Recommendations & Conclusions
5 items
6
Conclusion
3rd report - Problem drug use in Scotla…
Acknowledged
Given the severity of problem drug use in Glasgow, it is clear that decisive, radical action is needed. The Thistle is a gold standard facility and represents an intervention that is commensurate with the scale of Glasgow’s drug problem. However, it is also expensive. The Thistle could prove good value …
Read more
Given the severity of problem drug use in Glasgow, it is clear that decisive, radical action is needed. The Thistle is a gold standard facility and represents an intervention that is commensurate with the scale of Glasgow’s drug problem. However, it is also expensive. The Thistle could prove good value by saving money elsewhere in the health service, but it will be for the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council to determine this following the evaluation, and to decide whether to continue The Thistle’s funding beyond the three-year pilot. We note that The Thistle is described as ‘gold standard’, and consider that a less sophisticated model of the facility could potentially offer corresponding harm reduction benefits, at a reduced cost. But, given that the pilot is being run as the stated ‘gold standard’ model, the effectiveness and therefore value for money and harm reduction capability of a less sophisticated model would remain untested and therefore largely unknown. (Conclusion, Paragraph 82)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government notes that The Thistle is subject to an independent evaluation and states they will welcome any evidence that emerges following the three-year pilot.
Read full response →
Scotland Office
7
Conclusion
3rd report - Problem drug use in Scotla…
Acknowledged
However, any discussion of the cost of The Thistle must be considered in the context of Scotland’s drugs crisis, with 1,172 people having died from drugs in 2023 alone. While it is right that the cost of The Thistle is properly considered, it must be recognised that the scale of …
Read more
However, any discussion of the cost of The Thistle must be considered in the context of Scotland’s drugs crisis, with 1,172 people having died from drugs in 2023 alone. While it is right that the cost of The Thistle is properly considered, it must be recognised that the scale of Scotland’s emergency inevitably requires a commensurate response that must entail significant investment. (Conclusion, Paragraph 83)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the Committee’s concern over drug deaths in Scotland and recognizes the specific challenges of substance misuse there, committing to work closely with the Scottish Government despite differing approaches.
Read full response →
Scotland Office
12
Recommendation
3rd report - Problem drug use in Scotla…
Acknowledged
It is vital that key stakeholders of The Thistle are engaged to address concerns about the impact of the facility and continue to work with the local community on how to address any concerns raised. We recognise that it may take time for the local effects of The Thistle to …
Read more
It is vital that key stakeholders of The Thistle are engaged to address concerns about the impact of the facility and continue to work with the local community on how to address any concerns raised. We recognise that it may take time for the local effects of The Thistle to be fully understood and assessed. We therefore await the independent evaluation to objectively understand the impact on the local community. (Recommendation, Paragraph 105) Expansion of services
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government notes that The Thistle is subject to an independent evaluation and states they will welcome any evidence that emerges as part of that following the three-year pilot, but does not commit to engaging stakeholders or taking specific action based on the evaluation.
Read full response →
Scotland Office
18
Recommendation
3rd report - Problem drug use in Scotla…
Acknowledged
The Minister has stated that the UK Government will consider the evidence emerging from the pilot. However, it was clear from the Minister’s evidence that the Home Office will not make legislative changes, even if the evaluation finds that the facility has been effective in meeting its aims. The UK …
Read more
The Minister has stated that the UK Government will consider the evidence emerging from the pilot. However, it was clear from the Minister’s evidence that the Home Office will not make legislative changes, even if the evaluation finds that the facility has been effective in meeting its aims. The UK Government should not approach the evaluation having already made up its mind about the future of The Thistle. The UK Government should seriously consider the evaluation and, if the outcomes are positive, should consider the merits of SDCFs alongside consideration of other interventions to tackle problem drug use. (Conclusion, Paragraph 135)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges its commitment to an evidence-based approach to drug policy within the law, citing various existing evidence-based programs as examples.
Read full response →
Scotland Office
19
Recommendation
3rd report - Problem drug use in Scotla…
Acknowledged
The UK Government must demonstrate that it has an evidence-based approach to policy making and will consider the independent evaluation of The Thistle. Any intervention found to be effective at saving lives and reducing harm should not be dismissed. (Recommendation, Paragraph 136)
Read more
The UK Government must demonstrate that it has an evidence-based approach to policy making and will consider the independent evaluation of The Thistle. Any intervention found to be effective at saving lives and reducing harm should not be dismissed. (Recommendation, Paragraph 136)
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges its commitment to an evidence-based approach to drug policy, citing existing programs like Individual Placement and Support, naloxone availability, and heroin-assisted treatment.
Read full response →
Scotland Office