Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Dumfries and Galloway Housing Partnership

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Upheld Reference 201503924 Sector Local Government Category repairs and maintenance Decided 01 May 2016

Full decision

Summary

Mrs C complained about the housing association on behalf of Mr A, a former tenant, regarding charges he had received for repairs required after he had left his property. He accepted that he had been asked at a pre-termination inspection to re-paint two walls but disputed the amount being requested, as he suspected that the amount was for further works that he was unaware of and had no opportunity to rectify.

Our investigation found that the association's communication with Mr A had been poor, with little information or justification given for the charges he was being asked to pay. We also found that the association's records showed that the works Mr A was being charged for were the painting of an entire room, including the ceiling and woodwork, even though only wall painting had been recorded as required on the inspection sheet signed by him and an inspector. Therefore, we upheld the complaint.

Recommendations

We recommended that the association: provide us with clarification of how the additional charge to change the locks was added to Mr A's invoice; calculate the amount payable by Mr A by determining what portion of the cost of the paint work related to two black walls; consider reducing the revised amount payable by Mr A by 50 percent in light of the administrative failures; apologise to Mr A for the failings identified; and reflect on the learning from this case to inform the review of the rechargeable repairs procedures they have advised us that they are undertaking.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201503924 as a PDF (13.81 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Dumfries and Galloway Housing Partnersh…

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201701597 01 Jan 2018 Mr C, who is a local councillor, complained on behalf of his constituents (Mr and Mrs A) who are tenants … Partly Upheld
201402759 01 Nov 2015 Miss C rents a property from the housing association. Over a number of years she experienced problems with the plumbing … Not Upheld
201405400 01 Sep 2015 Ms C brought a complaint to us on behalf of Mr A, who had complained to his landlord (the association) … Upheld
201305159 01 Feb 2015 Mr C complained about the housing association's handling of his representations about an incident that led to action being taken … Partly Upheld
201201479 01 Dec 2013 When Ms C moved to a new house she experienced problems of noise, harassment and intimidation and reported to the … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation