Source · IMB Annual Report

Gartree

Year: 2020 Published: 18 Mar 2021 Type: Prison · Cat B Population: 636 Recommendations: 13 Key concerns Positive findings

This IMB annual report for HMP Gartree covers the period from December 2019 to November 2020, heavily impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent lockdowns. Despite these challenges, the prison's management is commended for effectively handling the crisis and maintaining some services. The Board highlights significant reductions in self-harm and assaults, but expresses concerns over the detrimental long-term effects of extended lockdowns on prisoner wellbeing, the deteriorating state of the prison estate, and persistent issues regarding IPP prisoners and property management.

Safety statistics

Incidents during reporting year
IndicatorThis yearPrevious
Deaths in custody52
Self-harm incidents350562
ACCT cases opened164226
Prisoner assaults5278
Assaults on staff4881
Use of force190265

Positive findings

The IMB commends the Governor and staff for effectively managing the COVID-19 crisis, containing outbreaks, and maintaining key work delivery. Positive changes include clearer communication, improved staff attendance and retention, and progress by the new NHS healthcare provider in reducing waiting times. Physical improvements like fire safety measures are underway. There has been a notable reduction in self-harm incidents, prisoner-on-prisoner assaults, and use of force incidents compared to the previous year, possibly due to lockdown restrictions. Staff-prisoner relationships are generally positive, and the key worker scheme is progressing.

Key concerns

13 items
Other The Board is concerned that because of restrictions on our ability to visit the prison and to be able to communicate directly with prisoners and staff, we have perhaps not been able to establish a full picture of some of the issues faced by the prisoners for a large part of this reporting period.
Regime/Time Out of Cell Most of the prisoners have had to remain locked up for a worryingly extended period. The Board is concerned about the detrimental effects that this has, and will continue to have, on the prisoners, in relation to rehabilitation, progression, and physical and mental health, and for the wellbeing of the staff.
Estate/Conditions Repeated Some of the wings require immediate investment and the condition of the older residential accommodation needs addressing, as recommended in the Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) scrutiny report published in October 2020.
Staffing Our ability to recruit new Board members has been directly affected by COVID-19, and we continue to face challenges in recruiting and retaining members.
Regime/Time Out of Cell Repeated There are still many challenging prisoners serving an indeterminate sentence for public protection (IPP) who appear locked in the system. Gartree does not appear to be the best place for these prisoners, as there are not adequate resources to deal with them.
Complaints/Property Repeated The Board continues to be frustrated by the apparent inability of the Prison Service generally, and Gartree more specifically, to handle prisoner property.
Safety The Board has concerns that, as frustrations grow with continued restrictions to the regime, some of the prisoners may become less tolerant to lockdown conditions, and violence will increase again.
Mental Health Repeated There are still worrying numbers of prisoners listed as self-isolators or, more recently, as socially isolated prisoners, who withdraw from prison life and sometimes appear to be stuck within the system.
Education/Purposeful Activity Repeated We have always had some concerns about the amount of purposeful activity truly available to the prisoners at Gartree and continue to do so.
Food/Catering Repeated The kitchens have experienced a large number of issues with refrigeration equipment, and as expressed in our last annual report, the challenges regarding long delays before kitchen equipment is either replaced or repaired have continued.
Regime/Time Out of Cell It was unfortunate that the prisoners’ self-catering facilities were closed in March due to concerns regarding the transmission of COVID-19, and have since remained closed. In their recent report, HMIP raised the question of whether this continued closure of the kitchens was justified after six months.
Segregation Repeated The Board has previously raised concerns about the poor physical conditions in the unit, both for the prisoners and staff. There is a limited regime for prisoners housed in the unit and segregated on the residential wings, and the Board has continued to raise concerns about the excessive length of time that many prisoners are kept in the SAPU/segregated on the wings.
Staffing There have been occasions when it appears to the Board that there may be too many new and less experienced staff, with less on-the-job experience and fewer skills to be able to pre-empt trouble and difficult situations; some of the more experienced staff may be better equipped to diffuse situations.

