Source · Prevention of Future Deaths

Prabhaker Kapoor

Ref: 2019-0278 Date: 6 Aug 2019 Coroner: Adam Hodson Area: Birmingham and Solihull Responses identified: 1 / 1 View PDF

Essential updates to safer swallowing training and the MOODLE package were significantly delayed and lacked a completion timeline, despite being recommended in a Root Cause Analysis report.

Date 6 Aug 2019
56-day deadline 1 Oct 2019
Responses identified 1 of 1
Hospital Death (Clinical Procedures and medical management) related deaths

Coroner's concerns

AI summary
Essential updates to safer swallowing training and the MOODLE package were significantly delayed and lacked a completion timeline, despite being recommended in a Root Cause Analysis report.
View full coroner's concerns
I heard evidence that a review of safer swallowing training was to be provided to staff on team training days, and that changes would be made to the MOODLE training package by the Speech and Language Manager. The RCA report carried out by Matron indicated that this should have been completed by 15th May 2019, but in oral evidence it was revealed that this had not been done, and an estimated timeframe for completion could not be provided to me. Whilst it was suggested that confirmation could be submitted to HM Coroner upon successful completion of this review, HM Coroner would be functus officio. I therefore suggest that the Trust consider carrying out this review of safer swallowing and update the MOODLE training package as a matter of urgency.

Responses

1 respondent
Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust NHS / Health Body
1 Oct 2019 PDF
Action Taken

The Trust has updated its Moodle training package with SLT input to reflect standard operating procedures for dysphagia and 'nil by mouth' patients, reviewed standard operating procedures, developed 'preventing harm' study days, and disseminated a practice update on managing patients with swallowing difficulties. (AI summary)

View full response
Dear Mr Hodson, Inquest touching the death of Prabhaker Nath Kapoor Response to Regulation 28 Report to prevent future deaths write in response to the Regulation 28 Report made by you following the Inquest into the death of Mr Kapoor, which concluded on 5 August 2019. University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust (the Trust) has carefully considered the concerns raised within your report to prevent future deaths regarding a review of safer swallowing and update of our Moodle training package_ Review of Moodle training Moodle is an internal training e learning platform used to provide training packages to our staff on a range of subjects_ review of the training package had been commenced prior to the death of Mr Kapoor although it had not been completed at the time of the Inquest A review has now been undertaken, and the content of the training package has been updated by our Speech and Language Therapy team (SLT) to reflect our standard operating procedures relating to 'dysphagia' and patients who are 'nil by mouth' . The training package is currently developed and will be available for staff by 21 October 2019 The training package will be available to both new and existing staff: The Moodle package is only one way in which we provide training to our staff around safer swallowing and managing patients with dysphagia. It is an adjunct to training programme provided by the SLT team, who provide the following training on an annual basis, or more frequently if specifically requested:
1) Ward based training for registered and unregistered nursing staff Chair: Rt Hon Jacqui Smith Chief Executive: Dr David Rosser Way being

2) Specialist training for patients with disease specific swallowing problems (e:g. head and neck cancer, Parkinson' s disease etc ):
3) Stroke swallow screening training for specialist nurses who screen patients who have had a stroke.
4) Junior doctor/Registrar/Consultant training-explaining signs symptoms and wavs to manage swallowing problems:
5) In service swallow assessment and management training for allied health professionals.
6) Ward based training to implement the International Dysphagia Diet Standardisation. Review of our training provision Following this incident a task and finish group was set Up, chaired by our Deputy Chief Nurse, to review safer swallowing practices across the Trust and to review the ongoing work to align our education provision, policy and procedure documents Review of standard operating procedures A review of our existing standard operating procedures relating to managing patients who are nil by mouth and managing patients who have dysphagia has been undertaken by our SLT team: Following review the documents have been updated and we are satisfied that provide all our staff with clear guidance, rationale, and clinical expectations when managing and for patients who have dysphagia and/or are placed nil by mouth: There has been consultation with consultant oncologist, consultant geriatrician, consultant ear nose and throat surgeon, palliative care consultant and lead for nursing education: The standard operating procedures have been reviewed by our task and finish group referred to above and will be reviewed and ratified by our Operational Quality Assurance Group on 1 October 2019. Following ratification the documents will be disseminated to all staff via our communications team and will also appear on our intranet. AIl that having been said we recognise that the evidence base for restriction of water in those on thickened fluid regime is extremely weak There is no NICE recommendation in either direction; NICE simply references a Cochrane systematic review of the limited literature. This systematic review identifies no evidence of excess risk associated with access to water in this group of patients We will continue to review this literature and determine whether our current procedures remain reasonable: In the meantime we are though clear that trust wide adherence to current recommendations must be maintained: Rolling education programme_ preventing_harm study days' We have developed 'preventing harm' study days which are provided on a monthly basis to both new and existing staff: The days were created to ensure that all our staff have access to specialist led training: The session includes, amongst other training, education and training on the standard operating procedures referred to above Practice update A practice update on 'managing patients with swallowing difficulties in hospital' has been developed and disseminated to all of our staff by our Quality and Clinical Assurance team in order to raise awareness and minimise the potential risk to patients with dysphagia. Chair: Rt Hon Jacqui Smith Chief Executive: Dr David Rosser they caring

would like to assure you that the concerns raised within the Regulation 28 Report have been taken seriously which hope is demonstrated by the steps we have taken in reviewing our processes, guidelines, training and education:

Report sections

Investigation and inquest
On 17/05/2019 I commenced an investigation into the death of Prabhaker Nath Kapoor. The investigation concluded at the end of an inquest on 5th August 2019. The conclusion of the inquest was that of a Narrative Verdict, namely, “death due to aspiration of unthickened fluids in hospital.”
Circumstances of the death
On 19/11/18, the deceased had an unwitnessed fall at home and was admitted to the Emergency Department at Birmingham Heartlands Hospital where he was diagnosed with a fractured neck of the right humerus. He was to be admitted to Ward 24 where the fracture was to be treated conservatively using a brace. He developed pneumonia due to aspirating food and was treated with IV antibiotics. He had previously been assessed in March 2017 by speech and language therapists in the community for a pureed diet and thickened fluids due to dysphagia caused by previous stroke, and a Feeding At Risk form was completed upon admission to Ward 24 on 19/11/2019 for this diet to continue. At 04.55 on 21/11/18, he was found by a member of staff attempting to drink from an unthickened jug of water which had been left near his bedside. He aspirated an unknown quantity of the contents which contributed to his aspiration pneumonia. His condition rapidly deteriorated as a result of this, and despite appropriate treatment, he died and his death was verified at 08.10 on 21/11/18..

Following a post mortem, the medical cause of death was determined to be: 1a) ASPIRATION PNEUMONIA 1b) INHALATION OF LIQUID
2) FRAILTY
Copies sent to
2) NHS England3) Clinical Commissioning Group

Similar PFD reports

Shared signals

Related inquiry recommendations

Similar themes

Report details

Reference
2019-0278
Date of report
6 August 2019
Coroner
Adam Hodson
Coroner area
Birmingham and Solihull

Responses identified

Responses identified 1 of 1
All listed responses identified

Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 1 Oct 2019.

Sent to

University Hospitals Birmimgham NHS Trust

Source links