Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

University of Stirling

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201004972 Sector Education Category Policy/administration Decided 01 November 2011

View The University of Stirling scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Ms C was studying for a professional degree at the university. Following two instances of plagiarism, and because Ms C walked out of formal meetings, the university referred her to a fitness to practice hearing. Following the hearing, the university wrote to Ms C terminating her studies with immediate effect, and saying she would receive the award of a diploma in higher education.

Ms C complained that, during two meetings with the university (one about plagiarism, the other about placement), they did not support her or take into consideration that her personal circumstances had caused her to break down. She also complained that the fitness to practice hearing failed to take into account the circumstances she was in at the time of the two meetings, and she was not given the opportunity to provide an explanation for her behaviour. In addition, Ms C complained that, contrary to the university's policy and procedure for a fitness to practice hearing, they did not provide her with a copy of a briefing paper.

We did not uphold any of Ms C's complaints. As there were conflicting recollections of events, without direct objective evidence to support either Ms C's or the university's version, it was not possible to conclude with any certainty what actually happened at the two meetings or the fitness to practice panel. In relation to the briefing paper, we accepted as reasonable the university's explanation as to why, in the circumstances, they did not produce a paper on this occasion.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201004972 as a PDF (14.2 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving University of Stirling

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201601679 01 Dec 2016 Mr and Mrs C complained that their daughter (Miss A) was not provided with reasonable university accommodation for her specific … Not Upheld
201406266 01 May 2015 Miss C was a self-funding postgraduate student who decided to withdraw from her programme after facing some personal difficulties and … Not Upheld
201204334 01 Sep 2013 Mr C complained about the university's handling of his appeal. Mr C was withdrawn from his post-graduate research because of … Not Upheld
201102387 01 Sep 2012 Mr C complained on behalf of a student nurse (Miss A). During Miss A's working placements, a number of concerns … Not Upheld
201200674 01 Sep 2012 Ms C had admitted that she consulted another student's work without referencing it when completing her dissertation. As a result, … Not Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation