Recommendations & Conclusions
26 items
1
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Acknowledged
Transport is the largest source of carbon emissions in the UK, accounting for 27% of total emissions. If the UK is to meet its 2050 net zero carbon emissions target, a concerted effort will be needed to dramatically decarbonise the transport sector, particularly surface transport. This is a considerable challenge, …
Read more
Transport is the largest source of carbon emissions in the UK, accounting for 27% of total emissions. If the UK is to meet its 2050 net zero carbon emissions target, a concerted effort will be needed to dramatically decarbonise the transport sector, particularly surface transport. This is a considerable challenge, and it offers the UK an opportunity to become a world leader in green transport and decarbonisation technology.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government welcomes the report, agrees on the need for decarbonisation, highlights past electrification efforts, and states that its forthcoming Transport Decarbonisation Plan and the new Great British Railways will provide a long-term strategy and clearer accountability for achieving net zero in rail.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
2
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Acknowledged
We welcome the Department for Transport’s reaffirmation that it is committed to withdrawing all diesel-only trains by 2040—including freight trains. This will be a hugely important step in ensuring a greener, decarbonised rail network, which will be necessary for the Government to meet its legally binding net-zero target by
Read more
We welcome the Department for Transport’s reaffirmation that it is committed to withdrawing all diesel-only trains by 2040—including freight trains. This will be a hugely important step in ensuring a greener, decarbonised rail network, which will be necessary for the Government to meet its legally binding net-zero target by
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating they are developing a Traction Decarbonisation Plan (TDP) and Rail Environment Policy (REP) to set their long-term strategic direction for decarbonising the railway, with a comprehensive environment plan to be published by 2022. They do not explicitly reaffirm the commitment …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
3
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
While we recognise the immediate challenges brought about by the coronavirus pandemic, we are concerned about the frequent delays to the publication of the Department’s Transport Decarbonisation Plan and the Rail Reform White Paper based on the Williams Review. These delays have unfortunately compounded the difficulties for the rail industry …
Read more
While we recognise the immediate challenges brought about by the coronavirus pandemic, we are concerned about the frequent delays to the publication of the Department’s Transport Decarbonisation Plan and the Rail Reform White Paper based on the Williams Review. These delays have unfortunately compounded the difficulties for the rail industry to plan and invest in the development of a carbon- free railway.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government "partially agrees" with the implied need to address delays, stating it is developing a Transport Decarbonisation Plan (TDP) and Rail Environment Policy (REP), and will publish a comprehensive environment plan for the rail network by 2022.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
4
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
We recommend that the Department for Transport publishes a long-term strategy for decarbonising the rail network as a matter of priority. This should include a vision for what proportion of the future network will use electrification, battery and hydrogen. That strategy should be supported by appropriate costings, a credible delivery …
Read more
We recommend that the Department for Transport publishes a long-term strategy for decarbonising the rail network as a matter of priority. This should include a vision for what proportion of the future network will use electrification, battery and hydrogen. That strategy should be supported by appropriate costings, a credible delivery plan, and enabling targets and milestones. These targets and milestones should clarify how the 2040 and 2050 targets will fit together.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating they are developing a Traction Decarbonisation Plan (TDP) and Rail Environment Policy (REP) document to set a long-term strategic direction, with a comprehensive environment plan to be published by 2022. They note the Network Rail-led Traction Decarbonisation Network Strategy (TDNS) …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
5
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
Dedicated investment over the long-term will be essential in order to meet the considerable challenge of decarbonising the rail network by 2050. There will be understandable pressures on public spending in the coming years as the country recovers from the pandemic. However, measures to decarbonise our transport sector ought to …
Read more
Dedicated investment over the long-term will be essential in order to meet the considerable challenge of decarbonising the rail network by 2050. There will be understandable pressures on public spending in the coming years as the country recovers from the pandemic. However, measures to decarbonise our transport sector ought to be considered a Government priority.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, indicating they are developing a Traction Decarbonisation Plan (TDP) and Rail Environment Policy (REP) to set their long-term strategic direction for decarbonising the railway and will publish a comprehensive environment plan by 2022.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
6
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted
We call on the Department to work closely with other Government departments, including the Treasury, to secure agreement for the levels of funding necessary to begin implementing a long-term decarbonisation programme of the rail network. (Paragraph 31) 34 Trains fit for the futuree Rolling programme of electrification
Read more
We call on the Department to work closely with other Government departments, including the Treasury, to secure agreement for the levels of funding necessary to begin implementing a long-term decarbonisation programme of the rail network. (Paragraph 31) 34 Trains fit for the futuree Rolling programme of electrification
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government accepts the recommendation and commits to working closely with other departments, including the Treasury, to secure necessary funding for the decarbonisation policy to be set out in the Transport Decarbonisation Plan.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
7
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Acknowledged
Decarbonisation of the rail network over the next generation will require moving from diesel traction to cleaner technologies, such as electrification, battery, and hydrogen. We agree with the Department and industry experts that electrification is the only immediately viable decarbonisation option for most of the network, not least because the …
Read more
Decarbonisation of the rail network over the next generation will require moving from diesel traction to cleaner technologies, such as electrification, battery, and hydrogen. We agree with the Department and industry experts that electrification is the only immediately viable decarbonisation option for most of the network, not least because the alternatives are not suitable for freight and high-speed services due to their high energy demands.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating they are developing a Traction Decarbonisation Plan (TDP) and Rail Environment Policy (REP) to set a long-term strategic direction, with a comprehensive environment plan to be published by 2022, and notes the TDNS vision for technological mix.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
8
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Acknowledged
Rail electrification projects within Great Britain have historically been costly. The Department and Network Rail have said that lessons have been learned from previous projects. The importance of this cannot be overstated. The mistakes that unnecessarily increased the cost of previous schemes should not be repeated.
