Source · SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman)

Fife Council

SPSO (Scottish Public Services Ombudsman) Not Upheld Reference 201202003 Sector Local Government Category repairs and maintenance Decided 01 June 2013

View Fife Council scorecard

Full decision

Summary

Ms C complained to the council that a dusty black deposit had developed throughout her home over the past few years. She asked the council to investigate this, and later complained that they did not take enough action to identify its source.

Our investigation found that the council visited and suggested that the source of the black substance might be related to a nearby dual carriageway and they sealed a vent. They also said it might be from candles and incense that council officers saw above the radiators in various rooms. The council had the substance tested by a laboratory but this did not identify for certain what it was or where it was coming from. However, they were of the view that it had not come from the fabric of the building, as it had not penetrated the wallpaper. The council then told Ms C that if she wanted any further tests to be carried out, she would have to pay for them. They said, however, that if she did so and the source was something to do with the structure of the building, they would reimburse her for any costs if the work was done by an accredited contractor.

As well as having the substance tested at a laboratory, we found that the council had visited Ms C's home several times, and had arranged for her gas fire to be checked. We did not uphold her complaint, as we found that they had taken reasonable steps to have the matter investigated.

Related reading

View Decision Report 201202003 as a PDF (11.34 KB) Updated: March 13, 2018

View original on SPSO (Scottish Publ… website

Other decisions involving Fife Council

Reference Date Summary Outcome
202411894 01 Oct 2025 C owns a holiday let in a conservation area. The adjacent, terraced property was demolished but not rebuilt, leaving an … Not Upheld
202308876 01 Jul 2025 C complained to the council that their teenage child (A)'s school had not taken reasonable action following the report of … Upheld
202310572 01 Jun 2025 C complained that the council unreasonably failed to follow relevant processes and procedures in managing and responding to bullying behaviour … Upheld
202206015 01 Nov 2024 C complained that the council had failed to address excessive noise from a recreational area near their home. We found … Partly Upheld
202204206 01 May 2024 C complained about their housing. C had moved into the property because they were downsizing from their previous home. The … Partly Upheld
View all decisions for this organisation