 2] On 14th November the CCG included the following alert in its monthly Medicines Newsletter: BNF App – drug interactions checker A coroner’s report about a death as a result of an interaction between verapamil and clarithromycin concluded that opportunities were missed to have identified this interaction and recommended greater use of the BNF App to check for drug interactions. While GP clinical systems would be expected to highlight potentially serious interactions, prescribers should have a back-up available if prescribing without using the clinical system (e.g. home visit, clinical system failure etc). The BNF App is free to download for smartphones and tablets via this link. This newsletter is circulated to all of the CCG’s general practitioners, practice nurses and practice managers. I hope this provides satisfactory reassurance that we have acted to prevent future deaths from this medicines interaction in particular as well taking the opportunity to avoid further unknown medicine interactions. However, should you require any further information or clarification please do not hesitate to contact me. On behalf of the CCG I would like to express my sympathy and sincere condolences to the family and friends of Mrs Begum.

Report sections

Investigation and inquest
On 26/04/2018 I commenced an investigation into the death of Sufia Begum. The investigation  concluded at the end of an inquest on 20th August 2018. The conclusion of the inquest was:‐  Died from an unrecognised adverse drug interaction.
Circumstances of the death
The deceased was admitted to the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham on 14/04/18 suffering from  vomiting, confusion and generalised weakness. She had previously been treated at City Hospital for  exacerbation of asthma from 07/04/18 – 09/04/18 and had been prescribed clarithromycin. Tests at the  Queen Elizabeth Hospital confirmed she was suffering from an accumulation of verapamil (a calcium  channel blocker drug she was already taking) caused by the prescription of clarithromycin which inhibits  the enzyme which breaks down verapamil. It had not been recognised at the time that verapamil  interacts with clarithromycin. Despite treatment she died on 24/04/18. 

Based on information from the Deceased’s treating clinicians the medical cause of death was determined  to be:  MULTIORGAN FAILURE  CALCIUM CHANNEL BLOCKER TOXICITY 

ATRIAL FIBRILLATION
Copies sent to
I am also under a duty to send the Chief Coroner a copy of your responseSignatureLouise Hunt   Senior Coroner   Birmingham and Solihull

Similar PFD reports

Shared signals

Related inquiry recommendations

Similar themes

Report details

Date of report
19 September 2018
Coroner
Louise Hunt
Coroner area
Birmingham and Solihull

Responses identified

Responses identified 2 of 2
All listed responses identified

Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 14 Nov 2018 (estimated).

Sent to

Clinical Commission Group
NHS England

Source links