Read more
Rail electrification projects within Great Britain have historically been costly. The Department and Network Rail have said that lessons have been learned from previous projects. The importance of this cannot be overstated. The mistakes that unnecessarily increased the cost of previous schemes should not be repeated.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating that the Department is developing a Transport Decarbonisation Plan and Rail Environment Policy to set a strategic direction for decarbonisation, and that Network Rail's TDNS and further analysis will ensure affordability and value for money, thereby aiming to avoid past …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
9
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
We understand that rail electrification project costs are monitored by the Department and Network Rail as part of the Rail Network Enhancements Pipeline process. Any overspend would be flagged by that process. The financial failures of previous electrification programmes caused work to cease. It is vital that the future electrification …
Read more
We understand that rail electrification project costs are monitored by the Department and Network Rail as part of the Rail Network Enhancements Pipeline process. Any overspend would be flagged by that process. The financial failures of previous electrification programmes caused work to cease. It is vital that the future electrification programmes are subject to a new cost discipline, with robust and rigorous financial controls that enable electrification to be successfully delivered to budget.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government "partially agrees", stating it has already introduced robust financial mechanisms like the RNEP process following past cost challenges. It notes a review of financial governance is underway within Network Rail and commits to continuing to enhance processes where necessary to ensure lessons are …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
10
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
We recommend that the Department implements an enhanced financial mechanism beyond that contained in the Rail Network Enhancement Pipeline process. That enhanced financial mechanism must be designed to ensure that strict transparency and adherence to cost discipline are maintained in any electrification programme.
Read more
We recommend that the Department implements an enhanced financial mechanism beyond that contained in the Rail Network Enhancement Pipeline process. That enhanced financial mechanism must be designed to ensure that strict transparency and adherence to cost discipline are maintained in any electrification programme.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating that robust financial mechanisms including RNEP were already introduced, and while agreeing in principle to financial transparency, a review of financial governance is underway within Network Rail, with commitments to continue enhancing processes where necessary.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
11
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
As recommended by our predecessor Committee in 2018, the best way to deliver efficient and cost-effective electrification is to establish a rolling programme of electrification over the next 30 years. A rolling programme of electrification should also support the delivery of the Government’s “green industrial revolution” and “levelling up” economic …
Read more
As recommended by our predecessor Committee in 2018, the best way to deliver efficient and cost-effective electrification is to establish a rolling programme of electrification over the next 30 years. A rolling programme of electrification should also support the delivery of the Government’s “green industrial revolution” and “levelling up” economic disparities between the regions. The task of decarbonisation belongs to successive governments, but this administration must take the first steps towards meeting the 2050 “net zero” target.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, committing to endeavour to deliver a 30-year pipeline of electrification schemes but will ensure proper development through the RNEP process before committing to individual projects, balancing certainty for the industry with affordability and value for money.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
12
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
We recommend that the Department commits to a 30-year rolling programme of electrification projects and sets this out in its long-term rail decarbonisation strategy.
Government response AI summary
The government "partially agrees", committing to "endeavour to deliver" a visible pipeline of electrification schemes over the next 30 years. However, it qualifies this by emphasizing that schemes must be properly developed through the RNEP process to ensure affordability and value for money before commitment.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
13
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
The scale of change required to meet the 2040 and 2050 rail decarbonisation targets is considerable. We believe it would be beneficial to start the electrification programme as soon as possible, rather than wait for the start of the next control period in 2024. This would also enable the industry …
Read more
The scale of change required to meet the 2040 and 2050 rail decarbonisation targets is considerable. We believe it would be beneficial to start the electrification programme as soon as possible, rather than wait for the start of the next control period in 2024. This would also enable the industry to retain the workforce skills and experience it has developed through recent electrification schemes.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, committing to endeavour to deliver a 30-year pipeline of electrification schemes but will not start immediately, prioritising proper development through the RNEP process to ensure affordability and value for money.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
14
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted
We recommend that Network Rail and the ORR continue to explore the potential for an extension in third-rail electrification capability and that the Department, as the overall sponsor of rail decarbonisation, proactively monitors this development in Trains fit for the futuree 35 the event that Network Rail and the Office …
Read more
We recommend that Network Rail and the ORR continue to explore the potential for an extension in third-rail electrification capability and that the Department, as the overall sponsor of rail decarbonisation, proactively monitors this development in Trains fit for the futuree 35 the event that Network Rail and the Office of Rail and Road are unable to reach an agreement on whether to proceed with further third-rail electrification projects.”
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees to proactively monitor Network Rail and ORR's exploration of third-rail electrification extension, and is funding a project by the Rail Safety and Standards Board to investigate safety improvements for third rail electrification.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
15
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
In responding to this Report, if not earlier, the Department should publish the list of “no regret” electrification schemes identified by Network Rail and confirm which schemes they intend to deliver as a priority, the costs of doing so, and the timeframes. (Paragraph 62) Alternative decarbonisation technologies
Read more
In responding to this Report, if not earlier, the Department should publish the list of “no regret” electrification schemes identified by Network Rail and confirm which schemes they intend to deliver as a priority, the costs of doing so, and the timeframes. (Paragraph 62) Alternative decarbonisation technologies
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, providing an interim "no regret" electrification analysis as an annex, but clarifies it is superseded and full details on prioritised schemes, costs, and timeframes will be published through the updated RNEP process.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
16
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Acknowledged
We believe that battery and hydrogen technology should play an important part in decarbonising the rail network and should feature prominently in the Department’s long-term decarbonisation rail strategy. New technology should be embraced although we recognise that at present both battery and hydrogen have limitations in that neither can deliver …
Read more
We believe that battery and hydrogen technology should play an important part in decarbonising the rail network and should feature prominently in the Department’s long-term decarbonisation rail strategy. New technology should be embraced although we recognise that at present both battery and hydrogen have limitations in that neither can deliver the energy demands required for high-speed rail and freight services.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating they are developing a Traction Decarbonisation Plan (TDP) and Rail Environment Policy (REP) to set a long-term strategic direction for decarbonising the railway, with a comprehensive environment plan to be published by 2022. They note the need for further analysis …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
17
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted
The Department must make the case within Government to ensure that hydrogen trains are fully incorporated within the forthcoming national Hydrogen Strategy. This will help ensure the roll out of this new technology is properly co-ordinated and supported by appropriate infrastructure.
Read more
The Department must make the case within Government to ensure that hydrogen trains are fully incorporated within the forthcoming national Hydrogen Strategy. This will help ensure the roll out of this new technology is properly co-ordinated and supported by appropriate infrastructure.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the recommendation and is actively making the case across government to ensure hydrogen trains are included at an appropriate level in the forthcoming national Hydrogen Strategy.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
18
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted
In its response to this Report, the Department should provide more information on how it intends, working with other Government departments, to support the growth of a domestic battery industry to ensure this form of technology can be utilised on the railway.
Read more
In its response to this Report, the Department should provide more information on how it intends, working with other Government departments, to support the growth of a domestic battery industry to ensure this form of technology can be utilised on the railway.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government accepts the recommendation, committing to work with BEIS to support a domestic battery industry and detailing its existing £318 million investment in the Faraday Battery Challenge, which aims to establish the UK as a leader in battery science, research, and manufacturing.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
19
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
Although the rail industry requires a long-term strategy for decarbonising the rail network, it is important that the strategy is sufficiently flexible to incorporate alternative technologies, such as hydrogen and battery, and other new technologies that might be developed. When and if it is demonstrated that clean, green and cost- …
Read more
Although the rail industry requires a long-term strategy for decarbonising the rail network, it is important that the strategy is sufficiently flexible to incorporate alternative technologies, such as hydrogen and battery, and other new technologies that might be developed. When and if it is demonstrated that clean, green and cost- effective alternatives to electrification can deliver the energy required by freight and high-speed passenger services, they should be introduced to decarbonise the rail network.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating they are developing a Traction Decarbonisation Plan (TDP) and Rail Environment Policy (REP) document to set a long-term strategy, with a comprehensive environment plan to be published by 2022. They acknowledge the need for further analysis as technologies evolve to …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
20
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted
The long-term rail decarbonisation strategy must explain the process by which the development of alternative technologies will be reviewed and how such technologies can be incorporated into the network strategy, if they reach the necessary level of development.(Paragraph 88) Decarbonising rail freight
Read more
The long-term rail decarbonisation strategy must explain the process by which the development of alternative technologies will be reviewed and how such technologies can be incorporated into the network strategy, if they reach the necessary level of development.(Paragraph 88) Decarbonising rail freight
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government accepts the recommendation, stating that the TDNS recommends regional assessments of alternative technologies and that Great British Railways will be well-placed to consider all options and update the analysis periodically as technologies develop.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
21
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Deferred
Encouraging modal shift from road to rail freight will be an essential part of ensuring the transport sector contributes to the net zero 2050 target. It is therefore crucial that any action taken to decarbonise the rail network does not have the adverse effect of distorting the competitiveness of the …
Read more
Encouraging modal shift from road to rail freight will be an essential part of ensuring the transport sector contributes to the net zero 2050 target. It is therefore crucial that any action taken to decarbonise the rail network does not have the adverse effect of distorting the competitiveness of the rail freight market and pushing freight on to the road. The risk of adverse outcomes highlights the need for the Government to produce its national freight strategy. (Paragraph 97) 36 Trains fit for the futuree
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government notes the recommendation, recognising the importance of freight decarbonisation without distorting competitiveness, and commits to setting out further details in the forthcoming Transport Decarbonisation Plan and a cross-modal freight strategy.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
22
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Deferred
As part of its upcoming cross modal freight strategy, the Department should ensure there is a single cross-modal freight decarbonisation target including both rail and road freight. (Paragraph 98) Research and development funding
Government response AI summary
The government notes the recommendation and will set out further details on freight decarbonisation, including a pathway to net zero, in the forthcoming Transport Decarbonisation Plan and cross-modal freight strategy, rather than committing to a specific target now.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
23
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
We welcome Government funding to support the establishment of the Global Centre of Rail Excellence, which is a positive step in decarbonising the rail network. However, we heard evidence that the amount of research and development funding provided by Government for innovation in the rail sector compares unfavourably to other …
Read more
We welcome Government funding to support the establishment of the Global Centre of Rail Excellence, which is a positive step in decarbonising the rail network. However, we heard evidence that the amount of research and development funding provided by Government for innovation in the rail sector compares unfavourably to other transport sectors. This will need to change if the rail sector is to meet the considerable challenge of decarbonising by 2050. R&D funding can help to catalyse the development of new technologies and support smaller businesses and local economies.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, highlighting existing significant R&D support and plans to simplify funding and improve collaboration under the Williams-Shapps White Paper. Great British Railways will become the primary public funder of R&D, aligning funding with long-term investment strategies and private sector innovators.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
24
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
We recommend that the Department’s long-term rail decarbonisation strategy sets out how research and development will be supported and properly funded in order to deliver the scale of change required to decarbonise the rail network.(Paragraph 103) Making trains fully accessible
Read more
We recommend that the Department’s long-term rail decarbonisation strategy sets out how research and development will be supported and properly funded in order to deliver the scale of change required to decarbonise the rail network.(Paragraph 103) Making trains fully accessible
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government partially agrees, stating significant R&D support is ongoing and will be simplified through the Williams-Shapps White Paper. Great British Railways will become the primary public funder of R&D, with closer alignment to long-term investment strategies and stronger links with private sector innovators.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
25
Conclusion
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted
Public transport must be accessible to all. It is unacceptable that several train companies have consistently failed to meet targets to make their trains fully accessible, despite having had 11 years to do so. In our view, the Department’s response of extending the legal deadline and requiring monthly progress reporting …
Read more
Public transport must be accessible to all. It is unacceptable that several train companies have consistently failed to meet targets to make their trains fully accessible, despite having had 11 years to do so. In our view, the Department’s response of extending the legal deadline and requiring monthly progress reporting does not treat this matter with the seriousness that it deserves.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government commits to removing the remaining 3% (525 vehicles) of non-compliant trains from service as soon as possible, with 133 of these only being used when coupled to compliant vehicles. Operators are prioritising compliant trains and taking operational mitigations.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
26
Recommendation
Sixth Report - Trains fit for the futur…
Accepted in Part
The Department must set out how it will ensure that train operators meet the legal requirement to make their trains fully accessible and what sanctions will be used if some train operators once again fail to meet the deadline. We will monitor this situation closely. (Paragraph 110) Trains fit for …
Read more
The Department must set out how it will ensure that train operators meet the legal requirement to make their trains fully accessible and what sanctions will be used if some train operators once again fail to meet the deadline. We will monitor this situation closely. (Paragraph 110) Trains fit for the futuree 37
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Department is committed to ensuring accessibility, stating 97% of trains are compliant and the remaining 3% will be removed from service or used only with compliant vehicles. Operators are prioritizing compliant trains and implementing operational mitigations, but the response does not explicitly detail sanctions …
Read full response →
Department for Transport