Recommendations & Conclusions
25 items
1
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
A lack of HGV drivers has concerned Government and industry for more than a decade. Too few people want to work in the sector, and the retention rate for those who become drivers is low. The covid-19 pandemic exacerbated those trends, turning a chronic problem into an acute one. The …
Read more
A lack of HGV drivers has concerned Government and industry for more than a decade. Too few people want to work in the sector, and the retention rate for those who become drivers is low. The covid-19 pandemic exacerbated those trends, turning a chronic problem into an acute one. The acute shortage may now be abating, but it is unclear whether progress and capacity will be sustained.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government recognises the difficulties caused by HGV driver shortages, noting that the recommendation has already been partially addressed as part of the '33 measures' interventions.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
2
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
In the past, the Department for Transport argued that the haulage sector itself was primarily responsible for addressing driver recruitment and retention. The unprecedented nature of the recent crisis led the Government to take a different tack. That change was welcome. However, the Government’s piecemeal approach has involved a range …
Read more
In the past, the Department for Transport argued that the haulage sector itself was primarily responsible for addressing driver recruitment and retention. The unprecedented nature of the recent crisis led the Government to take a different tack. That change was welcome. However, the Government’s piecemeal approach has involved a range of limited and/or temporary measures. Government intervention also gives the impression that the issue of driver shortages is for the Government alone to fix. Whilst the Government has a role to play, this is a private sector industry, and we believe the private sector needs to put its own house in order.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the central role of industry in ensuring a resilient workforce in the road freight sector and will continue to work with industry to make improvements for the long term and consider the need for short term mitigations.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
3
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
We want to see greater ambition, which means the introduction of a coherent strategic plan. In the five years since our predecessor Committee examined this issue, the sector has failed to solve its own problems. Little to no improvement has been made on a whole range of important issues. The …
Read more
We want to see greater ambition, which means the introduction of a coherent strategic plan. In the five years since our predecessor Committee examined this issue, the sector has failed to solve its own problems. Little to no improvement has been made on a whole range of important issues. The Government must force the pace and end years of industry inertia.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government welcomes the Committee's steer on the central role of industry, saying key issues are for industry to lead, but they will continue to work with industry and consider the need for short-term mitigations.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
4
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
One step the Government should take straightaway, as part of its review of the Driver Certificate of Professional Competence, is to ensure the logistics sector funds its own driver training, as is common practice in the bus and coach sector. It makes no sense that HGV drivers should have to …
Read more
One step the Government should take straightaway, as part of its review of the Driver Certificate of Professional Competence, is to ensure the logistics sector funds its own driver training, as is common practice in the bus and coach sector. It makes no sense that HGV drivers should have to pay their own training fees when we face continued shortages. (Paragraph 23) Retention
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government notes this recommendation has already been partially addressed as part of the '33 measures' interventions. A review into the mandatory Driver Certificate of Professional Competence (DCPC) training is underway to ensure it does not act as a barrier for drivers.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
5
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
Driving an HGV is a challenging job. It is physically demanding and involves lengthy, anti-social hours. The way in which drivers are treated and the conditions in which they are required to work can exacerbate those pressures. Unless these conditions improve, retention rates will remain low. Post-pandemic pay increases can …
Read more
Driving an HGV is a challenging job. It is physically demanding and involves lengthy, anti-social hours. The way in which drivers are treated and the conditions in which they are required to work can exacerbate those pressures. Unless these conditions improve, retention rates will remain low. Post-pandemic pay increases can only do so much to improve retention, particularly because the structure of the sector has tended to drive down pay rates in the past.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government notes the need for improved standards for HGV drivers, stating that industry must lead the implementation of working practices. They are investing £52.5M in roadside facilities and working with the sector on standards for HGV parking and facilities.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
6
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
The Government, in consultation with the sector, should devise a binding code of conduct setting minimum standards for employers’ and other businesses’ treatment of HGV drivers.
Government response AI summary
The government notes the need for improved standards for HGV drivers, but believes industry must lead the implementation of working practices. Government supports recent increases to remuneration and is providing £345,000 to support a recruitment campaign led by industry sponsorship.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
7
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
Overnight parking facilities for HGV drivers are insufficient, especially on key road freight routes. This lack of capacity is not new; the Department’s previous lorry parking survey identified it five years ago. (Paragraph 35) 32 Road freight supply chain
Read more
Overnight parking facilities for HGV drivers are insufficient, especially on key road freight routes. This lack of capacity is not new; the Department’s previous lorry parking survey identified it five years ago. (Paragraph 35) 32 Road freight supply chain
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government is gathering evidence through a 'National Lorry Parking Survey' to understand needed improvements, which will be published in early 2023. A £32.5M matched-funding grant will fund improvements to HGV driver facilities, and National Highways will invest £20m in improving roadside facilities on the …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
8
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted in Part
The Government should use the findings of its current lorry parking survey to set regional targets for building additional parking capacity. It should set up a joint Government-industry taskforce to ensure these targets are met.
Government response AI summary
The government will use its lorry parking survey results to inform a £32.5M matched-funding grant scheme for facility improvements and a £20M investment by National Highways. However, they do not intend to set up a joint Government-industry taskforce.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
9
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Deferred
Without clear direction from the Government’s planning legislation and guidance, building desperately-needed new driver’s facilities, and even upgrading old ones, is a tortuous process. Local authorities in Kent, and other parts of the country where supply chain movements are prominent, face an impossible task and cannot be expected to elect …
Read more
Without clear direction from the Government’s planning legislation and guidance, building desperately-needed new driver’s facilities, and even upgrading old ones, is a tortuous process. Local authorities in Kent, and other parts of the country where supply chain movements are prominent, face an impossible task and cannot be expected to elect to provide for lorry parks in their local plans in the face of opposition from residents impacted by such large projects. This is a national issue which requires a national Government fix.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government is prioritising the development of a call for evidence to understand the practical issues of planning for freight and logistics infrastructure. The program of changes to the planning system will include options to ensure sufficient land is allocated to service the needs of …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
10
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Deferred
The Government must build on its commitment in the Queen’s Speech to reform the existing planning framework and ensure that decisions for new driver facilities are not left to individual planning authorities. The Government must reform national planning policy to ensure that more driver facilities, which are fit for purpose …
Read more
The Government must build on its commitment in the Queen’s Speech to reform the existing planning framework and ensure that decisions for new driver facilities are not left to individual planning authorities. The Government must reform national planning policy to ensure that more driver facilities, which are fit for purpose and industry leading, are delivered. The Government must make an assessment as to whether the demand for new facilities can be delivered with only light reform. If it cannot, the Government should seek to take this dilemma from local authorities and local plans and place the responsibility at a central level. This would rightly recognise these facilities as key national infrastructure assets.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government is prioritising the development of a call for evidence to understand the practical issues of planning for freight and logistics infrastructure. The program of changes to the planning system will include options to ensure sufficient land is allocated to service the needs of …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
11
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
HGV drivers need safe and secure places to stop, to rest and to recuperate. Drivers told us that too often the facilities available to them were unfit for purpose. Rest facilities must be improved if more drivers are to remain in the sector.
Government response AI summary
The Government is considering what role standards have to play in driving improvements to driver facilities and encouraging providers to properly maintain and improve their business offerings, including on the areas raised by the Committee.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
12
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
The Government should set a minimum standard for driver facilities. This should cover: Ȥ Security to protect drivers and their vehicles; Ȥ Availability and cleanliness of toilet and shower facilities; Ȥ Food options, including healthy choices; and Ȥ Sufficient provision for female drivers.
Read more
The Government should set a minimum standard for driver facilities. This should cover: Ȥ Security to protect drivers and their vehicles; Ȥ Availability and cleanliness of toilet and shower facilities; Ȥ Food options, including healthy choices; and Ȥ Sufficient provision for female drivers.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government is considering what role standards have to play in driving improvements to driver facilities and encouraging providers to properly maintain and improve their business offerings, including on the areas raised by the Committee.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
13
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
The Government owns the freehold of a number of motorway service areas. Delays in negotiating leasehold extensions with operators are holding up necessary investments in some of these facilities. While the Government must, of course, ensure it receives value for money, it is disappointing how little urgency it has shown.
Read more
The Government owns the freehold of a number of motorway service areas. Delays in negotiating leasehold extensions with operators are holding up necessary investments in some of these facilities. While the Government must, of course, ensure it receives value for money, it is disappointing how little urgency it has shown.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government is assessing future ownership options for motorway service areas (MSA) freeholds and investing £52.5 million in roadside facility improvements, but makes no firm commitments regarding leasehold negotiations.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
14
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
The Department should inject more urgency and immediately escalate and prioritise negotiations to agree new leases with motorway service operators operating on Government-owned land.
Government response AI summary
The government is assessing future ownership options for government-owned MSA land to maximize taxpayer value and ensure responsiveness to future road users, and investing £52.5 million in roadside facility improvements including at MSAs.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
15
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
HGV drivers should not park overnight in laybys or other unsuitable locations. It leaves drivers vulnerable to crime and is not conducive to rest and recuperation. Yet some drivers are forced to do this as managed facilities are full, while others choose to, either to save money or because the …
Read more
HGV drivers should not park overnight in laybys or other unsuitable locations. It leaves drivers vulnerable to crime and is not conducive to rest and recuperation. Yet some drivers are forced to do this as managed facilities are full, while others choose to, either to save money or because the available facilities are poor. The only way to tackle HGV parking in laybys is to build new facilities and upgrade existing ones Road freight supply chain 33 to ensure there are enough spaces for all drivers. Only when drivers are not able to argue that there is nowhere else to park should penalties for parking away from managed facilities be increased.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government will launch a £32.5M matched-funding grant scheme for operators to improve HGV driver facilities and National Highways will invest £20m in roadside facility improvements. They are also gathering evidence via a 'National Lorry Parking Survey' to understand needed improvements.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
16
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
The fragmented nature of the road haulage sector makes it difficult for logistics operators to act in a concerted fashion to improve the conditions for HGV drivers. The actions of a few large companies, such as the major supermarket chains, exacerbates this. These companies use their market power to drive …
Read more
The fragmented nature of the road haulage sector makes it difficult for logistics operators to act in a concerted fashion to improve the conditions for HGV drivers. The actions of a few large companies, such as the major supermarket chains, exacerbates this. These companies use their market power to drive down costs but take no responsibility for the consequences. What is needed is a sector-wide solution, but, so far, despite a lot of warm words, the sector has failed to deliver this. Radical action is required to end this cycle of failure.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government notes the need for improved standards and safety for HGV drivers and supports improvements to working practices and facilities, but industry must lead the implementation of changes. Government is supporting a campaign to increase the number of people considering logistics as a career, …
Read full response →
Department for Transport
17
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
In other policy areas, where the Government has run out of patience with inertia, it has threatened industry with actions which would be taken if the industry does not find its own solution. Similar examples can be found in measures brought in to reduce sugar content in soft drinks and …
Read more
In other policy areas, where the Government has run out of patience with inertia, it has threatened industry with actions which would be taken if the industry does not find its own solution. Similar examples can be found in measures brought in to reduce sugar content in soft drinks and the use of packaging which cannot be recycled. The Government should mirror this approach in the logistics sector.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government notes the recommendation but highlights its existing 33 interventions to address the HGV driver shortage and says it will continue to engage with industry stakeholders.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
18
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
The Government should give the logistics sector two years to deliver sufficient drivers and high-quality parking facilities. If industry does not deliver, the Government should implement the levy charging mechanism and cause the industry to pay sufficient sums for the Government to build these facilities and pay to train new …
Read more
The Government should give the logistics sector two years to deliver sufficient drivers and high-quality parking facilities. If industry does not deliver, the Government should implement the levy charging mechanism and cause the industry to pay sufficient sums for the Government to build these facilities and pay to train new drivers, so they do not have to pay the cost of their own training. Such a mechanism must be accompanied by Government planning reforms in order for the industry to be able to deliver and avoid paying the Supply Chain Levy.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government has already put in place 33 interventions including skills bootcamps, using Brexit freedoms to allow regular drivers to tow a trailer, and investing more than £52 million to improve lorry parking and welfare facilities for drivers.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
19
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Not Addressed
The Supply Chain Levy should be applied to those at the production and sales end of the supply chain, such as large retailers, oil companies and online service giants. These organisations currently make large profits which do not trickle further down the supply chain to the companies which transport the …
Read more
The Supply Chain Levy should be applied to those at the production and sales end of the supply chain, such as large retailers, oil companies and online service giants. These organisations currently make large profits which do not trickle further down the supply chain to the companies which transport the goods. As a result, hauliers and ferry operators are posting operating losses and therefore cannot afford to increase the pay and welfare standards of those they employ. The Supply Chain Levy would require the parts of the supply chain where margins are greatest to deliver improved standards and the resilience to the supply chain which they themselves require to ensure their shelves, warehouses and petrol pumps are full. (Paragraph 59) Recruitment
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government notes the recommendation regarding a supply chain levy, stating that taxes are a matter for HM Treasury and are kept under review. They mention actions taken to improve standards and resilience, but do not address the levy itself.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
20
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
The average age of HGV drivers continues to increase. Although the sector is perhaps more open to female drivers than in the past, it has largely failed to attract a diverse workforce. It is disappointing how little progress has been made since our predecessor Committee reported five years ago. That …
Read more
The average age of HGV drivers continues to increase. Although the sector is perhaps more open to female drivers than in the past, it has largely failed to attract a diverse workforce. It is disappointing how little progress has been made since our predecessor Committee reported five years ago. That 1% of drivers are women, and only 3% of drivers are under the age of 25, should be a cause for shame for the industry and a clarion call to do more. The Supply Chain Levy we recommend, and resultant improvements in training and facilities, should assist in improving these appalling ratios. In addition, the sector must redouble its efforts to attract and retain a diverse workforce. (Paragraph 63) 34 Road freight supply chain
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government recognizes that the lack of diversity continues to present a barrier to solving labor shortages and supports the industry-led Generation Logistics campaign highlighting sector opportunities to under-represented groups.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
21
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
There are various routes to becoming an HGV driver. The sector does not find it difficult to recruit new entrants. It has struggled to make apprenticeships work as an entry point, because the role does not fit within the parameters set by the Department for Education’s various arm’s-length bodies such …
Read more
There are various routes to becoming an HGV driver. The sector does not find it difficult to recruit new entrants. It has struggled to make apprenticeships work as an entry point, because the role does not fit within the parameters set by the Department for Education’s various arm’s-length bodies such as the Institute for Apprenticeships and Technical Education and the Education and Skills Funding Agency.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states they have developed training routes including apprenticeships, with 2,599 lorry driver apprentices in training.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
22
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
We welcome the introduction of skills bootcamps as a faster, more flexible route to becoming an HGV driver. The Government should make the provision of skills bootcamps for HGV drivers permanent, with part of the scheme targeted at underrepresented groups in the current workforce. That policy could be funded from …
Read more
We welcome the introduction of skills bootcamps as a faster, more flexible route to becoming an HGV driver. The Government should make the provision of skills bootcamps for HGV drivers permanent, with part of the scheme targeted at underrepresented groups in the current workforce. That policy could be funded from the sector’s apprenticeship levy contribution. (Paragraph 70) Infrastructure
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees that bootcamps and apprenticeships have started to make an impact and will continue to monitor their progress and effectiveness, and has developed a wide range of other training routes to become an HGV driver and make financial support for training available.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
23
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Acknowledged
We welcome the steps the Government have taken to get more freight off our roads and on to our railways. We hope this is a process the establishment of Great British Railways will accelerate. The current model which sees freight moved from one end of the country to the other …
Read more
We welcome the steps the Government have taken to get more freight off our roads and on to our railways. We hope this is a process the establishment of Great British Railways will accelerate. The current model which sees freight moved from one end of the country to the other by road is illogical. Moving to a multi-modal model, in which long distances are served by rail and water and shorter journeys by road, will help the country decarbonise and improve the efficiency and resilience of the freight and logistics sector. It will also improve the lives of HGV drivers who would spend fewer nights away from home.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government agrees that more freight should be taken from the road and on to rail and water and is exploring the potential to increase rail freight capacity on the rail network to help reduce carbon emissions from the freight sector.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
24
Recommendation
First Report - Road freight supply chain
Accepted
The Government, alongside the sector, must work together to set targets and deadlines to switch more freight from road to rail and water. This must happen alongside steps to decarbonise road freight itself.
Government response AI summary
The government supports modal shift of freight from road to rail and water, committing to a rail freight growth target, creating a Strategic Freight Unit, and providing £20m per year through mode shift freight grant schemes.
Read full response →
Department for Transport
25
Conclusion
First Report - Road freight supply chain
The introduction of the EU’s new Entry/Exit system later in 2022 threatens to cause further confusion, disruption, and delay at the UK’s border, particularly at the Port of Dover. The Minister stressed that other Departments were primarily responsible for the management of the UK’s borders. We recognise the division of …
Read more
The introduction of the EU’s new Entry/Exit system later in 2022 threatens to cause further confusion, disruption, and delay at the UK’s border, particularly at the Port of Dover. The Minister stressed that other Departments were primarily responsible for the management of the UK’s borders. We recognise the division of departmental responsibility, but managing disruption will be the responsibility of the Department for Transport. It is crucial the Government gets a grip of this issue and engages urgently not just with the European Commission but with its counterparts in France and Ireland whose trade could also be disrupted if a solution cannot be found. (Paragraph 82) Road freight supply chain 35
Show less
Department for Transport