Source · Recommendations & oversight

National Audit Office

NAO value-for-money reports examining the economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of government spending. Recommendations are tracked against government responses and, where a PAC hearing followed, linked to the committee's own recommendations and Treasury Minute responses.

2,824 reports 2,175 recommendations 1,827 confirmed by NAO 61% implementation rate

Reports

2,824 matching reports · newest published first

Early progress in transforming courts and tribunals

Published 9 May 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Justice

In this report we outline what HM Courts and Tribunals Service’s (HMCTS) change portfolio to modernise and upgrade the justice system will deliver, consider early progress against plans and explore how HMCTS and its partners …

Exiting the EU: The financial settlement

Published 20 Apr 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Exiting the European Union · HM Treasury

This report forms part of the National Audi Office’s programme of work to examine how the government is overseeing and implementing the UK’s exit from the EU. It is our first report on the financial …

Ensuring sufficient skilled military personnel

Published 18 Apr 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Defence

This report reviews whether the Ministry of Defence has an effective approach to developing the capability of its regular forces, and how it is adapting to meet the new challenges.

Investigation into errors in Employment and Support Allowance

Published 21 Mar 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Work and Pensions

This investigation covers a single, major cause of underpayment error in ESA. This error relates to people whose existing benefit claim was converted to ESA and who were entitled to income-related ESA but were only …

Financial sustainability of local authorities 2018

Published 8 Mar 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

This report reviews developments in the sector and examines whether the Department, along with other departments with responsibility for local services, understands the impact of funding reductions on the financial and service sustainability of local …

The BBC’s commercial activities: a landscape review

Published 7 Mar 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Unknown (358)

This report, our first on this subject, is a landscape review of the BBC’s commercial activities, setting out how the BBC organizes these activities and the key risks and challenges they currently face.

Reducing emergency admissions

Published 2 Mar 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

The report examines progress that the Department of Health & Social Care, NHS England, NHS Improvement and other stakeholders are making in reducing the impact of emergency admissions on acute hospitals. The report takes a …

Low carbon heating of homes and businesses and the Renewable Heat Incentive

Published 23 Feb 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy

The Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI) is a scheme to encourage a switch from fossil fuel heating systems to renewable and low-carbon alternatives in homes and business premises in Great Britain. Our report assesses the value …

Converting maintained schools to academies

Published 22 Feb 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Education

This report focuses on the arrangements for converting schools to academies. We assess the Department for Education’s approach and the extent of conversion; the robustness, cost and speed of the conversion process; and the availability …

The adult social care workforce in England

Published 8 Feb 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

The Department of Health & Social Care’s role in overseeing the adult social care workforce.

The Ministry of Defence’s arrangement with Annington Property Limited

Published 30 Jan 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Defence

The Ministry of Defence (the Department) has committed itself to annual rental bills of nearly £200 million and lost out on billions of pounds of asset value as a result of selling and leasing back …

NHS financial management and sustainability 2018

Published 19 Jan 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department of Health and Social Care

Additional funding, aimed to help the NHS get on a financially sustainable footing, has instead been spent on coping with existing pressures.

PFI and PF2

Published 18 Jan 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

HM Treasury

A briefing on the rationale, costs and benefits of the Private Finance Initiative; the use of and impact of PFI, and ability to make savings from operational contracts; and the introduction of PF2. There are …

Delivering STEM (science, technology, engineering and mathematics) skills for the economy

Published 17 Jan 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy · Department for Education

Government efforts to improve the quality and take-up of science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) skills have yielded some positive results but there remains an urgent need for departments to set out a shared view …

National College for Teaching and Leadership Accounts

Published 11 Jan 2018 Financial Audit No recommendations indexed

Department for Education

Amyas Morse, Comptroller and Auditor General has qualified his audit opinions on the National College for Teaching and Leadership’s (NCTL) 2016-17 Accounts due to a limitation in the scope of his audit of the regularity …

The Thameslink, Southern and Great Northern rail franchise

Published 10 Jan 2018 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Department for Transport

This examines the causes of poor performance on the Thameslink, Southern and Great Northern network since the franchise began in September 2014, the effects on passenger services, financial outcomes for the operator and the Department, …

Investigation into changes to Community Rehabilitation Company contracts

Published 19 Dec 2017 Value for Money No recommendations indexed

Ministry of Justice

An investigation into why and how the Ministry of Justice adjusted Community Rehabilitation Companies’ (CRCs) contracts; and the financial and other implications of the adjustments to the CRCs’ contracts. 19 December 2017

Response and delivery evidence

2,175 recommendations tracked

Across the NAO recommendation corpus. Response, implementation and NAO confirmation are separate measures; the categories below overlap.

Status Recommendations Share
Implemented 1,320 61%
Accepted 1,718 79%
Partially accepted 200 9%
Work in progress 503 23%
Rejected 41 2%
Confirmed by NAO follow-up 1,827 84%
Methodology: status determined from departmental responses, Treasury Minute responses, PAC follow-up hearings, and NAO own progress tracking.

Departments named in NAO reports

Departments named in NAO reports · all years
Department of Health and Social Care (126 reports) HM Treasury (95 reports) Cabinet Office (88 reports) Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy (81 reports) Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (76 reports) HM Revenue and Customs (74 reports) Department for Work and Pensions (66 reports) Ministry of Defence (63 reports) Department for Education (63 reports) Department for Transport (62 reports) Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (56 reports) Devolved administrations (56 reports) Home Office (53 reports) Ministry of Justice (39 reports) Department for Culture, Media & Sport (30 reports)