Source · IMB Annual Report
New Hall
AI-generated report summary HMP/YOI New Hall received a generally positive assessment from the IMB for the reporting year ending February 2020, with prisoners treated fairly and humanely. The report highlighted improvements such as reduced self-harm, the introduction of in-cell telephony, and an outstanding education success rate of 96.69%. Key concerns, however, included long waits for mental health transfers, insufficient staffing and resources for vulnerable prisoners, and persistent issues with property transfer and resettlement accommodation.
Year: 2020
Published: 11 Nov 2020
Type: Prison · Cat women's, YOI
Population: 388
Recommendations: 4
Key concerns
Positive findings
Safety statistics
| Indicator | This year | Previous |
|---|---|---|
| Deaths in custody | 0 | — |
Positive findings
AI-generated summaryThe Board found that residents were treated fairly and humanely and were generally well-prepared for release. Improvements included a new gym floor, shower upgrades, building repairs, and the introduction of in-cell telephony. The prison successfully reduced self-harm incidents, improved reporting processes, and saw a reduction in the use of force. The approach to Equality and Diversity was embedded, with successful Pride in Prison and Black History Month events. Healthcare achieved a 90%+ recommendation rate from residents and ran a successful Hepatitis C testing program. Education provision was outstanding with a 96.69% success rate and high learner satisfaction, providing sufficient opportunities for 100% of the population. ROTL success was maintained at 100%, and good relationships with Probation and CRC providers supported resettlement. The St Giles House service was commended for securing accommodation, and Resettlement Days provided valuable support to prisoners prior to release, including efforts to secure employment with national employers like Greggs. Family Days were regularly arranged to maintain vital family contact.
Key concerns
The Prison Service needs to address the issue of residents with severe mental health problems waiting long periods of time in prison before transferring to more appropriate accommodation elsewhere.
Healthcare provision should be consistently delivered and sufficient staffing levels maintained to ensure the safety and well-being of prison staff and residents alike.
Current resources are grossly inadequate to ensure the effective management of those who reside and work on Holly House.
The IMB remain concerned that not enough is being done to address issues of Mental Health prior to women being sent to prison.
In addition, the buildings and fabric of the prison should not be allowed to fall below their current levels without redress. There can be lengthy delays in repairing or replacing faulty equipment [in the kitchen].
The Prison Service needs to address and introduce a more robust process to ensure that prisoners and their property are not separated during prison transfers.
Transportation of women to New Hall being a problem then and this remains so now. A woman can appear in court twenty miles from the prison and then endure a six to seven hour journey to the establishment. ...residents will frequently arrive in the late evening, tired and stressed. Late arrivals may also have to wait until the following morning for any medical needs.
In October 2019, the Equalities Officer was hospitalised and unfortunately no work was done with any of the groups during her absence. Also throughout the year prior to this, regime requirements caused her to be frequently deployed elsewhere. The response by management was disappointing.
The DIRF Scrutiny Panel which should meet quarterly has not now been convened since November 2018.
Although generally very open to seeking the views of residents, the complaints process requires some attention. The apparent lack of timely feedback to written concerns (which many residents view as formal complaints) feature heavily in Applications to the IMB.
Budgetary issues during the reporting period have impacted on education service provision. There is always frustration when classes are cancelled or residents are faced with regime restrictions. Some residents who remain on the Wings due to a lack of classes and also because of the restricted numbers who can attend.
There remains ongoing issues in relation to the timeliness of service provided by HOIE in relation to progressing the cases of those who have been identified as ‘of interest’ to and liable to Deportation by HOIE. ... the need to keep people in custody beyond their release date.
Accommodation is limited and often hard to find, particularly if the resident is a repeat offender.
Concerns relating to the trading and accompanying bullying and trading of vaping paraphernalia.
Recommendations
Healthcare provision should be consistently delivered and sufficient staffing levels maintained to ensure the safety and well-being of prison staff and residents alike.
Government response
NHS England commissioners and the prison regularly review the healthcare contract and the staffing resource at both the Prison Health Operational Group and Contract meetings. Staffing began to improve when the Board’s reporting period ended and an action plan is in place to ensure further improvements are made which is being monitored at each meeting. However, it is pleasing that the Board recognise the hard work of healthcare staff locally in providing critical services within a challenging population. Changes to the prison’s staffing profile during the Board’s reporting period has also ensured that operational staff are now available to support clinics in the healthcare centre.
Recommendation 2
The Prison Service needs to address the issue of residents with severe mental health problems waiting long periods of time in prison before transferring to more appropriate accommodation elsewhere.
Government response
I understand the Board’s concern about the time it takes to transfer prisoners with mental ill health to a secure unit. The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) and HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) are determined to improve the transfer process, ensure delays are reduced and avoid prison being used inappropriately.
The Secretary of State for Justice is committed to working with the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care and health partners to articulate a coherent picture of how healthcare is delivered throughout the criminal justice pathway. The Government is also committed to reforming the Mental Health Act and the MoJ is working closely with the Department for Health and Social Care to respond to the independent review, chaired by Professor Simon Wessely which includes recommendations about improving the secure transfer process. A joint White Paper will be published in the coming months.
Transfer times are improving at HMP/YOI New Hall with the last four transfers taking place within the guided timescales. NHS England and Improvement’s (NHSE&I) Specialised Commissioning team is continuing to work in collaboration with the Department of Health to review the process to ensure timely transfers under the Mental Health Act. NHSE&I also continue to monitor the time taken from referral to transfer and provide support where needed. Where there are any challenges delaying the transfer of care these are escalated within the Trusts and the Clinical Commissioning Groups on an individual basis. The 2011 Prison Transfer and Remission guidance has also been amended following a comprehensive consultation process and is waiting publication as the planned publication in March 2020 was impacted by the Covid-19 pandemic.
The regional Health and Justice commissioning team has also been working in partnership with the healthcare provider and HMPPS to develop a joint business case to increase the financial resource for Holly House based on the new trauma informed delivery model. While a review did begin at the start of the calendar year, Covid-19 has impacted on its progress. However, a bid has been submitted to the health commissioners for dedicated healthcare staffing for the unit.
A new prison functional head and custody manager are also now in post to refresh the project plans and individual care plan meetings are taking place, as well as an overarching meeting each week to monitor progress of women located on Holly House.
The Secretary of State for Justice is committed to working with the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care and health partners to articulate a coherent picture of how healthcare is delivered throughout the criminal justice pathway. The Government is also committed to reforming the Mental Health Act and the MoJ is working closely with the Department for Health and Social Care to respond to the independent review, chaired by Professor Simon Wessely which includes recommendations about improving the secure transfer process. A joint White Paper will be published in the coming months.
Transfer times are improving at HMP/YOI New Hall with the last four transfers taking place within the guided timescales. NHS England and Improvement’s (NHSE&I) Specialised Commissioning team is continuing to work in collaboration with the Department of Health to review the process to ensure timely transfers under the Mental Health Act. NHSE&I also continue to monitor the time taken from referral to transfer and provide support where needed. Where there are any challenges delaying the transfer of care these are escalated within the Trusts and the Clinical Commissioning Groups on an individual basis. The 2011 Prison Transfer and Remission guidance has also been amended following a comprehensive consultation process and is waiting publication as the planned publication in March 2020 was impacted by the Covid-19 pandemic.
The regional Health and Justice commissioning team has also been working in partnership with the healthcare provider and HMPPS to develop a joint business case to increase the financial resource for Holly House based on the new trauma informed delivery model. While a review did begin at the start of the calendar year, Covid-19 has impacted on its progress. However, a bid has been submitted to the health commissioners for dedicated healthcare staffing for the unit.
A new prison functional head and custody manager are also now in post to refresh the project plans and individual care plan meetings are taking place, as well as an overarching meeting each week to monitor progress of women located on Holly House.
Recommendation 3
In addition, the buildings and fabric of the prison should not be allowed to fall below their current levels without redress.
Government response
I am grateful to the Board for acknowledging the work that has taken place to improve conditions at the prison. Regarding the areas of concern, in total 154 reactive repairs have been required in the kitchen during the 12 months up to November 2020. This includes recent repairs to the flooring and the replacement of the hygienic cladding panels to the walls. Whilst most issues have been addressed there are some fridges still requiring parts; these are on order to enable completion. Repairs and the condition of the kitchen have been added as a standing agenda item at the monthly meeting between the Governor, HMPPS Prison Maintenance Group and the service provider, Amey, to closely monitor progress in this area.
Within the gymnasium, although the equipment remains the responsibility of the prison, a new floor has been installed and funding provided for new windows. It is hoped that this will be completed within this financial year 2020/21. In addition, over the past 12 months, 44 reactive repairs have been completed to improve the condition of the gymnasium. A previous unsuccessful bid to refurbish the showers will be resubmitted for consideration during the next financial year 2021/22.
Within the gymnasium, although the equipment remains the responsibility of the prison, a new floor has been installed and funding provided for new windows. It is hoped that this will be completed within this financial year 2020/21. In addition, over the past 12 months, 44 reactive repairs have been completed to improve the condition of the gymnasium. A previous unsuccessful bid to refurbish the showers will be resubmitted for consideration during the next financial year 2021/22.
Recommendation 4
The Prison Service needs to address and introduce a more robust process to ensure that prisoners and their property are not separated during prison transfers.
Government response
Further to the response to last year’s report sent to the Board on 27 January 2020, HMPPS has worked closely with stakeholders to consult on proposed changes to the new Prisoners’ Property Policy Framework. Discussions ahead of consultation with IMB members began with the IMB Secretariat in late February 2020, who proposed meetings take place with Board members in April. In light of the pressures placed on Boards by Covid-19, HMPPS agreed with the IMB Secretariat to pause this consultation until August and September. This work is now moving forward and the feedback received from IMB members at these meetings is being considered alongside the comments received earlier this year from other stakeholders. The intention is that the revised draft policy framework will be circulated for wider consultation at the beginning of 2021. The Prisoner Escort and Custody Services 4 Generation contract also began during August 2020 with a new fleet of vehicles which allow for an additional half box of consumable items to the limit of 7.5kg to be carried for each prisoner on top of the existing agreed volumetric limits. Locally HMP/YOI New Hall continues to monitor the transfer of prisoners’ property and where this is not received this is escalated with the sending prison at the earliest opportunity. In addition, HMPPS is taking steps to ensure there is a consistent approach when prison staff forward on any excess items to prisoners at their new establishment after a transfer has taken place.
Related inspections & investigations
Other reports for New Hall
Population 313
· Self-harm 1,162
· Concerns
Population 365
· Self-harm 1,032
· Concerns
Population 335
· Self-harm 609
· Concerns
Population 324
· Self-harm 965
· Concerns
Population 311
· Self-harm 467
· Concerns