Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Dumfries and Galloway Housing Partnership

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201402759 Sector Local Government Category repairs and maintenance Decided 01 November 2015

Full decision

Summary

Miss C rents a property from the housing association. Over a number of years she experienced problems with the plumbing in her kitchen which affected her washing machine. She said she had to replace five washing machines at a substantial cost. She complained that, although the association ultimately fixed the problem, it took them several years to do so, and they refused her request for reimbursement of the cost of the replacement washing machines. Miss C also complained about the standard of other maintenance work carried out at her property. She said that this left her family unable to use the bedrooms. She felt that her rent should be reduced as a result of this.

We found that Miss C first raised the problem with her plumbing in 2011. We accepted that this was not resolved after two visits from a plumber, however, she did not raise the matter with the association again until 2014. As such, we were not critical of the association for failing to carry out further investigations until 2014. The cause of the plumbing problem was identified, but it was not resolved for five months due to an administrative error. We were satisfied that the association acknowledged and apologised for this oversight, and offered compensation in line with their policy. As Miss C did not provide evidence of her out-of-pocket expenses or the damage to her washing machines, we found it reasonable for her claim to be rejected.

We acknowledged that Miss C had found the other maintenance works to be disruptive, however, we were satisfied that the association considered whether temporary relocation to another property was required. We also found that work was carried out in line with their repairs and maintenance policy, and that the minimum standards expected of them were met.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201402759 as a PDF (11.46 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Dumfries and Galloway Housing Partnersh…

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201701597 01 Jan 2018 Mr C, who is a local councillor, complained on behalf of his constituents (Mr and Mrs A) who are tenants … Partly Upheld
201503924 01 May 2016 Mrs C complained about the housing association on behalf of Mr A, a former tenant, regarding charges he had received … Upheld
201405400 01 Sep 2015 Ms C brought a complaint to us on behalf of Mr A, who had complained to his landlord (the association) … Upheld
201305159 01 Feb 2015 Mr C complained about the housing association's handling of his representations about an incident that led to action being taken … Partly Upheld
201201479 01 Dec 2013 When Ms C moved to a new house she experienced problems of noise, harassment and intimidation and reported to the … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation