Source · Select Committees · Environmental Audit Committee

Second Report - The UK's footprint on global biodiversity

Environmental Audit Committee HC 674 Published 30 September 2021
Report Status
Government responded
Conclusions & Recommendations
31 items (17 recs)
Government Response
AI assessment · 31 of 31 classified
Accepted 6
Accepted in Part 2
Acknowledged 6
Not Addressed 14
Rejected 3
Government response
Fifth Special Report - The UK’s footprint on global biodiversity: Government Response to the Committee’s Second Report · published 1 Feb 2022
Read the government response ↗ Response on the Index
Filter by: Clear

Recommendations & Conclusions

14 items
3 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 25

We recommend that the Government urgently prioritise the development of the indicator on overseas environmental...

Recommendation
We recommend that the Government urgently prioritise the development of the indicator on overseas environmental impacts of UK consumption of key commodities, since a better understanding of the environmental impacts of imported products is crucial to meeting the Government’s objectives … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government details its Net Zero Strategy and the use of the Green Book for environmental impact in spending, but does not commit to developing the specific indicator on overseas environmental impacts of UK consumption or setting a related footprint target.
View Details →
4 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 26

Ministers should consider how best to encourage behavioural change towards more sustainable and ethical patterns...

Recommendation
Ministers should consider how best to encourage behavioural change towards more sustainable and ethical patterns of consumption. Subsidies, environmental tax measures and tax reliefs are some of the financial and fiscal tools available to government. The Public Accounts Committee has … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government's response focuses on environmental impact assessments within Free Trade Agreements and tackling illegal wildlife trade, rather than addressing the recommendation to encourage behavioural change through financial tools or the Treasury's approach to environmental tax measures.
View Details →
5 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 27

The Committee looks forward to seeing an ambitious approach from Government to embedding Net Zero...

Conclusion
The Committee looks forward to seeing an ambitious approach from Government to embedding Net Zero in all policy decisions in its forthcoming Net Zero Strategy.
Government Response Summary
The government's response details compliance with Greening Government Commitments and annual reporting on sustainable procurement and buying standards, but it does not address the committee's specific point about the ambition of its forthcoming Net Zero Strategy.
View Details →
6 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 28

In the Net Zero Strategy, the Government should commit to evaluating all taxation changes against...

Recommendation
In the Net Zero Strategy, the Government should commit to evaluating all taxation changes against how well they deliver on the Government’s environmental objectives. 48 The UK’s footprint on global biodiversity The Government’s approach to how taxation changes will be … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government's response discusses the forthcoming Government Food Strategy and environmental land management schemes, but does not address the recommendation to commit to evaluating all taxation changes against environmental objectives in the Net Zero Strategy.
View Details →
7 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 29

The Net Zero Strategy should include an explicit commitment to Net Zero stress test all...

Recommendation
The Net Zero Strategy should include an explicit commitment to Net Zero stress test all future fiscal events and a commitment to develop a nature stress test to be used for fiscal events. The Net Zero Strategy must be published … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government's response outlines broader commitments to green investment, anti-deforestation legislation, and international agreements, but does not address the recommendation for Net Zero or nature stress testing of future fiscal events.
View Details →
8 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 35

For the Government to make good on its support for environmental sustainability to be at...

Recommendation
For the Government to make good on its support for environmental sustainability to be at the heart of global production and trade, it needs to mainstream biodiversity considerations more consistently into its trade agreements and operations. Leaving the European Union … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government's response discusses the importance of financing for nature and the Global Environment Facility's performance, but does not address the specific recommendation to mainstream biodiversity considerations into trade agreements and operations.
View Details →
9 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 36

We recommend that sustainability impact assessments be conducted for all future trade agreements and that...

Recommendation
We recommend that sustainability impact assessments be conducted for all future trade agreements and that as part of the Government’s Nature Strategy the Government consider how to monitor and deliver environmental net gain in trade deals. In response to this … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government's response details its commitments and existing overseas development assistance programmes related to nature and biodiversity, but does not address the recommendations for sustainability impact assessments for future trade agreements or widening participation in the Wildlife Financial Taskforce.
View Details →
10 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 51

We welcome and agree with the Secretary of State’s analysis that addressing the sustainability of...

Recommendation
We welcome and agree with the Secretary of State’s analysis that addressing the sustainability of the UK’s global supply chains will be one of the most powerful ways in which the UK can reduce its adverse impact on levels of … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response is a verbatim repetition of the committee's recommendation, stating that efforts must be stepped up to make overseas biodiversity monitoring a reality, without outlining any specific government action to achieve this.
View Details →
11 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 52

Sustainable government procurement presents a pathway to increasing the sustainability of supply chains.

Conclusion
Sustainable government procurement presents a pathway to increasing the sustainability of supply chains. Yet Government performance against existing sustainable procurement policies has been unimpressive. The removal of the mandatory reporting obligation by Government departments against the Greening Government Commitments has … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government's response focuses on addressing climate change and biodiversity loss through COP26 outcomes and the Leaders' Pledge for Nature, failing to address the committee's specific concerns regarding sustainable government procurement and mandatory reporting obligations.
View Details →
12 Conclusion Not Addressed

We welcome the news that the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs is considering...

Conclusion
We welcome the news that the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs is considering restarting the routine reporting of levels of compliance with Government buying standards. We also note with approval the effect that Government commitments on the importation … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response is incomplete and only reiterates the committee's conclusion, failing to address the substance of the committee's welcome for routine reporting on Government buying standards and sustainable palm oil commitments.
View Details →
16 Recommendation Not Addressed
Para 57

90% of respondents to the Government’s consultation on new laws for forest-risk commodities believed proposals...

Recommendation
90% of respondents to the Government’s consultation on new laws for forest-risk commodities believed proposals should be extended so that it is illegal for UK businesses to use any key commodities related to deforestation in their supply chains. We agree … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response is incomplete and only reiterates the committee's recommendation, failing to address the substance of making it illegal for UK businesses and the finance sector to use commodities linked to deforestation.
View Details →
18 Conclusion Not Addressed

The UK Overseas Territories are home to 94 per cent of British endemic species and...

Conclusion
The UK Overseas Territories are home to 94 per cent of British endemic species and 90 per cent of the biodiversity for which the UK Government has responsibility. The territories are also of global importance given the large proportion of … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response merely repeats the committee's conclusion verbatim without providing any specific action, commitment, or further engagement.
View Details →
20 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 88

Consideration of natural capital must be a priority in the assessment of overseas development assistance...

Conclusion
Consideration of natural capital must be a priority in the assessment of overseas development assistance projects. Nature sustains all of us and becomes even more critical in a developing country context. We welcome the Government’s announcement of a new International … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government response is incomplete and only reiterates the committee's conclusion, failing to address the detail of how it will nature-proof ODA expenditure or the committee's regret regarding the source of international climate finance.
View Details →
23 Conclusion Not Addressed
Para 128

We reiterate our welcome for the UK Government’s leadership in establishing the Global Ocean Alliance...

Conclusion
We reiterate our welcome for the UK Government’s leadership in establishing the Global Ocean Alliance and signing the Leaders’ Pledge for Nature. We also welcome the establishment of nature as a key theme for COP26.
Government Response Summary
The government's response is a direct repetition of the committee's welcome for its leadership in establishing the Global Ocean Alliance and Leaders' Pledge for Nature, and for nature as a key theme for COP26.
View Details →