Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Fife NHS Board

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201507639 Sector Health Category communication / staff attitude / dignity / confidentiality Decided 01 June 2016

View NHS Fife scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Ms C complained on behalf of her mother (Mrs A) who had been a patient in Victoria Hospital. Ms C felt that her mother should not have been asked if she agreed to Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (DNACPR) being put on her notes, as her mother was in a state of delirium. Ms C said that she, as next of kin, should make the decision, not hospital staff.

We looked at Mrs A's medical records and we took independent advice from an consultant geriatrician. We found that hospital staff had documented their consideration of Mrs A's situation and their actions to a reasonable standard, and they had acted in accordance with the relevant guidance on resuscitation and DNACPR. The guidance is clear that a patient with capacity can consent to or refuse CPR, and if they lack capacity the decision rests not with the next of kin, but with a legally appointed proxy or with the lead clinician. In general terms, overall responsibility for making a decision about CPR rests with the lead clinician. In the circumstances, we did not uphold Ms C's complaint.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201507639 as a PDF (11.14 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Fife NHS Board

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202410341 01 May 2026 C complained about the care and treatment provided by the board in relation to a cancerous lesion (squamous cell carcinoma, … Upheld
202308194 01 Dec 2025 C complained that the board’s mental health services did not communicate information regarding C's adult child (A) reasonably. A, who … Upheld
202402736 01 Dec 2025 C complained on behalf of their spouse (A). The first of C’s complaints was that the board had failed to … Partly Upheld
202404687 01 Sep 2025 C complained about the care and treatment provided by the board in relation to excision of a right sided neck … Upheld
202305480 01 Sep 2025 C complained about the nursing care provided to their late parent (A) whilst in hospital. They complained about a lack … Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation