Recommendations & Conclusions
7 items
3
Conclusion
4th Report - Covid-19 and the criminal …
Acknowledged
However, the creation and enforcement of any new criminal offence must be compatible with widely understood principles of the rule of law. Ensuring that those principles are upheld serves to enhance understanding of and compliance with the law, which is essential to achieving positive public health outcomes and to save …
Read more
However, the creation and enforcement of any new criminal offence must be compatible with widely understood principles of the rule of law. Ensuring that those principles are upheld serves to enhance understanding of and compliance with the law, which is essential to achieving positive public health outcomes and to save lives.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government described its approach to legal changes during the pandemic, asserting that actions were necessary and proportionate and that restrictions were removed when safe. It also outlined its strategy to move away from regulations to public health measures and guidance.
Read full response →
Ministry of Justice
8
Recommendation
4th Report - Covid-19 and the criminal …
Acknowledged
We support the creation of the UK Health Security Agency as a new body designed to ensure the nation can respond quickly and at greater scale to future pandemics. In line with Lord Wolfson’s suggestion that expertise in the criminal law needs in future to be brought into pandemic planning, …
Read more
We support the creation of the UK Health Security Agency as a new body designed to ensure the nation can respond quickly and at greater scale to future pandemics. In line with Lord Wolfson’s suggestion that expertise in the criminal law needs in future to be brought into pandemic planning, we urge the Government to ensure that the Agency has sufficient expertise in the criminal law, and factors such expertise into future pandemic preparation. We support the creation of the UK Health Security Agency as a new body designed to ensure the nation can respond quickly and at greater scale to future pandemics.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the need for lessons learned and states central government departments are best placed to consider the criminal justice system's role and ensure relevant expertise is fed into the policy process for future pandemic preparedness. It does not explicitly commit to ensuring UKHSA …
Read full response →
Ministry of Justice
9
Recommendation
4th Report - Covid-19 and the criminal …
Acknowledged
Given the central role that new covid-19 related offences and lockdown laws played in protecting public health, we recommend that the Government commission a study, to be conducted by the UK Health Security Agency or other relevant body, into the role of the criminal justice system in protecting public health …
Read more
Given the central role that new covid-19 related offences and lockdown laws played in protecting public health, we recommend that the Government commission a study, to be conducted by the UK Health Security Agency or other relevant body, into the role of the criminal justice system in protecting public health during pandemics. The aim of the study should be to examine how effective the creation of covid-19 offences was in achieving compliance with public health regulations and protecting public health.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees that lessons must be learned from the pandemic experience and will draw on expertise within UKHSA and other bodies. It states central government departments are best placed to consider the criminal justice system's role and is continuing to review measures for future …
Read full response →
Ministry of Justice
10
Conclusion
4th Report - Covid-19 and the criminal …
Acknowledged
There has been general recognition of the need to respond very quickly to the changing circumstances of the pandemic, particularly as it began when facts about the virus were not well known. The Government was right to use all the legislative tools at its disposal, as granted by Parliament, in …
Read more
There has been general recognition of the need to respond very quickly to the changing circumstances of the pandemic, particularly as it began when facts about the virus were not well known. The Government was right to use all the legislative tools at its disposal, as granted by Parliament, in order to legislate to protect public health during the covid-19 pandemic.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the committee's observation, stating that the UK and Devolved Governments responded to unprecedented challenges during the pandemic to protect public health, the NHS, and livelihoods.
Read full response →
Ministry of Justice
12
Recommendation
4th Report - Covid-19 and the criminal …
Acknowledged
A lesson from the covid-19 pandemic is that Parliament should play a more active role in the creation, scrutiny and oversight of new criminal offences in response to emergencies. One of the primary functions of parliamentary scrutiny of legislation is to make the legislative process, and the law it creates, …
Read more
A lesson from the covid-19 pandemic is that Parliament should play a more active role in the creation, scrutiny and oversight of new criminal offences in response to emergencies. One of the primary functions of parliamentary scrutiny of legislation is to make the legislative process, and the law it creates, accessible and transparent. Parliament plays an important role in making sure that the law and any new criminal offences are so far as is possible intelligible, clear and predictable. It is not satisfactory in this context that Parliament was not always able to fulfil its function when Members were required to consider statutory instruments already repealed or already superseded. We recommend that the Government and the Procedure Committee of the House of Commons consider how future scrutiny of emergency regulations can be conducted in a timely fashion.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees on the importance of timely scrutiny for emergency legislation and explains the challenges and measures taken during the pandemic, but does not commit to specific new actions or a formal consideration process for future improvements.
Read full response →
Ministry of Justice
16
Conclusion
4th Report - Covid-19 and the criminal …
Acknowledged
We recognise that throughout the pandemic the Government’s priority has been to communicate as clearly as possible to the public what they should and should not do. We also recognise that due to the speed with which legislation needed to be passed, and the complexity of the legislative framework, it …
Read more
We recognise that throughout the pandemic the Government’s priority has been to communicate as clearly as possible to the public what they should and should not do. We also recognise that due to the speed with which legislation needed to be passed, and the complexity of the legislative framework, it was difficult always to capture the nuance between what was advisable and what was prohibited by law within Government announcements and ministerial press conferences.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the challenges in communicating clear guidance during the pandemic, stating they have evolved their approach and continue to make efforts to communicate law and guidance as clearly as possible.
Read full response →
Ministry of Justice
18
Conclusion
4th Report - Covid-19 and the criminal …
Acknowledged
We recognise that sometimes novel offences were created at speed and that there was inevitably, therefore, some initial uncertainty about their extent and application. The concept of legal certainty is also an essential component of the rule of law. In principle, all restrictions should be cast in terms of sufficient …
Read more
We recognise that sometimes novel offences were created at speed and that there was inevitably, therefore, some initial uncertainty about their extent and application. The concept of legal certainty is also an essential component of the rule of law. In principle, all restrictions should be cast in terms of sufficient clarity and certainty to enable people to understand whether certain kinds of activity will or will not incur criminal liability. Government communication of any new criminal offences must always accurately reflect the true legal position so as not to undermine public trust, and subsequently public compliance. We recognise that the novelty of these offences meant the usual clarity in the law that evolves as cases are prosecuted and heard by the courts was necessarily absent and clarity and understanding of the public, police and the courts can naturally be expected to improve over time as happens with other offences.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees that good communication is essential for compliance and protecting public health, and states they will learn lessons from pandemic communications via the COVID-19 public inquiry for future planning.
Read full response →
Ministry of Justice