GEO Group states that as the contract for Harmondsworth IRC passed to Mitie, they cannot take action regarding working practices there. However, they will consider lessons learned from the inquest for their other operations. (AI summary)
Source · Prevention of Future Deaths
Brian Dalrymple
Ref: 2014-0410
Date: 18 Sep 2014
Coroner: Jeremy Chipperfield
Area: West London
Responses identified: 1 / 5
View PDF
The report identifies a lack of awareness among detention staff regarding indicators of mental health issues, a failure to act on recorded observations, inadequate medical visits to segregated detainees, and the absence of a comprehensive clinical record system.
Date
18 Sep 2014
56-day deadline
13 Nov 2014 est.
Responses identified
1 of 5
Coroner's concerns
The report identifies a lack of awareness among detention staff regarding indicators of mental health issues, a failure to act on recorded observations, inadequate medical visits to segregated detainees, and the absence of a comprehensive clinical record system.
View full coroner's concerns
In the circumstances it is my statutory duty t0 report to you: (1) There is a lack of awareness amongst detention staff at Harmondsworth of: behaviours (and reported experiences) which may indicate the existence of mental health issues affecting particular detainees-particularly in relation to schizophrenia; and (i) the need to ensure that such potential indicators are brought to the attention of those responsible for the particular detainee's healthcare_ Despite the training which had been received by such staff prior to Mr Dalrymple's detention indicators of his mental ill-health were not recognised as such. Witness] identified events and circumstances from the point of Mr Dalryple's presentation at port and throughout his period of detention that he said "should have been picked up" and triggered a psychiatric assessment (for which there was an "overwhelming need") in Mr Dalrymple's case such concerns were not properly acknowledged at Harmondsworth_ The DCOs had not received sufficient training in the recognition of relevant indicators The evidence was that officers were and remain unclear whether particular behaviours, unusual in local society at large, should be regarded as significant amongst the population at Harmondsworth: It was clear from the evidence given by the Deputy Immigration Manager, and that of a clinical Contract Manager Interim Healthcare Manager that significant reliance Is placed on the detention officers to raise concerns over a detainee's mental heath.
(2) Relevant and significant observations recorded by detention centre staff and others are not actively brought to the attention of relevant healthcare staff: In the present case, custody officers' entries in wing history records were sufficient (alone or in combination) to alert a reader t0 the possibility of mental health issues affecting Mr Dalrymple whilst delained at Harmondsworth IRC; these indicators were missed: In the terms of Witness the overall picture of developing (relapsing) mental disorder was not available to any one set of people.
(3) Medical practitioners may be employed at Harmondsworth IRC without knowledge necessary t0 that role: The locum GP who gave evidence at the inquest was unaware of Delention Centre Rules 2001 or of the duties imposed on him by them-rule 35, for example: He was also unaware that healthcare staff had access t0 wing history documents.
(4) Routine medical visits to segregated detainees are inadequate properly to assess detainees' healthcare needs; The evidence was that each detainee would be asked through (he wicket medical problems?" and if the answer was negative,there would be nO further interaction- #Any witness described the practice as "not iit for purpose (5) The absence of a comprehensive and accessible (computerised) clinical record relating to each detainee at IRCs Harmondsworth and Colnbrook
(2) Relevant and significant observations recorded by detention centre staff and others are not actively brought to the attention of relevant healthcare staff: In the present case, custody officers' entries in wing history records were sufficient (alone or in combination) to alert a reader t0 the possibility of mental health issues affecting Mr Dalrymple whilst delained at Harmondsworth IRC; these indicators were missed: In the terms of Witness the overall picture of developing (relapsing) mental disorder was not available to any one set of people.
(3) Medical practitioners may be employed at Harmondsworth IRC without knowledge necessary t0 that role: The locum GP who gave evidence at the inquest was unaware of Delention Centre Rules 2001 or of the duties imposed on him by them-rule 35, for example: He was also unaware that healthcare staff had access t0 wing history documents.
(4) Routine medical visits to segregated detainees are inadequate properly to assess detainees' healthcare needs; The evidence was that each detainee would be asked through (he wicket medical problems?" and if the answer was negative,there would be nO further interaction- #Any witness described the practice as "not iit for purpose (5) The absence of a comprehensive and accessible (computerised) clinical record relating to each detainee at IRCs Harmondsworth and Colnbrook
Responses
The GEO Group UK Ltd
Noted
Dear Inquest touching into the death of Brian Christopher Dalrymple Thank you for your letter dated September 2014 enclosing Regulation 28 Report and Record of Inquest: You will no doubt recall the written and oral evidence I gave in which [ explained all of the actions taken to address the concerns you raise in your letter and indeed other concerns already raised by GEO. As the Contract for the management of Harmondsworth IRC passed to Mitie on 01s September 2014, there is of course no practicable steps GEO can take in relation to the working practices at Harmondsworth: However; the lessons learned from Inquests such as this are invaluable and I can assure you on behalf of GEO that we will be considering them very carefully in relation to the company' $ other operations where appropriate, and in order to try and ensure that tragic deaths, such as can be avoided in future_ Inote that you have sent a copy of the report to Mitie. Please do not hesitate to contact me if [ can assist further:
Report sections
Investigation and inquest
The investigation into the death of Brian Christopher Dalrymple concluded at the end of the inquest on 27-Jun-14. The jury's conclusion of the inquest was "natural causes contributed to by neglect"; the medical cause was a ruptured dissection of the thoracic aorta and hypertension. The jury produced a narrative conclusion, a copy of which is atlached herewilh:
Circumstances of the death
Having entered the UK from the USA on 14-Jun-11, Mr Dalrymple was refused entry by the UKBA and detained at Harmondsworth Immigration Removal Centre pending removal: On 27-Jul-11, he was removed t0 Colnbrook Immigration Removal Centre where he died on 31-Jul-11 The fatal rupture was caused by extreme hypertension-a condition for which he declined treatment and monitoring for most of the period of his detention. He expressed unusual views about his ability to control hypertension (by spiritual means) as well as about other matters and exhibiled unusual behaviour during his detention_ After his death it was discovered that Mr Dalrymple was schizophrenic and had been prescribed medication for this condition in the USA The inquest considered issues related to his deleriorating psychiatric condition and capacity in detention, amongst others.
Action should be taken
In my opinion action should be taken lo prevent future deaths ad believe you have the power t0 lake such action:
Copies sent to
14 Jeremy Chipperfield kcupakou and The
Similar PFD reports
Related inquiry recommendations
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Training for IPC professionals engineers and clinicians
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
IPC role specifications and staffing levels
Southport Inquiry
Autism spectrum disorder police training
Southport Inquiry
Prevent training on online activity assessment
Southport Inquiry
Neurodiversity training for Prevent practitioners
Southport Inquiry
Balancing vulnerability with professional curiosity
Southport Inquiry
Sharing information about closed Prevent referrals
Southport Inquiry
Prevent Supervisor training on closure decisions
Southport Inquiry
Prevent referral training for organisations
Southport Inquiry
Taxi driver duty to report criminal activity
Report details
- Reference
- 2014-0410
- Date of report
- 18 September 2014
- Coroner
- Jeremy Chipperfield
- Coroner area
- West London
Responses identified
Responses identified
1 of 5
4 responses not yet linked
Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 13 Nov 2014 (estimated).
Sent to
- GEOAmey
- Nestor Primecare
- Serco
- Home Office
- Practice Plc