Select Committee · Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee

Progress on devolution in England

Status: Closed Opened: 9 Mar 2020 Closed: 2 Mar 2022 22 recommendations 1 conclusion 1 report

Relaunched inquiry: Progress of Devolution in England The Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee has relaunched its inquiry into progress on devolution in England. The inquiry will scrutinise the impact of recently agreed devolution agreements and ask if the transfer of further powers to England’s regions can boost local economies and provision of public services. … Show more

Clear

Reports

1 report
Title HC No. Published Items Response
Fourth Report - Progress on devolution in England HC 36 1 Oct 2021 23 Responded

Recommendations & Conclusions

7 items
10 Recommendation Fourth Report - Progress on devolution … Not Addressed

The Committee has persistently sought clarity from the Government about how the UK Shared Prosperity...

The Committee has persistently sought clarity from the Government about how the UK Shared Prosperity Fund will work. The Government has had over four years to design and bring forward a coherent alternative to the European Development Funds that will completely end in 2023. This delay has been unacceptable and … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government's response is an exact repetition of the recommendation text, providing no substantive reply to the committee's proposals regarding the UK Shared Prosperity Fund.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
11 Recommendation Fourth Report - Progress on devolution … Not Addressed

A sustainable approach to local government funding requires longer term budgetary arrangements and discretion for...

A sustainable approach to local government funding requires longer term budgetary arrangements and discretion for local authorities and combined authorities over how to spend. We therefore welcome that the 2021 spending review will be multi- year. This reflects the wider need for a long-term plan to support the finances of … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government's response is an exact repetition of the recommendation text, providing no substantive reply to the committee's proposal for block grants and an end to ringfencing and competitive bidding.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
12 Recommendation Fourth Report - Progress on devolution … Not Addressed

We retain our predecessor committee’s scepticism about whether health devolution accurately describes the current arrangements...

We retain our predecessor committee’s scepticism about whether health devolution accurately describes the current arrangements in Greater Manchester. It clearly does not in Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly. We support the recommendations of the Health Devolution Commission on the future of health devolution and the role that should be … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government's response discusses the devolution of the adult education budget and the Department for Education's functions, completely failing to address the original recommendation regarding health devolution and a London Health Commissioner.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
13 Recommendation Fourth Report - Progress on devolution … Not Addressed

The devolution of the adult education budget should be part of the devolution framework, accompanied...

The devolution of the adult education budget should be part of the devolution framework, accompanied by transitional support and measures to mitigate differences in course options between areas. The same powers over adult education should be available to all areas with devolution deals. Further education, in particular FE colleges, should … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government's response discusses housing and planning powers, Mayoral Development Corporations, and streamlining funding, completely failing to address the recommendation regarding the devolution of the adult education budget, FE colleges, or strengthening local authority oversight of schools.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
14 Recommendation Fourth Report - Progress on devolution … Not Addressed

The devolution framework should provide for the devolution to combined and local authorities of the...

The devolution framework should provide for the devolution to combined and local authorities of the spatial planning powers, call-in powers for planning applications, the powers to establish development corporations, compulsory purchase orders, consultation on strategic planning applications, and strategic infrastructure levies, currently exercised by some combined authorities. There should be … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government's response focuses entirely on transport systems, bus services, Network Rail, and the new Great British Railways, failing to address the recommendation for devolving spatial planning powers, housing powers, development corporations, or strategic infrastructure levies.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
15 Recommendation Fourth Report - Progress on devolution … Not Addressed

The Government should consider the case for extending powers for Transport for London-style oversight of...

The Government should consider the case for extending powers for Transport for London-style oversight of local buses to all transport authorities, whether combined or local authorities. Where transport services cross local authority boundaries, joint working relationships should be encouraged between the local authorities affected. Similarly, Network Rail, Highways England and … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government's response focuses on local authorities' role in net zero, climate action plans, Local Nature Recovery Strategies, and public asset takeovers, completely failing to address the recommendation regarding Transport for London-style oversight for buses, joint working arrangements for transport services, or scrutiny of transport.
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
16 Recommendation Fourth Report - Progress on devolution … Not Addressed

We have heard, both in this inquiry and our inquiry into local government and the...

We have heard, both in this inquiry and our inquiry into local government and the path to net-zero, that local government can play an important role in policies relating to energy efficiency. The Government should strongly consider the case for devolution of further powers in this area. It should also … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government's response discusses the flexible approach to devolution through County Deals and the role of directly elected leaders or alternative governance models, but it does not address the specific recommendation to consider devolving powers related to energy efficiency, the environment, farming and forestry policies, …
Read full response →
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

Oral evidence sessions

5 sessions
Date Witnesses
25 Jan 2021 Cllr James Jamieson · Local Government Association (LGA), Rt Hon Greg Clark, The Lord Kerslake · UK2070 Commission View ↗
30 Nov 2020 Amy Harhoff · Durham County Council, David Williams · Hertfordshire County Council, James Palmer · Herbert Smith Freehills, Jamie Driscoll · North of Tyne Combined Authority View ↗
7 Sep 2020 Andrew Carter · Centre for Cities, Bill McCarthy · NHS England, Guy Ware · London Councils, Helen Charlesworth-May · Cornwall Council, Kate Kennally · Cornwall Council, Mr David Phillips · Institute for Fiscal Studies, Sir Richard Leese CBE · Manchester City Council View ↗
22 Jun 2020 Abdool Kara · National Audit Office, Andrew Walker · Local Government Information Unit, Jim Hubbard · CBI, Mike Short · UNISON, Mr Ed Hammond · Centre for Public Scrutiny, Simon Parkinson · Workers’ Education Association View ↗
16 Mar 2020 Dr John Stanton · City, University of London, Professor Colin Copus · De Montfort University, Professor Francesca Gains · University of Manchester View ↗

Who gave evidence

23 witnesses
WitnessOrganisationSessions
Abdool Kara · Executive Director National Audit Office 1
Amy Harhoff · Corporate Director of Regeneration, Economy and G… Durham County Council 1
Andrew Carter · Chief Executive Centre for Cities 1
Andrew Walker · Head of Research Local Government Information Unit 1
Bill McCarthy · North West Regional Director NHS England 1
Cllr James Jamieson · Chairman Local Government Association (LGA) 1
David Williams · Leader Hertfordshire County Council 1
Dr John Stanton · Senior Lecturer in Law City, University of London 1
Guy Ware · Director of Local Government Performance & Finance London Councils 1
Helen Charlesworth-May · Strategic Director for Public Health and Care Cornwall Council 1
James Palmer · Partner Herbert Smith Freehills 1
Jamie Driscoll · Mayor North of Tyne Combined Authority 1
Jim Hubbard · Head of Regional Policy CBI 1
Kate Kennally · Chief Executive Cornwall Council 1
Mike Short · Head of local government and education UNISON 1
Mr David Phillips · Associate Director Institute for Fiscal Studies 1
Mr Ed Hammond · Director Centre for Public Scrutiny 1
Professor Colin Copus · Emeritus Professor of Local Politics De Montfort University 1
Professor Francesca Gains · Professor of Public Policy University of Manchester 1
Rt Hon Greg Clark 1
Simon Parkinson · Chief Executive Workers’ Education Association 1
Sir Richard Leese CBE · Leader Manchester City Council 1
The Lord Kerslake · Chair UK2070 Commission 1

Correspondence

2 letters
DateDirectionTitle
1 Mar 2022 To cttee Letter from the Minister for Levelling Up, the Union and Constitution to the Ch…
29 Jan 2021 To cttee Letter from the Minister for Regional Growth and Local Government to the Chair …