Select Committee · Public Accounts Committee

Evaluating innovation projects in children’s social care

Status: Closed Opened: 26 Jul 2022 Closed: 24 Feb 2023 5 recommendations 14 conclusions 1 report

Since 2014 the Department for Education has provided over £300 million of funding to a range of “innovation projects”, intended to help local authorities improve outcomes for children and improve value for money children’s social care. In June 2024, the National Audit Office noted DfE’s exemplary approach to evaluation and learning in the programme. The …

Clear

Reports

1 report
Title HC No. Published Items Response
Twenty-Seventh Report - Evaluating innovation projects in c… HC 38 23 Nov 2022 19 Responded

Recommendations & Conclusions

5 items
2 Recommendation Twenty-Seventh Report - Evaluating inno… Accepted

We are not yet convinced the Department’s dissemination of learning from the programme is delivering...

We are not yet convinced the Department’s dissemination of learning from the programme is delivering widespread improvement. The Innovation Programme and its successor schemes have spread practice from six promising innovations across 57 further local authorities. There is some evidence that practice from the schemes is being taken up outside …

Government response. The government agreed and stated its strategy addresses the recommendation by promoting take up of well-evidenced models, using Practice Guides, establishing learning events, testing Family Network Support Packages, and delivering a fostering recruitment and retention programme.
HM Treasury
3 Recommendation Twenty-Seventh Report - Evaluating inno… Accepted

The Department does not yet have the data it needs to understand the impact of...

The Department does not yet have the data it needs to understand the impact of the innovation programme. Systems that provide high quality information to everyone involved can contribute to a culture of evaluation and an understanding of 6 Evaluating innovation projects in children’s social care what is working. Lack …

Government response. The government agreed and will publish a Children’s Social Care (CSC) data strategy by the end of 2023, developed with local authorities and sector experts, to improve data collection, transparency, and use for better outcomes.
HM Treasury
4 Recommendation Twenty-Seventh Report - Evaluating inno… Accepted

Potential innovation risks being hampered by inflexibility in the wider system of children’s social care.

Potential innovation risks being hampered by inflexibility in the wider system of children’s social care. The Department intended the Innovation Programme to both improve outcomes for children in the social care system and produce savings. Residential care in children’s homes is especially expensive, while outcomes for children appear better for …

Government response. The government agreed and stated its implementation strategy addresses the recommendation by working closely with DLUHC and HMT, pivoting service use to early family help and support, testing Family Network Support Packages, and delivering a fostering recruitment and retention programme.
HM Treasury
5 Recommendation Twenty-Seventh Report - Evaluating inno… Accepted

A challenging funding environment requires that government maintains its commitment to evaluation, and applies its...

A challenging funding environment requires that government maintains its commitment to evaluation, and applies its learning to secure better outcomes. As the Innovation Programme and its successor schemes move towards the end of 14 years of funding by 2027, the Department wants to see innovation and learning activity move into …

Government response. The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation and will demonstrate the benefits of its spending on innovation and evaluation by publishing a National Framework and Dashboard for consultation, and through continued support and funding for the What Works Centre for …
HM Treasury
6 Recommendation Twenty-Seventh Report - Evaluating inno… Accepted

The Department believes the impact of the Innovation Programme on the sector has been ‘transformational’.

The Department believes the impact of the Innovation Programme on the sector has been ‘transformational’. It describes the demand stimulated by the programme, having received over 200 applications for the first funding round of a programme where evaluation was a condition of funding.15 The Department also described issues caused by …

Government response. The government agrees to continue to promote and nurture a culture of evaluation through evaluating new proposals in the Care Review implementation strategy, and funding and support for a children’s services What Works Centre. A departmental evaluation strategy was published …
HM Treasury

Oral evidence sessions

1 session
Date Witnesses
8 Sep 2022 Isabelle Trowler · Department for Education, Susan Acland-Hood · The Department for Education, Suzanne Lunn · Department for Education View ↗