Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

University of Stirling

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201200674 Sector Education Category academic appeal/exam results/degree classification Decided 01 September 2012

View The University of Stirling scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Ms C had admitted that she consulted another student's work without referencing it when completing her dissertation. As a result, her dissertation was downgraded. She appealed this decision, saying that her health issues were not taken into account in assessing her work, but the university said that there were no grounds to take these concerns to their appeal panel.

Ms C complained to us that the university failed to adequately take into consideration her health issues when assessing her appeal and had failed to tell her that she could apply for an extension to her dissertation deadline. When we investigated, the university provided us with a number of documents that they make available to students. These included information which says that if there is a health problem, students should tell them at the time of the illness or shortly afterwards, and which explains how to request an extension to coursework deadlines and the grounds on which an extension can be granted. They also explained that, in cases of plagiarism and academic misconduct, motivation is not taken into account. As Ms C had been provided with and had access to information about how to inform the university of health issues and how to request an extension to coursework guidelines, we did not uphold her complaint.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201200674 as a PDF (11.33 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving University of Stirling

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201601679 01 Dec 2016 Mr and Mrs C complained that their daughter (Miss A) was not provided with reasonable university accommodation for her specific … Not Upheld
201406266 01 May 2015 Miss C was a self-funding postgraduate student who decided to withdraw from her programme after facing some personal difficulties and … Not Upheld
201204334 01 Sep 2013 Mr C complained about the university's handling of his appeal. Mr C was withdrawn from his post-graduate research because of … Not Upheld
201102387 01 Sep 2012 Mr C complained on behalf of a student nurse (Miss A). During Miss A's working placements, a number of concerns … Not Upheld
201004972 01 Nov 2011 Ms C was studying for a professional degree at the university. Following two instances of plagiarism, and because Ms C … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation