Recommendations & Conclusions
25 items
1
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
In Wales, farming is a vital profession, central to the preservation of the Welsh language and rural culture. Despite its significance, it remains a physically demanding, low-income sector, largely made up of small, family- run livestock farms with an average annual income of around £22,000. We acknowledge that remuneration is …
Read more
In Wales, farming is a vital profession, central to the preservation of the Welsh language and rural culture. Despite its significance, it remains a physically demanding, low-income sector, largely made up of small, family- run livestock farms with an average annual income of around £22,000. We acknowledge that remuneration is low considering the intensive, remote and year-round nature of the work. (Conclusion, Paragraph 16)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the essential role of the farming sector in Wales, recognizing its importance to the Welsh economy, life, and identity.
Read full response →
Wales Office
2
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
We re-emphasise the cultural importance of Welsh farms, which not only produce food but are the foundation stones of local communities and help sustain the Welsh language. A higher proportion of Welsh speakers work in agriculture compared to the general Welsh population, making the sector a linguistic stronghold. (Conclusion, Paragraph …
Read more
We re-emphasise the cultural importance of Welsh farms, which not only produce food but are the foundation stones of local communities and help sustain the Welsh language. A higher proportion of Welsh speakers work in agriculture compared to the general Welsh population, making the sector a linguistic stronghold. (Conclusion, Paragraph 17) Inheritance Tax Reforms
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the essential role of the Welsh farming sector in supporting its Growth Mission and contributing to Welsh life and identity.
Read full response →
Wales Office
3
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted
We support the objective of reforming Agricultural Property Relief (APR) and Business Property Relief (BPR) to close the loophole that encouraged wealthy investors to purchase agricultural land as a means of avoiding tax. (Conclusion, Paragraph 49)
Government response AI summary
The government details its announced reforms to Agricultural Property Relief and Business Property Relief, effective from April 2026, including an increase in the 100% relief allowance from £1 million to £2.5 million to protect more farms and businesses.
Read full response →
Wales Office
4
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted in Part
Impact Assessments based on farm valuations may offer a general indication of how many farms could potentially exceed the £1 million Inheritance Tax (IHT) threshold, however such assessments are limited. Without access to detailed information on individual farm circumstances, such as estate ownership structures, succession plans, and gifting arrangements, these …
Read more
Impact Assessments based on farm valuations may offer a general indication of how many farms could potentially exceed the £1 million Inheritance Tax (IHT) threshold, however such assessments are limited. Without access to detailed information on individual farm circumstances, such as estate ownership structures, succession plans, and gifting arrangements, these estimates lack precision and risk being misleading. We acknowledge that relying solely on farm valuation-based data could result in an inaccurate picture of the true impact of the IHT reforms on Welsh farming communities. (Conclusion, Paragraph 50) 40
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges concerns by increasing the 100% relief allowance for agricultural property relief from £1 million to £2.5 million, allowing couples to pass on up to £5 million tax-free, and refers to a published note detailing the reforms.
Read full response →
Wales Office
5
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Not Addressed
We are concerned that the UK Government has been unable to provide any clarity on the specific impact of its proposed IHT reforms in Wales or supply any Wales-specific data. Only UK-wide figures for farming estates potentially liable to pay IHT have been published, and no disaggregated data for Wales …
Read more
We are concerned that the UK Government has been unable to provide any clarity on the specific impact of its proposed IHT reforms in Wales or supply any Wales-specific data. Only UK-wide figures for farming estates potentially liable to pay IHT have been published, and no disaggregated data for Wales was provided to us by the Government. (Conclusion, Paragraph 51)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges concerns about IHT reforms by increasing the 100% relief allowance to £2.5 million, but does not provide clarity or Wales-specific data on the impact, instead referring to a UK-wide technical note.
Read full response →
Wales Office
6
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted in Part
We are also concerned that the change in policy may have a disproportionate impact on elderly farmers or those with terminal illness who have arranged their affairs on the basis that their estates would not be subject to IHT, and will not have an opportunity to change their succession arrangements …
Read more
We are also concerned that the change in policy may have a disproportionate impact on elderly farmers or those with terminal illness who have arranged their affairs on the basis that their estates would not be subject to IHT, and will not have an opportunity to change their succession arrangements in ways which would legitimately minimise any eventual IHT charge. We are also concerned by the effect of these tax changes on farmers in Wales which, as we heard from RABI, already have high rates of physical and mental ill health. (Conclusion, Paragraph 52)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges concerns by increasing the 100% relief allowance for agricultural property relief from £1 million to £2.5 million, allowing couples to pass on up to £5 million tax-free, following feedback from the farming community.
Read full response →
Wales Office
7
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Not Addressed
The Government was complacent in the way it introduced such a major change to the tax treatment of farms in Wales. The absence of an assessment of the impact on Welsh farming estates created a vacuum which was filled by different organisations publishing competing statistics which predicted a varying scale …
Read more
The Government was complacent in the way it introduced such a major change to the tax treatment of farms in Wales. The absence of an assessment of the impact on Welsh farming estates created a vacuum which was filled by different organisations publishing competing statistics which predicted a varying scale of impact for those who inherit farming estates. Consequently, an unnecessary climate of uncertainty and confusion has emerged in an industry central to the cultural, environmental and economic fabric of rural Wales. (Conclusion, Paragraph 53)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges concerns about IHT reforms by increasing the 100% relief allowance to £2.5 million but does not address the committee's criticism regarding its complacent approach or the absence of a Wales-specific impact assessment.
Read full response →
Wales Office
8
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Rejected
We are disappointed that the Government has maintained a complacent approach to measuring the impact of these tax changes despite the scale of public disquiet in Wales. In the absence of a Wales-specific Impact Assessment, the UK Government must delay implementing its final APR and BPR reforms until one has …
Read more
We are disappointed that the Government has maintained a complacent approach to measuring the impact of these tax changes despite the scale of public disquiet in Wales. In the absence of a Wales-specific Impact Assessment, the UK Government must delay implementing its final APR and BPR reforms until one has been published and scrutinised by the Welsh Affairs Committee. We recommend that, working in collaboration with the Treasury, HMRC, Wales Office and Welsh Government, all the available data that relates to farm ownership in Wales should be revisited to develop a more detailed understanding of the potential impact the changes to IHT may have on farmers in Wales who intend to leave their estates to the next generation of Welsh farmers. (Recommendation, Paragraph 54) Funding, Ringfencing & Barnettisation
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government rejects delaying implementation for a Wales-specific impact assessment, stating it has increased the APR/BPR allowance to £2.5 million after listening to feedback and that a technical note has been published for UK-wide changes.
Read full response →
Wales Office
9
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
We acknowledge that the UK Government’s decision to remove the ring- fencing and apply the Barnett Formula to future agricultural funding was made in response to a request from the Welsh Government. We note that the Welsh Government’s view on this decision has evolved over time. (Conclusion, Paragraph 65) 41
Read more
We acknowledge that the UK Government’s decision to remove the ring- fencing and apply the Barnett Formula to future agricultural funding was made in response to a request from the Welsh Government. We note that the Welsh Government’s view on this decision has evolved over time. (Conclusion, Paragraph 65) 41
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government confirms that agriculture and fisheries funding is now added to devolved governments' baseline, maintained in cash terms, and is no longer ringfenced, with the Welsh Government responsible for its expenditure.
Read full response →
Wales Office
10
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted
It is a fundamental principle of devolution that decisions affecting Wales should be made in Wales and that the Welsh Government should have autonomy over its budget, without ring-fencing imposed by the UK Government. (Conclusion, Paragraph 66)
Government response AI summary
The government confirms that agriculture and fisheries funding is no longer ringfenced and devolved governments, including Wales, now have autonomy to decide how to spend this funding from 2025-26.
Read full response →
Wales Office
11
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
We note the concerns raised by stakeholders during our oral evidence sessions about the potential for this change to lead to a reduction in Welsh agricultural funding. The evidence we received from the UK and Welsh Governments does not suggest that Welsh agricultural funding will decline following the removal of …
Read more
We note the concerns raised by stakeholders during our oral evidence sessions about the potential for this change to lead to a reduction in Welsh agricultural funding. The evidence we received from the UK and Welsh Governments does not suggest that Welsh agricultural funding will decline following the removal of ringfencing and the application of the Barnett Formula. The Welsh Government has allocated £366 million for agricultural support in 2025–26, £29 million more than the £337 million baseline set by the UK Government for the same period. (Conclusion, Paragraph 67)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government confirms agriculture and fisheries funding has been added to the devolved governments’ baseline from 2025-26, maintained in cash terms, and is no longer ringfenced, with the Welsh Government responsible for spending decisions.
Read full response →
Wales Office
12
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Rejected
To help safeguard the future of agriculture, we believe there is a strong case for the Welsh Government to maintain the practice of ring-fencing agricultural funding. This would provide continuity, certainty and ensure that all allocated resources are dedicated exclusively to supporting Welsh agriculture. (Recommendation, Paragraph 68)
Read more
To help safeguard the future of agriculture, we believe there is a strong case for the Welsh Government to maintain the practice of ring-fencing agricultural funding. This would provide continuity, certainty and ensure that all allocated resources are dedicated exclusively to supporting Welsh agriculture. (Recommendation, Paragraph 68)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government explains that agriculture and fisheries funding is no longer ringfenced, having been added to devolved governments' baseline, and that the Welsh Government is now responsible for how to spend this funding, thus not supporting the recommendation for continued ring-fencing.
Read full response →
Wales Office
13
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
We recommend that the Treasury and Wales Office work collaboratively with the Welsh Government to ensure that the baselining of agricultural funding into the Welsh Government’s block grant, alongside the application of the Barnett Formula to future allocations, does not lead to a real- terms decline in funding for Welsh …
Read more
We recommend that the Treasury and Wales Office work collaboratively with the Welsh Government to ensure that the baselining of agricultural funding into the Welsh Government’s block grant, alongside the application of the Barnett Formula to future allocations, does not lead to a real- terms decline in funding for Welsh agriculture. It is vital that this does not become a mechanism through which agricultural funding for Wales is gradually reduced, relocated or deprioritised in future spending decisions. (Recommendation, Paragraph 69) Trade
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that agriculture and fisheries funding will be added to devolved governments’ baseline funding from 2025-26, maintained in cash terms, and no longer ringfenced, with the Welsh Government responsible for spending decisions. It does not commit to preventing a real-terms decline.
Read full response →
Wales Office
14
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted
We welcome the foundational agreement between the UK and EU to establish a common Sanitary/Phyto-Sanitary (SPS) zone. However, we are concerned about the lack of a clear timeline for when an SPS zone will be established. (Conclusion, Paragraph 80)
Government response AI summary
The government states negotiations for a Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) Agreement with the EU have commenced and aims to conclude discussions and have legislative arrangements in place no later than 2027.
Read full response →
Wales Office
15
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted in Part
The UK Government must intensify efforts to fully establish an SPS zone with the EU, as a key step towards reducing trade friction for Welsh agricultural exports. We call on the Government to publish a roadmap for how they plan to establish an SPS zone between the UK and EU …
Read more
The UK Government must intensify efforts to fully establish an SPS zone with the EU, as a key step towards reducing trade friction for Welsh agricultural exports. We call on the Government to publish a roadmap for how they plan to establish an SPS zone between the UK and EU by May 2026. (Recommendation, Paragraph 81)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it is committed to working with the EU to advance an SPS agreement, describing it as a central element of their work to reduce agri-food trade friction and cut costs. However, the response does not commit to publishing a roadmap for how …
Read full response →
Wales Office
16
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Rejected
The UK’s Free Trade Agreements (FTA) with Australia and New Zealand will disproportionately disadvantage the agricultural sector in Wales. Beef and sheep meat make up a significantly larger share of the agricultural sector in Wales compared to England. As a result, Wales is more exposed 42 to the potential impact …
Read more
The UK’s Free Trade Agreements (FTA) with Australia and New Zealand will disproportionately disadvantage the agricultural sector in Wales. Beef and sheep meat make up a significantly larger share of the agricultural sector in Wales compared to England. As a result, Wales is more exposed 42 to the potential impact of imports from Australia and New Zealand under these trade agreements. We are concerned that, as these imports increase yearly, Welsh beef and lamb producers will face greater competition from Australian and New Zealand imports and may struggle to remain competitive. (Conclusion, Paragraph 89)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government rejects the committee's concern, stating there is no evidence that the FTAs have impacted Welsh beef or lamb production, as quotas have not been fully utilised and imports are primarily displacing other imports. They also highlight existing safeguard mechanisms within the agreements.
Read full response →
Wales Office
17
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted
We are concerned that Free Trade Agreements have been entered into in the full knowledge that Wales’ agricultural industry may be negatively impacted. The Government must ensure that FTAs do not act as a ‘Trojan Horse’ that, overtime, will undermine the viability of farming in Wales. Although Australia and New …
Read more
We are concerned that Free Trade Agreements have been entered into in the full knowledge that Wales’ agricultural industry may be negatively impacted. The Government must ensure that FTAs do not act as a ‘Trojan Horse’ that, overtime, will undermine the viability of farming in Wales. Although Australia and New Zealand do not make full use of their existing Tariff Rate Quotas, there is no room for complacency here given the extent of the challenge increased international competition will pose to the industry in Wales. (Conclusion, Paragraph 90)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it carefully monitors trade data and sees no evidence that FTAs with Australia and New Zealand have negatively impacted Welsh beef or lamb production, as imports are primarily displacing EU imports. It highlights existing safeguards within the agreements.
Read full response →
Wales Office
18
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Rejected
As the Tariff Rate Quotas progress towards a highly liberalised trade arrangement, the UK Government, in consultation with the Welsh Government and Welsh industry, should publish an action plan which sets out how farms in Wales will be supported to compete in the new market and how any negative economic …
Read more
As the Tariff Rate Quotas progress towards a highly liberalised trade arrangement, the UK Government, in consultation with the Welsh Government and Welsh industry, should publish an action plan which sets out how farms in Wales will be supported to compete in the new market and how any negative economic effects will be identified and mitigated. This plan should be prepared with the acknowledgment that its purpose is not only to protect individual Welsh farms but to maintain the economic and social wellbeing of rural communities across Wales. The action plan should be published by the end of May 2028 which represents the mid-point between implementation of the Australia and New Zealand Free Trade Agreements and the first significant milestone in the liberalisation of beef and sheep meat Tariff Rate Quotas. (Recommendation, Paragraph 91)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government rejects the need for an action plan, stating there is no evidence of negative impact on Welsh beef or lamb from current trade agreements, highlighting existing safeguards and its commitment to increasing export opportunities.
Read full response →
Wales Office
19
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted
We are concerned about the perceived disparity in production standards and the levels of financial support received by farmers in countries that the UK Government is negotiating trade agreements with. We are also concerned that lower-cost imports produced to less stringent standards could enter the UK market at prices below …
Read more
We are concerned about the perceived disparity in production standards and the levels of financial support received by farmers in countries that the UK Government is negotiating trade agreements with. We are also concerned that lower-cost imports produced to less stringent standards could enter the UK market at prices below the cost of domestic production in Wales, potentially undermining the competitiveness and long-term viability of Welsh farming. (Conclusion, Paragraph 96)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it carefully monitors trade data and has found no evidence that trade agreements with Australia and New Zealand have negatively impacted Welsh beef or lamb production, with imports mainly displacing EU products. It highlights existing safeguards within the agreements.
Read full response →
Wales Office
20
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
We recognise that there is some dissatisfaction among stakeholders concerning the effectiveness and scope of the Groceries Code Adjudicator. There remain concerns about whether the Groceries Code Adjudicator has sufficient powers to address the full spectrum of challenges facing the Welsh agricultural sector. (Conclusion, Paragraph 101) 43 The Future
Read more
We recognise that there is some dissatisfaction among stakeholders concerning the effectiveness and scope of the Groceries Code Adjudicator. There remain concerns about whether the Groceries Code Adjudicator has sufficient powers to address the full spectrum of challenges facing the Welsh agricultural sector. (Conclusion, Paragraph 101) 43 The Future
Show less
Wales Office
21
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
We support a long-term vision for farming in which generational transition within the sector is more actively supported. This includes creating clear and viable pathways for new entrants into farming, while ensuring that older farmers feel confident and assured to pass on their farms to a new generation of farmers. …
Read more
We support a long-term vision for farming in which generational transition within the sector is more actively supported. This includes creating clear and viable pathways for new entrants into farming, while ensuring that older farmers feel confident and assured to pass on their farms to a new generation of farmers. We are concerned that the UK Government fails to recognise that part of the uniqueness of Welsh farming is its larger network of tenant farmers than in England, which forms a key mechanism for allowing new entrants into the farming sector. (Conclusion, Paragraph 110)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the importance of supporting new entrants and tenant farmers in Wales, stating that Defra officials continue to work closely with the Welsh Government to develop programmes.
Read full response →
Wales Office
22
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
The UK Government should work in close partnership with the Welsh Government to develop more targeted support and technical upskilling programmes for young and new entrants into the Welsh farming sector. In doing so, it must actively promote and protect the vital role of tenant farming in Wales as a …
Read more
The UK Government should work in close partnership with the Welsh Government to develop more targeted support and technical upskilling programmes for young and new entrants into the Welsh farming sector. In doing so, it must actively promote and protect the vital role of tenant farming in Wales as a pathway into the industry. (Recommendation, Paragraph 111)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government recognizes the importance and states that Defra officials continue to work closely with the Welsh Government on shared challenges, remaining committed to constructive engagement as both governments develop programmes.
Read full response →
Wales Office
23
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
The UK’s food security is dependent upon sustainable domestic production, and by that measure the trends in Wales should be cause for concern. The number of people employed in the industry in Wales has declined, trade with key European markets has declined and livestock numbers in Wales have declined. We …
Read more
The UK’s food security is dependent upon sustainable domestic production, and by that measure the trends in Wales should be cause for concern. The number of people employed in the industry in Wales has declined, trade with key European markets has declined and livestock numbers in Wales have declined. We are concerned that a continuation of these trends might be seen as inevitable and policy makers in Cardiff and Westminster should focus on strengthening and growing the industry as part of a strategy to support domestic production and maintain UK food security. (Conclusion, Paragraph 117)
Show less
Wales Office
24
Conclusion
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Accepted
Farming practices and conditions in Wales differ significantly from those in England, and it is essential that these differences are fully understood by policy makers in Westminster. In its discussions with the UK Government, it is incumbent upon the Welsh Government to make the case for Welsh farming, but it …
Read more
Farming practices and conditions in Wales differ significantly from those in England, and it is essential that these differences are fully understood by policy makers in Westminster. In its discussions with the UK Government, it is incumbent upon the Welsh Government to make the case for Welsh farming, but it is essential that the Wales Office works to ensure that the needs of Welsh farming are accounted for in Whitehall as part of UK-wide policy development. Our report plainly shows that in this endeavour the Wales Office under successive Governments has not been as successful as it needs to be to build confidence among farmers in Wales. (Conclusion, Paragraph 121)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states that the Wales Office already supports UK Government departments in designing policies that reflect Wales' needs and works with them to assess policy impact in the agricultural sector.
Read full response →
Wales Office
25
Recommendation
2nd Report - Farming in Wales in 2025: …
Acknowledged
The UK Government needs to take specific account of the unique cultural, environmental and economic circumstances of farming in Wales when making future policy decisions which have direct implications for the agricultural sector in Wales. We recommend that any future policy decisions directly affecting the farming sector in Wales be …
Read more
The UK Government needs to take specific account of the unique cultural, environmental and economic circumstances of farming in Wales when making future policy decisions which have direct implications for the agricultural sector in Wales. We recommend that any future policy decisions directly affecting the farming sector in Wales be accompanied by a Wales- specific impact assessment led by the Wales Office and undertaken in conjunction with the Government department leading the relevant policy 44 change. This would ensure that the distinct characteristics and challenges of Welsh farming, particularly in comparison to England, are properly considered and not overlooked. A failure to account for the unique role farming plays in Wales, risks undermining the viability of rural farming communities, the Welsh language, and the future of farming in Wales. (Recommendation, Paragraph 122) 45
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states the Wales Office supports departments in designing policies that reflect Welsh needs and works with them to assess policy impact as appropriate, but does not specifically commit to Wales-specific impact assessments led by the Wales Office.
Read full response →
Wales Office