Recommendations

13 items · 9 repeated
#RecommendationAddresseeStatus
1 Will the minister seek to provide a sufficient budget for HMP Gartree to create a safe living standard that would be deemed acceptable in the wider community? It continues not to be acceptable to expect staff and prisoners to live and work in buildings where the infrastructure has seriously declined over several years. Repeated
Response
I understand the Board’s request for funding to improve the building fabric, living environment and complete installation of CCTV. The leaks in the wing offices have largely been investigated and fixed, and the roof of the Gartree Therapeutic Community Unit has been replaced. However, it is recognised that there are other roofs at HMP Gartree in need of replacement and whilst funding has been approved to fix some of the most affected roofs during the current financial year 2020/21, there a bid for further funding to fix all the roofs is needed. There is also an identified need for the shower areas to be refurbished, but due to the limited capital funding and the value of all bids across the prison estate exceeding what is available, work is having to be prioritised. In the meantime, HMP Gartree is working closely with the facilities management provider, Amey, to help with minor refurbishment and localised repairs have been completed to allow the showers to continue to be used. The prison also has a decoration programme and painting parties have made a noticeable improvement to the living conditions, which is beginning to make HMP Gartree a more decent environment, alongside a newly installed TV distribution system providing prisoners with a better TV signal. In addition, funding has been allocated for enhanced gate security and an x-ray body scanner to reduce the entry of contraband into the prison. Funding has also been allocated for CCTV in G and H wings and the main link corridor. The specification and request for quotation are currently being prepared to allow contractors to submit costs for the required CCTV work to be delivered this financial year 2020/21. For the areas still left without CCTV these will be dependent on funding and will be prioritised once available.
Ministry of Justice In progress
2 HMP Gartree continues to hold IPP prisoners, who are now many years over their tariff. A degree of frustration continues among these prisoners, and the COVID-19 pandemic will not have helped in any progression for these prisoners. This continues to be an issue which needs addressing urgently, and the Board looks forward to hearing from the minister about plans that will resolve this ongoing issue. Repeated
Response
I recognise the Board’s concern about those that remain in prison serving indeterminate sentences of Imprisonment for Public Protection (IPP). HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) is committed to doing all it can to support the progression of IPP sentenced prisoners and to help them reduce their risk to the point where the independent Parole Board determines that they may be safely released. The work to improve the management and progression of those serving IPP sentences has been underway for some time and is continuing via the joint IPP Action Plan, developed in partnership with the Parole Board. HMPPS is prioritising post-tariff prisoners in accessing rehabilitative interventions which includes Psychology Service led reviews and enhanced case management for those prisoners who have a complex set of risks and needs. Progression Regimes have also been developed at four prisons across the country, which are dedicated to supporting indeterminate prisoners who are struggling to achieve release via the usual routes. Across the custodial estate, the population of prisoners serving IPP sentences was over 6,000 at its peak in 2012. The latest published figures show the unreleased IPP population stood at 2,039 at the end of March 2020, a further reduction from 2,223 at the end of September 2019 - demonstrating the improvement in opportunities available to IPP prisoners to progress in their sentence. Locally, HMP Gartree continues to provide appropriate psychological services to support the work that is being undertaken to manage and progress IPP prisoners and the prison now has a dedicated IPP Lead to take forward the local IPP action plan put in place to help prisoners progress. However, it is important to note that, as the unreleased IPP population continues to decrease, those remaining in the prison population present the most complex and challenging cases. Many of these prisoners are still assessed as posing a high risk of committing further violent or sexual offences. HMPPS will continue to work with these individuals to offer them opportunities to reduce their identified risks but ultimately these risks must be addressed before the Parole Board can consider the prisoners’ release. In addition, HMPPS is currently rolling out the Offender Management in Custody (OMiC) model which is implementing a new Key Worker role to provide more dedicated time to support individual prisoners. Their key purpose is to engage prisoners in their rehabilitation and the coordination of their sentence. Whilst it is acknowledged that managing IPP sentenced prisoners can be a challenge, the improvements via OMiC, such as the introduction of the Prison Offender Manager and Key Worker role, will enable the prison to offer IPPs better management of their custody time and hopefully progression.
