Safety statistics
Incidents during reporting year
Positive findings
AI-generated summary
The prison was generally calm and settled, with good relationships between residents and staff. The Board was pleased to see the successful rollout of new body-worn cameras, addressing a long-standing issue, and noted significant improvements to the prison's fabric and cleanliness, including the boarding up of an unhygienic toilet. Cooperation between healthcare and custodial teams proved effective in managing the Covid-19 crisis, and innovative recruitment measures were adopted to address staff vacancies. The new 'Restart Dogs' programme was a welcome addition to purposeful activity.
Key concerns
6 items
Resettlement/Release
Repeated
prisoners’ property during transfer. This has been highlighted in at least our last three annual reports. Far more urgency needs to be applied to this problem.
Resettlement/Release
There should be focus on reviewing the sentences of imprisonment for public protection (IPP) prisoners, enabling them to progress and move towards a safe release. It is against natural justice that so long after this sentence was abolished so many prisoners are still in prison.
Resettlement/Release
Repeated
The Board continues to deal with a substantial number of property issues resulting from transfers from other establishments. More effort needs to be made to find a national solution to this problem. Despite a framework being developed in April 2020, nothing very significant seems to have happened and the IMB still chases property that has not arrived with the prisoner or is incomplete. No electronic system exists across the estate and prisoners still arrive with property cards.
Healthcare
Repeated
Accelerate plans for the conversion of the in-patient unit in healthcare to provide consultation and treatment rooms adequate for the number of residents in the prison. Should it be decided not to proceed with the above, then urgently upgrade the inpatient bath/shower room.
Healthcare
Liaise with the head of healthcare to reinstate escorts to outside hospital appointments to the levels in place the previous reporting year.
Safety
Repeated
Continue to encourage staff to make proper use of the BWCs which are now available and worn by frontline staff. Staff should be reminded that their value as de-escalation and evidential tools is only useful if they are turned on. This is essential for in-cell interaction where no other CCTV source is available.
Recommendations
6 items · 4 repeated
Addressee: HMPPS
The Board looks for positive timely action from the Prison Service regarding the point raised below: prisoners’ property during transfer. This has been highlighted in at least our last three annual reports. Far more urgency needs to be applied to this problem.
Repeated
Source text verified
Government responseI understand your growing concern about the loss of prisoners’ property and note unfortunately that applications about property issues represent the largest proportion received by your Board. Regarding the new Prisoners’ Property Policy Framework, the feedback received from operational engagement and internal / external stakeholders has been considered and, where appropriate, adjustments have been made. The framework aims to ensure that property is handled with efficiency, care and respect and that staff and prisoners are clear on the arrangements in place. It provides clear requirements and strengthens guidance on known problem areas. This includes providing stronger guidance to ensure volumetric control limits are respected, so that prisoners do not build up excessive amounts of property. It is now anticipated that the framework will be published this Summer.
While digital improvements to property processes are being explored, the nature of that work means that any digital changes are likely to be longer-term and will not be part of the framework at this stage. However, the planned introduction of digitally recorded Person Escort Records including property tags will enable better tracking of property in transit with Prisoner Escort and Custody Service (PECS) suppliers and will assist with investigations into the few complaints PECS receives about lost property. I was pleased to hear there are no significant issues relating to property management at HMP Dovegate.
Recorded status: In progress
Topic: Resettlement
Addressee: HMPPS
There should be focus on reviewing the sentences of imprisonment for public protection (IPP) prisoners, enabling them to progress and move towards a safe release. It is against natural justice that so long after this sentence was abolished so many prisoners are still in prison.
Source text verified
Government responseI acknowledge the Board’s concerns about the number of prisoners serving indeterminate sentences for public protection (IPP) who have completed their mandatory tariff period in prison. Since September 2016 a joint HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) and Parole Board IPP Action Plan has been in place, and regularly reviewed, to ensure a range of work streams are delivered, aimed at improving both the efficiency of the parole system and the progression opportunities of IPP prisoners. This commitment has in recent years delivered a substantial reduction in the number of IPP prisoners who have never been released. That number stood at 1,602 at the end of December 2021. This is reduced from 1,849 at the end of December 2020. This is very good progress considering that the population of unreleased prisoners serving IPP sentences was, at its highest in 2012, over 6,000.
Psychology-led reviews have been completed on over 1,300 IPP prisoners who are identified as being the most complex and challenging cases. These detailed reviews have led to improved individual pathways to progression, which are then overseen by the Prison or Community Offender Manager. The Government is providing opportunities for progression, which is evidenced by the continued high positive outcomes at parole hearings for IPP prisoners; in 2020/21 72% of IPP prisoners received either a release decision or a recommendation for a progressive move to open conditions. I acknowledge the amount of people being recalled to prison under the terms of IPP has risen significantly in the last five years. HMPPS is working with the Parole Board to ensure that the post-Recall review and management processes are as efficient and streamlined as possible, to ensure that recalled prisoners are re-released as soon as it is safe to do so. Currently, there are approximately 35 IPP prisoners at HMP Dovegate managed and supported through monthly oversight and assessed according to their most pressing need(s).
More broadly, the Justice Select Committee (JSC) appointed by the House of Commons has launched an inquiry into IPP sentences to explore the possible legislative and policy options available to the Government to further reduce the number of IPP prisoners. We look forward to hearing their recommendations and will be considering them closely. Furthermore, the HMPPS IPP Project Lead who is in regular contact with the prison team, has been impressed by their approach and invited them to contribute best practice ideas to the JSC’s call for written evidence.
Recorded status: In progress
Topic: Resettlement
Addressee: HMPPS
The Board continues to deal with a substantial number of property issues resulting from transfers from other establishments. More effort needs to be made to find a national solution to this problem. Despite a framework being developed in April 2020, nothing very significant seems to have happened and the IMB still chases property that has not arrived with the prisoner or is incomplete. No electronic system exists across the estate and prisoners still arrive with property cards.
Repeated
Source text verified
Government responseI understand your growing concern about the loss of prisoners’ property and note unfortunately that applications about property issues represent the largest proportion received by your Board. Regarding the new Prisoners’ Property Policy Framework, the feedback received from operational engagement and internal / external stakeholders has been considered and, where appropriate, adjustments have been made. The framework aims to ensure that property is handled with efficiency, care and respect and that staff and prisoners are clear on the arrangements in place. It provides clear requirements and strengthens guidance on known problem areas. This includes providing stronger guidance to ensure volumetric control limits are respected, so that prisoners do not build up excessive amounts of property. It is now anticipated that the framework will be published this Summer.
While digital improvements to property processes are being explored, the nature of that work means that any digital changes are likely to be longer-term and will not be part of the framework at this stage. However, the planned introduction of digitally recorded Person Escort Records including property tags will enable better tracking of property in transit with Prisoner Escort and Custody Service (PECS) suppliers and will assist with investigations into the few complaints PECS receives about lost property. I was pleased to hear there are no significant issues relating to property management at HMP Dovegate.
Recorded status: In progress
Topic: Resettlement
Addressee: Governor / Director
Accelerate plans for the conversion of the in-patient unit in healthcare to provide consultation and treatment rooms adequate for the number of residents in the prison. Should it be decided not to proceed with the above, then urgently upgrade the inpatient bath/shower room.
Repeated
Source text verified
Government responseThe Board will be pleased to hear that the inpatient unit Healthcare project work is progressing and the bath/shower room upgrade work should be completed by the end of this financial year (2021/22). I note you have raised some local issues of concern in your report which the Director will continue to keep you aware of as work continues.
Recorded status: In progress
Topic: Healthcare
Addressee: Governor / Director
Liaise with the head of healthcare to reinstate escorts to outside hospital appointments to the levels in place the previous reporting year.
Source text verified
Recorded status:
Topic: Healthcare
Addressee: Governor / Director
Continue to encourage staff to make proper use of the BWCs which are now available and worn by frontline staff. Staff should be reminded that their value as de-escalation and evidential tools is only useful if they are turned on. This is essential for in-cell interaction where no other CCTV source is available.
Repeated
Source text verified
Recorded status:
Topic: Safety
Related inspections & investigations
18 Sep 2023
HMIP · Unannounced
Safety 3
· Respect 3
· Activity 1
· Release 3
18 Sep 2023
HMIP · Unannounced
30 Sep 2019
HMIP · Unannounced
11 Feb 2021
PFD
Michael Dobson · State Custody related deaths | Mental Health related deaths | Suicide (from 2015)
14 Jan 2020
PFD
Marlon Watson · State Custody related deaths; Suicide (from 2015)
Other reports for Dovegate
2025
Published 17 Feb 2026
Population 1,160
· Self-harm 1,018
· Concerns
2024
Published 4 Mar 2025
Population 1,160
· Self-harm 814
· Concerns
2023
Published 7 Mar 2024
· Concerns
2022
Published 20 Jan 2023
Population 1,210
· Self-harm 650
· Concerns
2020
Published 26 May 2021
Population 1,160
· Self-harm 775
· Concerns