Recommendations & Conclusions
8 items
3
Recommendation
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
The Bill should maintain the flexibility to allow ministers to adapt to future science and intelligence, but Defra should include a ban on animals younger than six months, heavily pregnant animals, and animals which have been subject to poor welfare practices on the face of the Bill, rather than secondary …
Read more
The Bill should maintain the flexibility to allow ministers to adapt to future science and intelligence, but Defra should include a ban on animals younger than six months, heavily pregnant animals, and animals which have been subject to poor welfare practices on the face of the Bill, rather than secondary legislation. It should include a clear definition of ‘heavily pregnant’. Putting these prohibitions in primary legislation would be a serious and sincere statement about the value the Government attaches to animal welfare.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states its Animal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill addresses pet smuggling and includes a proposal to ban the movement of dogs more than 42 days pregnant, but indicates these measures will be implemented through secondary legislation rather than on the face of the Bill …
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
4
Recommendation
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
Currently pet smuggling is viewed as a low-risk and high reward crime. The UK must improve its deterrents against pet smuggling.
Government response AI summary
The government is exploring increased penalties for pet smuggling through a consultation and the Welfare of Animals (Kept Animals) Bill, with analysis of responses ongoing. The Animal and Plant Health Agency has also appointed two temporary officers to coordinate investigations and disrupt illegal imports.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
5
Recommendation
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
The Government should increase the sentences given to pet smugglers, including greater consideration of custodial sentences. Increasing prosecution rates must also be a priority, as prosecution rates are proportionately low given the estimated size of the trade. The Government should make use of its full suite of investigatory and enforcement …
Read more
The Government should increase the sentences given to pet smugglers, including greater consideration of custodial sentences. Increasing prosecution rates must also be a priority, as prosecution rates are proportionately low given the estimated size of the trade. The Government should make use of its full suite of investigatory and enforcement powers to pursue the money generated from pet smuggling.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government is considering increased penalties for pet smuggling through the Welfare of Animals (Kept Animals) Bill and a recent consultation, the results of which are being analysed. The Animal and Plant Health Agency has also appointed two temporary officers to coordinate investigations and disrupt …
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
15
Recommendation
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
A number of non-endemic canine diseases are on the rise in the UK. These pose a serious health risk to the UK pet population. There is a particular risk from street animals being rehomed in the UK and dogs which have been smuggled in. Leaving the EU gives the UK …
Read more
A number of non-endemic canine diseases are on the rise in the UK. These pose a serious health risk to the UK pet population. There is a particular risk from street animals being rehomed in the UK and dogs which have been smuggled in. Leaving the EU gives the UK an opportunity to introduce regulations that will provide increased protection for animal health and biosecurity, the Government should act on this opportunity.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The Government agrees with the committee's findings, has made B.canis infection reportable, and is considering additional steps for commercial pet imports and proposes changes to regulations to tackle low-welfare imports.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
17
Recommendation
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
Britain is a leading player in the global equestrian market, which provides significant economic benefits to the UK. The Government must enable the expedited movement of ‘high health status’ horses across Europe to protect this industry. An agreement on high health status horses would benefit all parties involved and has …
Read more
Britain is a leading player in the global equestrian market, which provides significant economic benefits to the UK. The Government must enable the expedited movement of ‘high health status’ horses across Europe to protect this industry. An agreement on high health status horses would benefit all parties involved and has been advocated by the British, Irish and French racing and breeding industries to the highest levels of the European Commission. (Paragraph 50) Moving animals across borders 37
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the benefits of streamlining equine movements and commits to exploring potential flexibility and continuing to work towards a satisfactory solution for ‘high health status’ horses, despite the EU Commission's stance on third-country rules.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
22
Recommendation
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
The proposals put forward in Defra’s upcoming equine identification consultation should be digital by design and easy to use, except in exceptional circumstances, such as the studbook network which is vital for the support of native, rare and indigenous breeds. It is our understanding that these systems already exist within …
Read more
The proposals put forward in Defra’s upcoming equine identification consultation should be digital by design and easy to use, except in exceptional circumstances, such as the studbook network which is vital for the support of native, rare and indigenous breeds. It is our understanding that these systems already exist within the industry. The Government should embrace these systems or guarantee interoperability with them. Alongside this new identification system Defra should develop a funded action plan to enforce the identification rules. The consultation should be published within the next three months and the action plan should be published within three months of the consultation’s conclusion. (Paragraph 63) Moving livestock
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government will launch a new public consultation early in the new year to improve equine ID and traceability, focusing on digitisation and ease of record updates, while preserving studbook arrangements. However, there is no commitment to a funded action plan for enforcement.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
25
Recommendation
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
The Government must ensure border control posts capable of processing live animals are operational by March 2022. This date is an absolute deadline rather than a target. These posts should be geographically spread around the country and provide appropriate capacity to meet market demand to prevent overly long journey 38 …
Read more
The Government must ensure border control posts capable of processing live animals are operational by March 2022. This date is an absolute deadline rather than a target. These posts should be geographically spread around the country and provide appropriate capacity to meet market demand to prevent overly long journey 38 Moving animals across borders times which endanger animal welfare. Defra should publish information relating to the location and capacity of specific border control posts by December 2021 to allow businesses to prepare for the March 2022 deadline.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the need for live animal border control posts (BCPs), stating the Sevington BCP will be operational from 1 July 2022 (later than the recommended March 2022 deadline), with a second Kent facility identified and further BCPs to be designated once complete.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
28
Conclusion
First Report - Moving animals across bo…
Accepted in Part
The movement of agricultural animals between Great Britain and Northern Ireland, a practice that has existed for generations, has been disrupted by the Northern Ireland Protocol. The residency, scrapie and ear tagging requirements risk jeopardising the genetic integrity of Northern Irish breeding stock. Although it is a small number of …
Read more
The movement of agricultural animals between Great Britain and Northern Ireland, a practice that has existed for generations, has been disrupted by the Northern Ireland Protocol. The residency, scrapie and ear tagging requirements risk jeopardising the genetic integrity of Northern Irish breeding stock. Although it is a small number of farm businesses that are affected, these are often small, independent, family run business and the impact of the restrictions could be catastrophic.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government has reached an agreement with the EU on livestock residency but notes that livestock identification remains an outstanding issue, with ongoing discussions to find a solution. The government will continue to monitor implementation and report back within 12 months.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs