Select Committee · Foreign Affairs Committee

Coronavirus: FCDO response

Status: Closed Opened: 12 Mar 2020 Closed: 23 Oct 2020 8 recommendations 5 conclusions 2 reports
Clear

Reports

2 reports
Title HC No. Published Items Response
Third Report: Flying Home: The FCO’s consular response to t… HC 643 28 Jul 2020 13 Responded
First Report: Viral Immunity—The FCO’s role in building a c… HC 239 6 Apr 2020 0 Responded

Recommendations & Conclusions

3 items
2 Recommendation Third Report: Flying Home: The FCO’s co… Rejected

The FCO was given £75 million to help UK citizens return home.

The FCO was given £75 million to help UK citizens return home. However, only £40 million of this was spent. While no one would advocate waste, these funds were allocated to rescue British citizens and the amount unspent suggests that the lifelines that many needed were available but not used. … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government rejected the premise that unspent funds meant insufficient support, stating they will find funds if needed for further repatriations. They also clarified that they have not supported the repatriation of British nationals who permanently reside overseas, except for acutely vulnerable individuals on planned …
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
3 Conclusion Third Report: Flying Home: The FCO’s co… Rejected

The Government placed too much reliance on commercial carriers at the start of the crisis.

The Government placed too much reliance on commercial carriers at the start of the crisis. We were surprised that the Permanent Under-Secretary and the Minister gave different explanations for their Department’s decision to rely upon commercial flights. This decision was clearly made with cost saving in mind. Read more

Government response AI summary
The government defends its reliance on commercial carriers, explaining that it was necessary due to overwhelming demand, to avoid undercutting airlines, and to leverage existing air links, rather than being solely driven by cost-saving.
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office
4 Conclusion Third Report: Flying Home: The FCO’s co… Rejected

Whilst reliance on the commercial system may have been the most cost effective and convenient...

Whilst reliance on the commercial system may have been the most cost effective and convenient way to help the majority of travellers return to the UK, for some people this was not a practical solution. This included travellers who were vulnerable, those in the ‘high risk’ category and those who … Read more

Government response AI summary
The government rejected the idea of parallel chartered repatriation flights for vulnerable travellers, explaining that a dual approach with commercial routes was necessary to handle demand, avoid undermining airlines, and that financial assistance was provided to those in need.
Read full response →
Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office

Oral evidence sessions

3 sessions
Date Witnesses
30 Jun 2020 Jennifer Anderson · Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, Nigel Adams, Simon Manley · Foreign and Commonwealth Office View ↗
21 Apr 2020 Andrew Sanderson · Foreign and Commonwealth Office, Menna Rawlings · Foreign and Commonwealth Office, Sir Simon McDonald · Foreign and Commonwealth Office View ↗
17 Mar 2020 Professor David R Harper CBE · Chatham House View ↗

Who gave evidence

7 witnesses
WitnessOrganisationSessions
Andrew Sanderson · Finance Director Foreign and Commonwealth Office 1
Jennifer Anderson · Director for Consular Affairs Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office 1
Menna Rawlings · Director-General Economic and Global Issues Foreign and Commonwealth Office 1
Nigel Adams 1
Professor David R Harper CBE · Senior Consulting Fellow, Global Health Programme Chatham House 1
Simon Manley · Director General, C-19 Directorate Foreign and Commonwealth Office 1
Sir Simon McDonald · Permanent Under Secretary and Head of the Diploma… Foreign and Commonwealth Office 1

Correspondence

5 letters
DateDirectionTitle
10 Feb 2021 Correspondence with the Foreign Secretary on the Committee’s inquiry into "Flyi…
22 Jul 2020 Correspondence from Nigel Adams, Minister of State, regarding FCO consular resp…
23 Apr 2020 Correspondence from Permanent Under-Secretary of State, FCO, on Diplomatic Immu…
21 Apr 2020 Correspondence from Permanent Under-Secretary of State, FCO, on the EU Ventilat…
30 Mar 2020 Correspondence to the Foreign Secretary regarding the repatriation of UK Citize…