Source · Prevention of Future Deaths
Raymond Woodhouse
Ref: 2020-0217
Date: 21 Oct 2020
Coroner: Andrew Cox
Area: Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly
Responses identified: 0 / 1
View PDF
Inadequate staffing led to staff not listening to family, poor cleanliness, delayed antibiotics, and multiple failures in administering time-critical Parkinson's medication.
Date
21 Oct 2020
56-day deadline
20 Dec 2020
Responses identified
0 of 1
Coroner's concerns
Inadequate staffing led to staff not listening to family, poor cleanliness, delayed antibiotics, and multiple failures in administering time-critical Parkinson's medication.
View full coroner's concerns
i) The family complained they were unable to get staff on Karenza ward to listen to them. It was accepted in evidence that, at the time, there were staffing Information Classification: CONTROLLED difficulties on the ward that have since been addressed. ii) A lack of cleanliness with Mr Woodhouse being left in soiled bedding and clothes. It was not possible at inquest to come to a view that this was the cause of the infections in the knee and/or elbow. iii) Potential delay in the administration of antibiotics. In evidence, Dr accepted that with the benefit of hindsight this was the case. While it was not causative of the death it was possible this had resulted in an avoidable wash-out in theatre; iv) Delays or omissions of prescribed Parkinson’s medication. Matron had reviewed the nursing records. She accepted in evidence that there were ‘multiple’ occasions when medication was given late and three occasions when it was not given at all. She conceded nursing standards had fallen below what could reasonably be expected. The inquest was told this is a national problem coming out of the difficulties caused where a patient needs time-specific medication that falls outside traditional ward times for the administration of medication. I was also informed that a business case has been prepared for consideration by the Board for the appointment of a specialist Parkinson’s nurse and pharmacist. It was not known whether the case had been accepted and, if so, when it will be taken forward.
Report sections
Investigation and inquest
On 20 October 2020, I concluded an inquest into the death of Raymond Claude Woodhouse who died in RCHT on 11 February 2019. The medical cause of death was recorded as:
1a) Bronchopneumonia 1b) 1c) II) Parkinson’s disease, Infected bursitis (operated), Osteoarthritis of the knee (operated)
I recorded a Narrative Conclusion that Mr Woodhouse died from a known complication (infection) of a necessary surgical procedure (total knee replacement.)
1a) Bronchopneumonia 1b) 1c) II) Parkinson’s disease, Infected bursitis (operated), Osteoarthritis of the knee (operated)
I recorded a Narrative Conclusion that Mr Woodhouse died from a known complication (infection) of a necessary surgical procedure (total knee replacement.)
Circumstances of the death
Mr Woodhouse suffered with severe Parkinson’s disease. He also had debilitating pain in an arthritic left knee. The family obtained specialist advice about the risks of a knee replacement procedure and were advised that, while some risk was unavoidable, a key to a successful outcome was to ensure the administration of his prescribed Parkinson’s medication post-operatively. On 5/1/19, Mr Woodhouse fell and suffered a cut to his elbow that required stitching. On 16/1/19, Mr performed a total knee replacement at St Michael’s. The operation itself went well. On 21/1/19, without Mr being advised, Mr Woodhouse was transferred to RCHT (Karenza ward) for post-operative delirium and related complaints. Mr Woodhouse developed an infected left elbow. There was a delay in the administration of anti-biotics – possibly due to CRP levels not being checked – and Mr Woodhouse required a wash-out in theatre. Mr Woodhouse’s knee became infected and also required a wash-out. He deteriorated and died on 11/2/19.
Action should be taken
It is in relation to the business case for a specialist Parkinson’s nurse and pharmacist that I write to you. It would seem to me that this would be a sensible step to take that would prevent similar future deaths.
There was also an issue about the lack of knowledge of nurses generally in relation to specialist prescriptions for conditions like Parkinson’s. I felt that could be addressed by training that a specialist appointee would be well-placed to lead.
I wondered also if it would make sense for this cohort of patients (post-operative Parkinson’s patients) to go to a default ward where an in-patient stay was required. This would have the benefit of allowing the nurses on that ward to build up specialist knowledge. The family offered an observation that Mr Woodhouse’s nursing care improved significantly following his transfer from Karenza ward to a trauma ward. I accept this will always have to be subject to bed availability but it is a matter I felt appropriate to report to you for consideration.
There was also an issue about the lack of knowledge of nurses generally in relation to specialist prescriptions for conditions like Parkinson’s. I felt that could be addressed by training that a specialist appointee would be well-placed to lead.
I wondered also if it would make sense for this cohort of patients (post-operative Parkinson’s patients) to go to a default ward where an in-patient stay was required. This would have the benefit of allowing the nurses on that ward to build up specialist knowledge. The family offered an observation that Mr Woodhouse’s nursing care improved significantly following his transfer from Karenza ward to a trauma ward. I accept this will always have to be subject to bed availability but it is a matter I felt appropriate to report to you for consideration.
Similar PFD reports
Related inquiry recommendations
Muckamore Abbey Inquiry
Consultation before patient transfers
Muckamore Abbey Inquiry
Named person approval for transfers
Muckamore Abbey Inquiry
Independent living skills focus
Muckamore Abbey Inquiry
Higher-funded resettlement team for complex needs
Muckamore Abbey Inquiry
Time frame and financial information for families
Muckamore Abbey Inquiry
Continuing community support provision
Muckamore Abbey Inquiry
Key individual for resettlement communication
Vale of Leven Inquiry
Service change continuity plans
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Continuing responsibility for care
Mid Staffs Inquiry
Follow up of patients
Report details
- Reference
- 2020-0217
- Date of report
- 21 October 2020
- Coroner
- Andrew Cox
- Coroner area
- Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly
Responses identified
Responses identified
0 of 1
1 response not yet linked
Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 20 Dec 2020.
Sent to
- Royal Cornwall Hospital