Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Dunedin Canmore Housing Ltd

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Partly Upheld Reference 201204215 Sector Local Government Category repairs and maintenance Decided 01 February 2014

Full decision

Summary

Ms C complained on behalf of her neighbour (Mr A) about the time it took for the housing association to carry out repair work to address damp and drainage problems affecting his home. Mr A felt the association had ignored concerns he had raised both individually and collectively and was unhappy with the way the complaint was handled. Ms C raised the matter with a parliamentary minister because she was dissatisfied at having to constantly phone and write letters in order to gain the association's attention.

The association explained that the problems identified were significant and a timescale for completion of the work was difficult to provide because more investigative work was required, but they accepted that they could have communicated better with Mr A. They also acknowledged the information Ms C had provided, and had offered an ex-gratia payment to her and to another neighbour as an apology. In addition, they introduced a new customer care centre to improve communications.

It did take around nine months for the damp and drainage problems to be addressed, but the association provided evidence that during that time they were actively working to address extensive problems that affected the whole building. We agreed the circumstances were exceptional, and that their actions were reasonable.

We found the association's responses became more informative as work progressed, but on occasion it seemed that Ms C had to ask for information rather than this being proactively provided. We also upheld the complaint about communication. Overall, we found that their response to the complaint was reasonable, but we took the view that Mr A should have been offered the same redress as his neighbours.

Recommendations

We recommended that the association: offer a redress payment to Mr A.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201204215 as a PDF (12.46 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Dunedin Canmore Housing Ltd

Reference Date Summary Outcome
201507995 01 Sep 2016 Mr C complained that the housing association was failing to ensure that their contractors provided a reasonable stair-cleaning service in … Not Upheld
201300330 01 Mar 2014 Ms C complained to the housing association about various types of antisocial behaviour by a neighbour. She complained that the … Not Upheld
201204216 01 Feb 2014 Ms C complained about the time it took for the housing association to carry out repair work to address damp … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation