Recommendations 15 items · 1 repeated
Recommendations were extracted from the report by AI, and responses and their status from the ministerial response by AI. Each recommendation shows whether its wording has been checked against the report.
Response: Rejected
Addressee: Ministry of Justice · Topic: Resettlement
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that all prisoners serving indeterminate sentences for public protection (IPP) are released and, if recalled, are not automatically an IPP prisoner again (see paragraph 7.3.6).
Government response (as published)
I acknowledge the Board’s concern about prisoners serving indeterminate sentences for public protection (IPP) and when they are recalled on licence. The population of prisoners serving IPP sentences across the custodial estate was over 6,000 at its peak in 2012. The latest published figures show the unreleased IPP population stood at 1,895 at the end of September 2020, which is itself a reduction from 2,134 at the end of December 2019 – demonstrating good progress and improvement in opportunities available to progress in their sentence. However, it is important to note that, as the unreleased IPP population continues to decrease, those remaining in the prison population present the most complex and challenging cases. Many of these prisoners are still assessed as posing a high risk of committing further violent or sexual offences. HMPPS will continue to work with these individuals to offer opportunities to reduce their identified risks but ultimately these risks must be addressed before the independent Parole Board can consider the prisoner for release.
This is not a simple task but HMPPS remains committed to doing all it can to support the progression of IPPs and to help them reduce their risk to the point where the Parole Board determines that they may be safely released. Work is delivered via a joint IPP Action Plan, developed in partnership with the Parole Board which is regularly reviewed. HMPPS is prioritising post-tariff prisoners in accessing rehabilitative interventions which includes Psychology Service led reviews and enhanced case management for those with complex set of risks and needs. These reviews have identified pathways for individuals who have not progressed, following two or more parole hearings. The pathways include access to services available through the Offender Personality Disorder provision. To date over 1,500 reviews have taken place with 310 IPP prisoners having achieved release, and 394 having a progressive move to open conditions. HMPPS has also invested in four specialist Progression Regimes across the country providing 385 places dedicated to supporting indeterminate prisoners struggling to achieve release via the usual routes.
It was disappointing to hear that almost all of the 35 IPP prisoners released were subsequently recalled to prison (including 19 Lifers). The decision to recall is based upon the offender’s reported behaviour, there need not be a criminal conviction for a recall to be made. Equally, should authorities decide not to take further action against an alleged offence, or where the offence is considered by the courts by way of a further sentence, it does not automatically follow that the Parole Board will direct the recalled offender’s re-release on IPP licence. However, it is worth highlighting that an IPP licence remains in force for a minimum of 10 years and those recalled will continue to be reviewed under their IPP sentence in custody until the Parole Board has directed their re-release. They will then remain on IPP licence unless they are successful in applying for their licence to be terminated. There is a statutory requirement for the Parole Board to review each case for detaining a recalled IPP prisoner, and only they may direct the re-release. There are no plans to change this requirement.
Response: Implemented
Addressee: Ministry of Justice · Topic: Staffing
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that funding for prisons is sufficient to allow full regimes to be provided to all prisoners, officer training requirements to be met and the prison to be able to support prisoners’ rehabilitation, to enable their successful resettlement.
Government response (as published)
I acknowledge the Board’s comments about having sufficient funding to provide full regimes, meeting prison officer training requirements and supporting rehabilitation. Prisons at the moment are faced with the challenges surrounding Covid-19 and HMPPS has provided a helpful summary within the attached annex which sets out the position.
HMP Wealstun has sufficient funding in line with the operational staffing benchmark to provide a Covid regime / full regime and post Covid-19 recovery a new staffing profile will be introduced.
Response: In progress
Addressee: HMPPS · Topic: Safety
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that the requirements are clear about when prisons which were part of a pilot should undertake refresher training afterwards (see paragraph 4.5.7).
Government response (as published)
The four sites who piloted PAVA (incapacitant spray) are still considered as pilot sites whilst HMPPS continues to monitor and learn from their practices. This position will be reviewed as the wider rollout progresses and is eventually completed.
Response: Accepted
Addressee: HMPPS · Topic: Resettlement
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Consider whether locating IPP and life-sentenced prisoners at a prison without access to relevant programmes, and with ineffective processes to manage them, is an appropriate way to enable them to progress towards release (see paragraph 7.3.9)
Government response (as published)
Regarding the location of IPPs, it is accepted that these prisoners should be located at an establishment best placed to meet their sentence planning needs in terms of interventions, and for those assessed as needing access to certain interventions in other prisons staff will seek to find a suitable location as promptly as is reasonably possible. To support IPP prisoners, HMP Wealstun intends to recommence the monthly forum group by December 2020 and will also look at providing additional training and or one to one work to assist in terms of their sentence progression.
Response: In progress
Addressee: HMPPS · Topic: Resettlement
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Provide more category D open prison places, so that transfers are not delayed once a prisoner is recategorised (see paragraph 7.3.3).
Government response (as published)
As part of the 10,000 additional prison places programme, plans are also being developed to increase capacity in the Category D estate to enable more men to move to open conditions to support their rehabilitation. Locally, there are currently approximately 32 Category D prisoners held at HMP Wealstun. Several of these prisoners are deemed unsuitable for allocation to HMP/YOI Hatfield Category D Resettlement Prison as this establishment cannot facilitate supervised medication to the men held in their care. Some individuals are approved a move but require a completed offender assessment review prior to the transfer, due to a change in risk. The Category C estate is unfortunately currently inadequately resourced to enable these reviews to take place, creating a system grid lock. This grid lock is under review and HMP Wealstun is part of a pilot that intends to improve this capability.
Response: In progress
Addressee: HMPPS · Topic: Mental Health
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that as prisons move out of lockdown, any long-term effects on prisoners are identified and plans are in place to address them.
Government response (as published)
The key worker scheme has been largely targeted towards very vulnerable prisoners during Stage 4 of the Covid -19 regime delivery, as HMP Wealstun fully progresses into Stage 3, and when staffing availability allows, staff will start to deliver more key worker sessions. With the introduction of the new Offender Management in Custody staffing profile, this will allow for keyworker activity during the morning and afternoons to ensure all prisoners receive their allocated keyworker time. All Prisoner Offender Managers (probation, operational and non-operational) will be assigned an area of special interest, one of these areas will be IPP/Lifers.
Response: In progress
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Safety
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that once approval is given to resume training, refresher training in PAVA and rigid-bar handcuffs is given priority (see paragraph 4.5.6).
Government response (as published)
In response to ensuring HMP Wealstun’s prison officers are up to date with their training, the use of force instructors at all four of the pilot sites, which includes HMP Wealstun, were up skilled in both PAVA and Spontaneous Protection Enabling Accelerated Response training to then carry this training out with officers locally. Whilst the responsibility rests with individual prisons to ensure staff training is delivered and is current, HMPPS Safety and Rehabilitation Directorate were aware of some delays and the impact of Covid-19 has further hindered progress due to all training being paused. However, the prison has a Safe Operating Procedure in place and will commence training at the earliest opportunity. The Governor intends for staff to be fully compliant and receive their training by June 2021 with support from Physical Safety Group (Safety and Rehabilitation Directorate).
Response: Implemented
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Equality · Repeated from a previous year
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that adequate staffing is allocated to equality and diversity (disappointingly, an ongoing issue) (see paragraph 5.4.3).
Government response (as published)
Resources have now been provided to the Equalities team; the Senior Manager Equalities Lead position was re-evaluated and has been replaced with a Band 6 Equalities Manager who took up post in September 2020. A part time Band 3 Administrator has also joined the team.
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Regime
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that all relevant paperwork and witnesses are available for all adjudications, especially for those to be heard by the independent adjudicator (see paragraph 5.2.14).
Response: In progress
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Regime
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that when lockdown restrictions are lifted, key workers are fully in place for all prisoners (see paragraph 5.3.5).
Government response (as published)
The key worker scheme has been largely targeted towards very vulnerable prisoners during Stage 4 of the Covid -19 regime delivery, as HMP Wealstun fully progresses into Stage 3, and when staffing availability allows, staff will start to deliver more key worker sessions. With the introduction of the new Offender Management in Custody staffing profile, this will allow for keyworker activity during the morning and afternoons to ensure all prisoners receive their allocated keyworker time. All Prisoner Offender Managers (probation, operational and non-operational) will be assigned an area of special interest, one of these areas will be IPP/Lifers.
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Healthcare
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that Care UK has a process for replying to prisoner complaints within an agreed timescale (see paragraph 6.1.3).
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Regime
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that post is collected from the post room daily by the wing staff (see paragraph 7.2.4).
Response: In progress
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Resettlement
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that funding is available to reinstate the Resolve offending behaviour programme, given the significant number of prisoners with a history of domestic violence. (see paragraph 7.3.5).
Government response (as published)
Resolve OBP only ceased due to Covid -19 restrictions and although HMP Wealstun is hoping to procure a further years funding for Tackle It, the domestic violence programme run in partnership with Leeds Rhinos, this also will be subject to Covid restrictions as delivery of the programme involves group activity work. Recently six staff were trained to deliver Time Wise, an intervention designed to address violent behaviour which will be rolled out once the prison has appropriate IT to deliver it.
Response: In progress
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Resettlement
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Ensure that the monthly forum for IPP and life-sentenced prisoners with the OMU is reinstated (see paragraph 7.3.9).
Government response (as published)
To support IPP prisoners, HMP Wealstun intends to recommence the monthly forum group by December 2020 and will also look at providing additional training and or one to one work to assist in terms of their sentence progression.
Response: Rejected
Addressee: Governor / Director · Topic: Food
Recommendation (the Board's words)
Consider reducing the cost of food in the visits hall to the same as that in the staff mess (see paragraph 7.4.3).
Government response (as published)
The costing of items sold in the staff mess and the visits hall refreshment bar are not informed by regional policy. The staff mess is operated both as a learning and business enterprise by the provider of education Novus and HMP Wealstun has no influence over their pricing structures. The visits hall refreshment bar costing is in comparison and comparable to the services provided by a local community café and similar pricing to other establishments within the Yorkshire region.