Recommendations & Conclusions
6 items
3
Recommendation
First Report - COVID-19 and food supply
Accepted
It is entirely reasonable and predictable that consumers would want to buy more food in anticipation of a lockdown, the need to self-isolate if they developed COVID-19 symptoms; or school closures and changed working patterns resulting in more meals eaten at home. The Government and retailers, including convenience stores, failed …
Read more
It is entirely reasonable and predictable that consumers would want to buy more food in anticipation of a lockdown, the need to self-isolate if they developed COVID-19 symptoms; or school closures and changed working patterns resulting in more meals eaten at home. The Government and retailers, including convenience stores, failed to develop an effective joint communications plan in anticipation of increased consumer demand. At a time when the public was looking to the Government for advice on how to live safely, we consider that the Government could have made more effort to provide reassurances. In the event of further lockdowns or restrictions, the Government should ensure that more emphasis is placed on reassuring the public that there will be enough food and essential supplies for everyone.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it worked closely with supermarkets on messaging during the pandemic to reassure consumers. It commits to learning from the COVID-19 response and adapting its approach to future scenarios, aiming to deliver better aligned and joined-up communications with industry, placing more emphasis on …
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
7
Recommendation
First Report - COVID-19 and food supply
Accepted
The significantly increased demand for online shopping, combined with in-store measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19 and limit excessive buying, have had a negative impact on people who are not shielding but struggling to access food, despite being able to afford it. We accept that some mistakes and compromises …
Read more
The significantly increased demand for online shopping, combined with in-store measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19 and limit excessive buying, have had a negative impact on people who are not shielding but struggling to access food, despite being able to afford it. We accept that some mistakes and compromises were inevitable and that retailers, on the whole, responded well to the unprecedented situation, although they will need to adjust to different needs more quickly in future. However, we urge Defra to consult with retailers and charities to ensure that reasonable adjustments are made for this group of people as the pandemic continues. Ensuring that the necessary steps to contain future pandemics or other crises do not result in disproportionate impacts on people with disabilities or other vulnerabilities should be built into the Government and industry’s emergency planning. (Paragraph 35) Food insecurity
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government highlights its past and ongoing close collaboration with retailers, local authorities, and charities to provide support and priority delivery slots for vulnerable people not shielding. It commits to continuing this work with industry and stakeholders in the future to ensure these groups can …
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
12
Recommendation
First Report - COVID-19 and food supply
Accepted
The distribution of food parcels to people who were Clinically Extremely Vulnerable (CEV) and without other means of support was a valuable way of ensuring that those people had access to basic foodstuffs. We accept that many of the complaints about the contents of parcels were likely to relate to …
Read more
The distribution of food parcels to people who were Clinically Extremely Vulnerable (CEV) and without other means of support was a valuable way of ensuring that those people had access to basic foodstuffs. We accept that many of the complaints about the contents of parcels were likely to relate to the early food parcels made from the emergency bulk food offer from Government to local authorities. Once the centralised system was in place, it appeared to operate very well. However, if the Government repeats such an endeavour in future, such as during a second wave of COVID-19, it should make greater efforts to ensure that nutrition and dietary needs are given higher priority from the start.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the committee's comments on improving food parcel provision and commits to fully reflecting the experience and learning from the initial response in the design of any potential future service, should the national food box scheme need to be reinstated.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
18
Recommendation
First Report - COVID-19 and food supply
Accepted
The hospitality and foodservice sectors may take over a year to recover from forced closure and further financial difficulties are likely. The Government should work with producers, processors and wholesalers to understand their concerns and monitor the health of food and drink suppliers, particularly SMEs, over the next 18 months …
Read more
The hospitality and foodservice sectors may take over a year to recover from forced closure and further financial difficulties are likely. The Government should work with producers, processors and wholesalers to understand their concerns and monitor the health of food and drink suppliers, particularly SMEs, over the next 18 months as supply chains restart. In its response to this Report, the Government should include a plan for how it intends to support food and drink suppliers to the hospitality and foodservice sector during this turbulent time. (Paragraph 92) 50 COVID-19 and food supply Key workers in the food sector
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government acknowledges the difficulties faced by food and drink suppliers and outlines a comprehensive plan of existing financial support schemes, including a specific 'bounce back' package for food and drink SMEs (e-commerce, exports) and a VAT cut for hospitality, to support the sector during …
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
20
Recommendation
First Report - COVID-19 and food supply
Accepted
Guidance on measures that businesses should take to protect workers, such as guidance on how to introduce social distancing and the use of personal protective equipment, was not issued quickly enough. We commend the processors, manufacturers, retailers and trade unions that developed and implemented COVID- secure working practices before the …
Read more
Guidance on measures that businesses should take to protect workers, such as guidance on how to introduce social distancing and the use of personal protective equipment, was not issued quickly enough. We commend the processors, manufacturers, retailers and trade unions that developed and implemented COVID- secure working practices before the Government had issued satisfactory guidance. It is disappointing that guidance on social distancing in the workplace was only published in April. We recognise the pressure the Government, and in particular Public Health England, was under at the time. However, yet again, it appears that the Government was somewhat slow to react and support food businesses in dealing with the impacts of COVID-19 prevention measures. The Government should ensure that improved co-ordination mechanisms are in place between government departments, public bodies and with the devolved administrations to ensure that in any future disruption, guidance can be developed, cleared and issued more rapidly. This may mean better resourcing of critical specialist functions, so they have the capacity to meet unexpected surges in demand.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government stated it has already developed a rapid process for guidance development and established multiple forums with stakeholders and devolved administrations to improve coordination, addressing the recommendation for faster guidance issuance.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
25
Recommendation
First Report - COVID-19 and food supply
Accepted
The Government cannot afford to be complacent; even though the supply chain ultimately proved to be resilient, for several weeks shoppers were faced with empty shop shelves and (in effect) rationing of staple goods. This disruption largely came from changing patterns of demand caused by Government action, which is an …
Read more
The Government cannot afford to be complacent; even though the supply chain ultimately proved to be resilient, for several weeks shoppers were faced with empty shop shelves and (in effect) rationing of staple goods. This disruption largely came from changing patterns of demand caused by Government action, which is an unusual situation. Disruptions that reduce the supply of food to the UK, for example because of a disorderly end to the transition period or climate change effects, will pose different, and potentially greater, challenges altogether. There also remains the possibility that further waves of COVID-19, or another future pandemic, may still lead to the disruption of cross-border supply chains. We welcome the Secretary of State’s confidence about the end of the transition period, but seek reassurances that food supply disruptions have been factored into contingency planning across Government. Defra must review the annual Sector Security and Resilience Plans for the food sector in light of lessons learned from the COVID-19 pandemic, including the extent to which consumer behaviour can disrupt supply chains. It should also be clearer about the difference between resilience and efficiency, and assess the extent to which our dependence on multi-national just-in-time supply chains affects resilience. Given the industry’s concerns about the potential impact of a disorderly end to the Brexit transition period, and other potential risk factors, this should happen as a matter of urgency.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government stated that Defra is conducting lessons learned exercises on consumer behaviour impacts and has reviewed Sector Security Resilience Plans in light of COVID-19 experiences, accepting the recommendation for improved planning.
Read full response →
Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs