Recommendations & Conclusions
15 items
1
Conclusion
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
The covid-19 pandemic has had a severe impact on adult social care. People have received less care and often care workers have been compelled to deliver only the basics. More people are going without care and many people’s needs are increasing significantly. Social care workers and unpaid carers are burnt …
Read more
The covid-19 pandemic has had a severe impact on adult social care. People have received less care and often care workers have been compelled to deliver only the basics. More people are going without care and many people’s needs are increasing significantly. Social care workers and unpaid carers are burnt out. Covid-19 has exacerbated the need for more immediate funding for the sector.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that throughout the pandemic they made available over £2.9 billion in specific COVID-19 funding to support the adult social care sector.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
2
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
The Government provided vital additional funding to the adult social care sector during the pandemic, and we appreciate that the additional covid-19 funding cannot continue indefinitely. However, the Government’s own guidance that care workers should self-isolate if they test positive for covid-19 indicates that the risk to the sector is …
Read more
The Government provided vital additional funding to the adult social care sector during the pandemic, and we appreciate that the additional covid-19 funding cannot continue indefinitely. However, the Government’s own guidance that care workers should self-isolate if they test positive for covid-19 indicates that the risk to the sector is not over. We do not accept that controlling covid-19 infections is analogous to other types of infection control, since Ministers were unable to name any other sector whose employees the Government is still advising to self-isolate. Given the huge financial pressures on the sector and acute challenges with retaining staff, the Government should extend the Infection Control Fund for as long as the public health situation requires it to advise care workers to self-isolate with covid-19. (Paragraph 13) Immediate pressures
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that at the Autumn Statement 2022 it made up to £7.5 billion of additional funding available over two years to support adult social care and discharge.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
3
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
The Government is focused on long-term reform of adult social care, but in order to get to the future it needs to save the sector from the brink of collapse. Covid-19 has highlighted the underlying structural challenges of rising demand, unmet need, and difficulties recruiting and retaining staff, and has …
Read more
The Government is focused on long-term reform of adult social care, but in order to get to the future it needs to save the sector from the brink of collapse. Covid-19 has highlighted the underlying structural challenges of rising demand, unmet need, and difficulties recruiting and retaining staff, and has also exacerbated them. On top of that, there are severe current pressures arising from increases in the National Living Wage and the National Minimum Wage, and from rising inflation. We strongly disagree with the former Minister for Local Government, Faith and Communities that adult social care has adequate funding currently, having received compelling evidence that there is an immediate need for additional funding. The Government should allocate additional funding this year through the adult social care grant, cover inflationary pressures and unmet care needs, and should announce this as soon as possible so that local authorities can plan how to cope best with the pressures they are facing. (Paragraph 21) Funding gap
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government is making available more funding for adult social care through general taxation and increased Council Tax flexibilities, with up to £7.5 billion of additional funding over two years to support adult social care and discharge.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
5
Conclusion
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
The covid-19 pandemic had the effect of raising public awareness of adult social care. It also achieved general support for a tax increase specifically to plug the long- standing funding gap. However, the Government has missed this opportunity. It has done so firstly by allocating the vast majority of the …
Read more
The covid-19 pandemic had the effect of raising public awareness of adult social care. It also achieved general support for a tax increase specifically to plug the long- standing funding gap. However, the Government has missed this opportunity. It has done so firstly by allocating the vast majority of the proceeds of its Health and Social Care Levy to the NHS, and secondly by in theory ringfencing what little funding it has allocated to adult social care for reforms rather than for cost pressures. Members of the public are seeing taxes on their payslips going to health and social care, yet we heard the money going to social care “won’t touch the sides”.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that the savings from delaying the implementation of charging reform are being retained in local authority budgets to help them meet the current pressures in social care, with additional funding being provided.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
10
Conclusion
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
While the changed timetable for rolling out Section 18(3) will help to stagger the additional assessments local authorities will need to conduct, we are nevertheless concerned about local authorities’ capacity to conduct tens of thousands of additional assessments, particularly given the size of the backlog that already exists. We are …
Read more
While the changed timetable for rolling out Section 18(3) will help to stagger the additional assessments local authorities will need to conduct, we are nevertheless concerned about local authorities’ capacity to conduct tens of thousands of additional assessments, particularly given the size of the backlog that already exists. We are further concerned that the Government’s proposed workarounds will place additional strain on those requesting care and care workers, and could lead to an inconsistent service being provided and an increase in complaints. The Government’s re-evaluation of the combined impact of its charging reforms, Section 18(3), and the fair cost of care should include a revisiting of the recruitment and training needs of assessors.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it is committed to addressing the pressures facing social care and continues to provide significant additional grant funding to councils.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
15
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
We recognise the benefits of raising a proportion of funding for adult social care locally. As we have argued in previous reports, we support greater fiscal devolution. In finding the right balance of funding sources for adult social care, however, we are concerned by the increasing reliance on locally raised …
Read more
We recognise the benefits of raising a proportion of funding for adult social care locally. As we have argued in previous reports, we support greater fiscal devolution. In finding the right balance of funding sources for adult social care, however, we are concerned by the increasing reliance on locally raised tax revenue as currently constituted. In our previous report on local authority financial sustainability and the section 114 regime, we recommended a variety of ways in which the mix of funding to local authorities could be improved, including: resetting business rates, implementing the Fair Funding Review, 75% business rates retention with additional funding put towards an equalisation grant, and revaluing council tax. For this inquiry, we heard that the amount that areas can raise through council tax is not related to need: often the places with the lowest income from council tax have a higher proportion of adults who are eligible for state support for their care. We also recognise that the decision to raise social care precept will become a harder sell for councils when residents have already seen their National Insurance Contributions increase to pay for health and social care. In deciding how much additional funding to provide from the centre for adult social care, the Government must proceed with the aim of rebalancing the sources of funding so there is not such a reliance on council tax.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that overall funding for health and social care will be maintained at the same level as if the Levy was in place, and that savings from delaying implementation of charging reform will be distributed via the existing Social Care Grant that supports …
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
16
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
One-year funding settlements and short-term grants are hampering local authorities’ ability to plan and to deliver value for money, which in turn affects local care markets as it makes it more difficult for local authorities to enter longer term contracts with providers. The Government must provide a multi-year funding settlement …
Read more
One-year funding settlements and short-term grants are hampering local authorities’ ability to plan and to deliver value for money, which in turn affects local care markets as it makes it more difficult for local authorities to enter longer term contracts with providers. The Government must provide a multi-year funding settlement to give local authorities the visibility they need both for their own sustainability and also to help shape sustainable local care markets. It should also aim to make announcements about grants and social care precept at an earlier stage in councils’ budgeting cycle.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that in developing the People at the Heart of Care white paper, it engaged extensively with other government departments, and has worked closely with colleagues across government since the white paper publication to produce the recently published Next Steps to Put People …
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
18
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
The Department for Health and Social Care is drip-feeding numerous policy changes in adult social care, many of which are welcome, but many of which will have a significant impact on local authorities in terms of their spending and capacity. These include the cap and new means test, commencing Section …
Read more
The Department for Health and Social Care is drip-feeding numerous policy changes in adult social care, many of which are welcome, but many of which will have a significant impact on local authorities in terms of their spending and capacity. These include the cap and new means test, commencing Section 18(3) of the Care Act 2014 in respect of residential care, the fair cost of care, reforms in the People at the Heart of Care White Paper around housing, data, and assurance, and reforms in the Joining up Care for People, Places and Populations White Paper around health and care integration. We understand that local authorities are working closely with central government on these reforms. But we are concerned that the Government does not have a handle on what the total impact on local authorities will be. The 76 Long-term funding of adult social care Government should publish a new burdens assessment by the end of the year to determine the level of resource needed by local government in terms of staff, expertise, and funding to deliver the full package of adult social care reforms. (Paragraph 77) People at the heart of care: the direction of travel for reform
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that National Planning Policy already makes clear that local authorities must plan for a range of housing needs, including the needs of older and disabled people, and that they do not intend to introduce statutory requirements at this time.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
26
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
The Minister for Care and Mental Health asserted that the chapter on the workforce in the People at the Heart of Care White Paper is the Government’s social care workforce strategy, but the number of further calls for a social care workforce strategy that have been made since the White …
Read more
The Minister for Care and Mental Health asserted that the chapter on the workforce in the People at the Heart of Care White Paper is the Government’s social care workforce strategy, but the number of further calls for a social care workforce strategy that have been made since the White Paper’s publication clearly indicates that the contents of that chapter do not amount to a strategy, or are not what the sector expected to see from one. The Government should publish a 10-year strategy for the adult social care workforce. It should develop the strategy in collaboration with care workers, providers, local government, the NHS, unpaid carers, and people receiving care. The strategy should not just be a wish-list but needs to be a clear roadmap with core milestones, outcomes, and measures of success. We agree with the Government that retention should be a key performance indicator, but it is important that measures of success also include opportunities for progression, reduced prevalence of zero-hour contracts, and whether care workers feel valued for the highly skilled nature of their work. (Paragraph 117) 78 Long-term funding of adult social care
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees that ensuring there is holistic care that fits around people’s needs includes ensuring that people receive the right care and support, and can maintain healthy independent living, beginning with where they live, and the people they live with.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
27
Conclusion
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
We heard repeatedly that an absolutely critical lever for stabilising the adult social care market was tackling staff shortages and low retention. This would widen access to care and help to give unpaid carers a much-needed break. There is also the very real risk that the Government’s charging reforms do …
Read more
We heard repeatedly that an absolutely critical lever for stabilising the adult social care market was tackling staff shortages and low retention. This would widen access to care and help to give unpaid carers a much-needed break. There is also the very real risk that the Government’s charging reforms do not immediately improve matters, for instance by drawing more people into the care system without having enough workers to deliver the care for which these people will now be eligible. We were repeatedly told that the solution is to increase wages. It is little consolation to hear from the Minister for Care and Mental Health that only a fifth of the workforce is on the National Minimum Wage when we know how many workers are leaving the sector for higher paid jobs in other sectors, and that the sector struggles to compete with the NHS. While increasing wages would come at a cost, we were encouraged to see this as an investment because of the connection between wages and quality of care, the extra spending in our economy by better paid care workers, and the cost savings of retaining staff over having to hire more expensive agency staff. The Government’s proposals for health and care workforce integration in the Joining up Care for People, Places and Populations White Paper are welcome, but they must include a requirement to work towards achieving parity of pay for comparable roles across the NHS and social care. The Government’s guidance for fair cost of care exercises should require councils and providers to move towards pay rates for care workers that align with the NHS and that reward more senior staff with meaningfully higher pay than entry level workers.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government welcomes the committee’s interest in shared care records and notes its Digital Health and Care Plan sets out that health and care professionals will have access to a comprehensive view of a person’s health record by April 2025.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
28
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
We welcome the addition of care workers, care assistants and domiciliary care workers to the Shortage Occupation List, acknowledging that these roles are in short supply within the UK resident labour market. The Government should monitor the impact of adding care workers to the Shortage Occupation List on vacancies and …
Read more
We welcome the addition of care workers, care assistants and domiciliary care workers to the Shortage Occupation List, acknowledging that these roles are in short supply within the UK resident labour market. The Government should monitor the impact of adding care workers to the Shortage Occupation List on vacancies and be prepared to extend the visa period beyond 12 months, to lower the salary threshold, or both. (Paragraph 119) Unpaid carers
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government outlines existing funding allocated to support timely and safe discharge from hospitals through social care and reablement services, and integrated care boards commissioning step-down bed-based capacity.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
30
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
The Government claims “the money is there” to support carers’ breaks, but the evidence we received is that not enough carers are getting a break. There are many carers who have not had a break since the start of the pandemic. Providing intimate care, under pressure, for such a prolonged …
Read more
The Government claims “the money is there” to support carers’ breaks, but the evidence we received is that not enough carers are getting a break. There are many carers who have not had a break since the start of the pandemic. Providing intimate care, under pressure, for such a prolonged period, is bound to have an impact on a person’s mental and physical health. It is imperative that the Government announce additional ringfenced funding to enable more carers to take a break this year. (Paragraph 129) Long-term funding of adult social care 79
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government claims to already support carers through the Care Act 2014, the Better Care Fund, and an investment of up to £25 million for unpaid carers, stating the 2023-25 BCF framework will improve spend clarity.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
33
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
We welcome the Joining up Care for People, Places and Populations White Paper and commend the Government for making the integration of health and social care a policy priority. We particularly welcome the Government’s ambitions around shared outcomes, workforce integration, and ensuring every citizen has a shared care record by …
Read more
We welcome the Joining up Care for People, Places and Populations White Paper and commend the Government for making the integration of health and social care a policy priority. We particularly welcome the Government’s ambitions around shared outcomes, workforce integration, and ensuring every citizen has a shared care record by 2024. However, we are concerned that inconsistent geographical boundaries could result in gaps which could also hinder the successful pooling of budgets. In Spring 2023 the Government should review how many places have established governance and accountability models and their geographical footprints, and should work with local partners to modify boundaries if necessary to ensure all citizens can benefit from effective arrangements. The Government should also publish without delay its review of the arrangements that govern pooled budgets under Section 75 of the NHS Act 2006. The Government should seek to enable localised place-based arrangements between the NHS and individual councils, and pool budgets on that basis.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that much of the activity to integrate care should be driven by collaboration between commissioners and providers within integrated care systems (ICS) and will continue to work with place-based partnerships as they develop collaborative arrangements, including reviewing ICS boundaries in certain areas.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
35
Recommendation
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
Barriers to data-sharing between health and social care have been a long-standing challenge, so we particularly welcome the Government’s ambition to have shared care records for all citizens by 2024. It is vital that this ambition becomes a reality. 80 Long-term funding of adult social care The Government should set …
Read more
Barriers to data-sharing between health and social care have been a long-standing challenge, so we particularly welcome the Government’s ambition to have shared care records for all citizens by 2024. It is vital that this ambition becomes a reality. 80 Long-term funding of adult social care The Government should set up pilot schemes for shared care records, co-produced with people receiving care, carers, and care workers, and should report regularly on progress towards its 2024 target. Beyond 2024, the Government should publish annually the proportion of citizens who have shared care records and take steps to address any areas with particularly low take-up.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government claims to be addressing this already through the Digital Health and Care Plan, funding for integrated care systems to acquire shared record systems, and supporting local systems to develop care planning systems, including patient and carer input.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
36
Conclusion
Second Report - Long-term funding of ad…
Accepted
We are not reassured by the Director General for Adult Social Care’s comments that some places have found ways to continue discharge to assess funding from their own funding streams, not least by her admission that these workarounds are only short-term and only “for the bits of it they think …
Read more
We are not reassured by the Director General for Adult Social Care’s comments that some places have found ways to continue discharge to assess funding from their own funding streams, not least by her admission that these workarounds are only short-term and only “for the bits of it they think are vital”. The discharge to assess funding was an excellent example of effective health and care integration. Given the fragile state of adult social care and the magnitude of the NHS elective backlog, discharge to assess funding should be continued in order to help build back better. (Paragraph 145) Long-term funding of adult social care 81
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the positive impact of Discharge to Assess funding, stating they allocated £500 million in 2022-23 and provided £200 million to integrated care boards, and are providing £1.6 billion over 2023-24 and 2024-25.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government