Source · Select Committees · Public Accounts Committee
Nineteenth Report - Regulation after EU exit
Public Accounts Committee
HC 32
Published 12 October 2022
Recommendations
2
Not Addressed
The regulators are struggling to recruit and retain the skills they need to regulate effectively...
Recommendation
The regulators are struggling to recruit and retain the skills they need to regulate effectively after EU Exit. Having left the EU, the regulators need additional staff to deliver their new and expanded responsibilities. CMA is competing with the private …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government states that the recommendation is implemented, then describes how they ensure compliance with Nitrogen Dioxide limits, the uncertainty in models, and monitoring networks.
HM Treasury
View Details →
3
Not Addressed
Potential large-scale reductions in staffing levels in regulators will not be achieved without fundamental changes...
Recommendation
Potential large-scale reductions in staffing levels in regulators will not be achieved without fundamental changes in regulatory approaches. In the Spending Review 2021, the regulators received funding settlements they believed were sufficient to enable them to fulfil their post-EU Exit …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation, but then describes the NO programme, Clean Air Zones and the Local Air Quality Management (LAQM) requirements.
HM Treasury
View Details →
4
Not Addressed
The loss of access to EU systems and lack of progress in taking forward the...
Recommendation
The loss of access to EU systems and lack of progress in taking forward the regulatory cooperation provisions set out in the Trade and Cooperation Agreement increase regulatory risks and costs. On leaving the EU, the regulators lost access to …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government disagrees with the Committee’s recommendation and explains that they hold robust information on spend for its two air quality programmes.
HM Treasury
View Details →
5
Not Addressed
Regulatory divergence between the UK and the EU and within the UK internal market risks...
Recommendation
Regulatory divergence between the UK and the EU and within the UK internal market risks increasing costs for businesses, but also offers opportunities depending on the approach taken. Following EU Exit there is already some divergence in regulatory approach between …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government states that the recommendation is implemented, and then describes the consultation on a revised National Air Pollution Control Programme (NAPCP) and strong governance arrangements.
HM Treasury
View Details →
6
Not Addressed
It will be vital for regulators to continue to develop their engagement on the world...
Recommendation
It will be vital for regulators to continue to develop their engagement on the world stage. Outside the European Union, the regulators have taken steps to increase their international influence and engagement, recognising the importance of sharing good practice, increasing …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The government states that the recommendation is implemented, and then describes the consultation on a revised National Air Pollution Control Programme (NAPCP) and strong governance arrangements.
HM Treasury
View Details →
8
Accepted
The regulators set out a number of ways in which they are addressing these skills...
Recommendation
The regulators set out a number of ways in which they are addressing these skills shortages. On recruitment and retention of veterinarians, FSA has worked with the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons to agree a temporary arrangement that allows veterinarians …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA has already taken steps to address the shortage of qualified veterinarians by working with the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons to allow overseas-trained vets to improve their English skills while working, improving the attractiveness of public health veterinary roles, providing additional funding to improve pay and conditions, and developing a graduate program.
HM Treasury
View Details →
10
Accepted
The regulators have since been asked (along with the rest of government) to model headcount...
Recommendation
The regulators have since been asked (along with the rest of government) to model headcount reductions of 20%, 30% and 40%, which would have significant impacts on these plans. In HSE’s case, it explained that if the reductions are modelled …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA's budget will be maintained at the level agreed at Spending Review 2021, until March 2025, though will need to absorb inflationary pressures. HSE will continue to prioritize its resources on the strategic objectives set out in the HSE strategy 2022-32.
HM Treasury
View Details →
11
Accepted
On leaving the EU, the regulators lost access to EU data sharing and cooperation arrangements.
Recommendation
On leaving the EU, the regulators lost access to EU data sharing and cooperation arrangements. CMA can no longer share confidential information with the European Commission or member states in merger, competition or consumer enforcement cases.28 FSA has also lost …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA and HSE will write to the Committee in six months setting out progress in taking forward the cooperation arrangements set out in the Trade and Cooperation Agreement.
HM Treasury
View Details →
12
Accepted
The regulators told us they are taking action to mitigate issues around access to data.
Recommendation
The regulators told us they are taking action to mitigate issues around access to data. For example, in competition and consumer law enforcement, CMA can investigate itself and use its own powers to gather information.31 Despite no longer being able …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA and HSE will write to the Committee in six months setting out progress in taking forward the cooperation arrangements set out in the Trade and Cooperation Agreement.
HM Treasury
View Details →
13
Accepted
The EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA) includes a provision to establish a separate agreement...
Recommendation
The EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA) includes a provision to establish a separate agreement on competition enforcement cooperation (including the 28 Q 52, 29 Q 52, C&AG’s Report, para 2.17 30 Q 57–58 31 Q 56 32 Q 65 …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA will write to the Committee in six months (April 2023) setting out progress in taking forward the cooperation arrangements set out in the Trade and Cooperation Agreement, and continues to provide input into discussions on the TCA, exchanging scientific evidence and risk assessments with EU institutions via DEFRA.
HM Treasury
View Details →
14
Accepted
Following EU Exit there is already some divergence in regulatory approach between the UK and...
Recommendation
Following EU Exit there is already some divergence in regulatory approach between the UK and EU. The regulators gave us examples where divergence was happening or could happen due to differences in opinion on what the evidence said or how …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA and HSE already have robust monitoring in place to keep track of regulatory divergence and its implications, including horizon scanning, stakeholder engagement, and tracking EU regulations related to pesticides, biocides, REACH, and CLP.
HM Treasury
View Details →
15
Accepted
The regulators also provided examples of divergence where the UK and EU were making decisions...
Recommendation
The regulators also provided examples of divergence where the UK and EU were making decisions to different timetables. HSE has been able to get a chemical onto the market quicker than the EU as it has carried out reviews of …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA and HSE already have robust monitoring in place to keep track of regulatory divergence and its implications, including horizon scanning, stakeholder engagement, and tracking EU regulations related to pesticides, biocides, REACH, and CLP.
HM Treasury
View Details →
16
Accepted
CMA stated that “there is some benefit, particularly for business certainty, in there being consistency...
Recommendation
CMA stated that “there is some benefit, particularly for business certainty, in there being consistency as between the UK and the EU.”46 This applies more widely than just in the area of competition and consumer protection, although the overall impact …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA has put in place a range of monitoring activities across its regulatory regime to keep track of differences in regulation within the UK and has processes to manage divergence with the EU, engaging with industry stakeholders.
HM Treasury
View Details →
18
Accepted
There is a risk that over time regulatory divergence (both between the UK and the...
Recommendation
There is a risk that over time regulatory divergence (both between the UK and the EU and between the four nations of the UK) may lead to increased administrative burden and regulatory costs for businesses. All three regulators use fee …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA has put in place a range of monitoring activities across its regulatory regime to keep track of differences in regulation within the UK and has processes to manage divergence with the EU, engaging with industry stakeholders.
HM Treasury
View Details →
19
Accepted
While the UK was an EU member state, the regulators exerted international influence primarily through...
Recommendation
While the UK was an EU member state, the regulators exerted international influence primarily through the EU, even where they took part in international fora as individual organisations.56 The regulators now represent the UK’s interests outside of the EU. The …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA will write to the Committee in six months setting out their plans for further international engagement including their objectives and timescales for action.
HM Treasury
View Details →
20
Accepted
The regulators are taking steps towards increasing their participation in international fora, as well as...
Recommendation
The regulators are taking steps towards increasing their participation in international fora, as well as developing bilateral agreements and relationships with counterparts.60 CMA signed a mutual assistance and cooperation framework with its counterparts in the United States, Canada, New Zealand …
Read more
Government Response Summary
The FSA will write to the Committee in six months (April 2023) setting out their plans for further international engagement, including objectives and timescales, and will continue to fulfill international trade obligations and engage in international fora like Codex, but will scale back bilateral engagements to map out how to best target international priorities.
HM Treasury
View Details →
Conclusions (4)
1
Conclusion
Acknowledged
On the basis of a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, we took evidence from the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), the Food Standards Agency (FSA) and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) on regulation after EU Exit.1
Government Response Summary
The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation and explains that it launched a comprehensive Air Quality Information System (AQIS) Review to ensure the public and vulnerable groups have the information they need, with outcomes to be published on UK-AIR, and a final report in early 2024, with a web system review to be completed by March 2025.
7
Conclusion
Acknowledged
Having left the EU, the regulators need additional staff to deliver their new and expanded responsibilities. CMA told us that it has always been in competition with the private sector for skilled competition lawyers and economists, and the expansion of its role after EU Exit means the scale of this …
Government Response Summary
The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation, and states that it anticipated that the contract will be let by the end of 2022 and the department will write to inform the Committee when this has happened.
9
Conclusion
Not Addressed
In the Spending Review 2021 (SR21), the regulators received funding settlements they believed were sufficient to enable them to fulfil their post-EU Exit regulatory responsibilities. FSA, for example, agreed a £122 million budget covering its work in England and committed to maintaining its 2019 headcount levels, with the exception of …
Government Response Summary
The government repeated the committee's conclusion.
17
Conclusion
Not Addressed
Outside the EU single market, there is also greater scope for England, Wales and Scotland to reach different regulatory decisions in areas of devolved competence, which include food and environmental protect. The regulators are working with the devolved administrations under a set of ‘common frameworks’ to reach an agreed way …
Government Response Summary
The government responded to a different recommendation.