Ministry of Justice In progress
3 Will the minister provide an update on resources being planned post-COVID-19 to enable the delivery of measures outlined in the National Partnership Agreement for Prison Healthcare, which acknowledges the interdependency of health and social care and the prison environment (defined as physical environment, staffing levels and regime) for the crucial improvements to the health and wellbeing of all prisoners?
Response
Turning to the Board’s concern about the relationship between health and social care provision, the National Partnership Agreement for Prison Healthcare in England sets out a detailed programme of work, agreed by health and justice partners, to deliver safe, decent and effective provision for prisoners. The agreement takes a whole system approach to healthcare provision and recognises the physical environment, staffing levels and regime within prisons. I can assure the Board that the Ministry of Justice and its health partners are continuing to work together to deliver the programme of work underpinning this agreement and the resource requirements are continually reviewed.
Ministry of Justice In progress
4 Will the minister share the decision-making process not to include prison officers as key workers who could access the vaccine for COVID-19 as a priority group? Ministry of Justice
5 Will the Prison Service ensure that Gartree will be sufficiently funded post-COVID-19, so that prisoners’ access to employment, purposeful activity, education and healthcare will address the impacts of COVID-19 as quickly as possible?
Response
It is acknowledged that HMP Gartree experienced a loss of some external contracts throughout the year which has resulted in reduced activity places. However, there remains 578 full time activity places and the prison is currently working with HMPPS Public Sector Prison Industries and other contractors to increase the number of places available in its workshops, such as within the print shop. Funding through the Prison Education Dynamic Purchasing System has also been made available and will be used to increase the current education places, including looking at the opportunities for those prisoners who find it difficult to engage in the existing activity places.
HMPPS In progress
6 Does the Prison Service consider that Gartree has a sufficient ongoing maintenance budget and capital funding in order both that prisoners can live, and staff can work within a safe, secure and decent environment? Repeated
Response
I understand the Board’s request for funding to improve the building fabric, living environment and complete installation of CCTV. The leaks in the wing offices have largely been investigated and fixed, and the roof of the Gartree Therapeutic Community Unit has been replaced. However, it is recognised that there are other roofs at HMP Gartree in need of replacement and whilst funding has been approved to fix some of the most affected roofs during the current financial year 2020/21, there a bid for further funding to fix all the roofs is needed. There is also an identified need for the shower areas to be refurbished, but due to the limited capital funding and the value of all bids across the prison estate exceeding what is available, work is having to be prioritised. In the meantime, HMP Gartree is working closely with the facilities management provider, Amey, to help with minor refurbishment and localised repairs have been completed to allow the showers to continue to be used. The prison also has a decoration programme and painting parties have made a noticeable improvement to the living conditions, which is beginning to make HMP Gartree a more decent environment, alongside a newly installed TV distribution system providing prisoners with a better TV signal. In addition, funding has been allocated for enhanced gate security and an x-ray body scanner to reduce the entry of contraband into the prison. Funding has also been allocated for CCTV in G and H wings and the main link corridor. The specification and request for quotation are currently being prepared to allow contractors to submit costs for the required CCTV work to be delivered this financial year 2020/21. For the areas still left without CCTV these will be dependent on funding and will be prioritised once available.
HMPPS In progress
7 As raised by other Boards, the number of applications about property remains high, although it is difficult to provide a true reflection for the whole reporting period because of the lockdown. The Board looks forward to improved ways of working that will resolve these long and unacceptable ongoing issues with prisoners’ property, which are particularly difficult to resolve when property is lost in transit or not forwarded on by a previous establishment. Repeated
Response
It is unfortunate and regrettable that prisoners’ property continues to be an issue. The development of the new Prisoners’ Property Policy Framework is being informed by a project which was undertaken in summer 2019, involving stakeholders across HMPPS and the escort services. The project involved visiting 14 prisons, consultation with staff and prisoners, and engagement with external stakeholders such as the Independent Monitoring Board Secretariat and Prisons and Probation Ombudsman. Its purpose was to support the policy review and identify areas where immediate and more long-term changes may be required to improve operational practice. Following the conclusion of the project, HMPPS has worked closely with stakeholders to consult on proposed changes to the policy. Discussions ahead of consultation with IMB members began with the IMB Secretariat in late February 2020, who proposed meetings take place with Board members in April. In light of the pressures placed on Boards by COVID-19, HMPPS agreed with the IMB Secretariat to pause this consultation. This work is now moving forward again and the IMB Secretariat have proposed that the meetings now take place between August and September. The feedback received from IMB members at these meetings will then be considered alongside the comments received earlier this year from other stakeholders, with the intention that the revised draft policy framework will be circulated for wider consultation at the end of 2020. The Prisoner Escort and Custody Service (PECS) take steps to transport all property which falls within the agreed volumetric limits with prisoners when they transfer between establishments. A new fleet of vehicles are being provided through the PECS 4 Generation contract which starts in August 2020. These new vehicles will be able to transfer an additional half box of consumable items for each prisoner e.g. products purchased in the prison shop. In addition to this, HMPPS is considering what more can be done to encourage prisoners to send out or dispose of excess items to reduce the amount of their property that cannot transfer with them. Steps are also being taken to ensure a consistent approach when prisons forward on any excess items to prisoners at their new establishments after transfers have taken place. Locally, a dedicated Reception staffing group has been created at HMP Gartree to improve the handling of property. The processes for handling property, such as cell clearances has also been improved with a stronger message to staff to ensure property is treated with care and respect.
HMPPS In progress
8 The Board is concerned about the ongoing situation regarding the repair or replacement of equipment in the kitchens. Can the Prison Service engage with contractors to create a service level agreement which will achieve a more timely response to address such issues? Repeated HMPPS
9 Will the Prison Service share the plans to deal with the prisoners located in Gartree who have complex/serious mental health issues, who need specialist help from medical professionals? Repeated
Response
HMPPS acknowledges that some prisoners at HMP Gartree have complex mental health issues and may remain in segregated conditions for protracted periods of time if, following individual risk assessment, this is deemed the most appropriate location. However, the Long Term and High Security Estate (LTHSE) Pathway to Progression initiative aims to better meet the needs of the most complex and vulnerable prisoners, including those who often end up in segregation for protracted periods. A needs analysis of this prisoner cohort has been conducted and has led to improved specialist services and units across the LTHSE. A key aspect of this work is to enhance the links with specialist health pathways for prisoners as well as developing the existing specialist units, to offer suitable alternatives to segregation. The Offender Personality Disorder pathway jointly commissioned between HMPPS and NHS England is one of these services, which provides appropriate prisoners access to specialist help, such as a Democratic Therapeutic Community (DTC), an adapted DTC for those with learning disabilities and a progression Psychologically Informed Planned Environment for those who require a period of consolidation before moving to the next phase of their treatment. Alongside these developments all segregation units receive additional support from the Pathways to Progression team. This has seen improved outcomes for many complex men within the LTHSE and at HMP Gartree there are clear examples of improved joint working which has enabled the progression of complex cases both to health services and specialist units in custody. The Psychology team at HMP Gartree is also continuing to work together with the Healthcare provider to provide local bespoke support for prisoners with complex mental health issues.
HMPPS In progress
10 Will the Governor take all measures necessary to reduce the levels of violence, self-harm, bullying, drug taking and drug smuggling, including adequate staffing and resource continued being allocated to the safer custody team? Repeated
Response
As part of the wider safety strategy for prisons, a training programme is in development, that aims to provide prison staff with the knowledge that they need to identify signs, signals and indicators of existing, or emerging, gang or harmful group behaviours (GHGB). Following this training, staff will better understand and recognise the characteristics of gang membership and the safety risks. Additionally, staff will be better equipped to record and use intelligence, allowing local targeted actions in response to the GHGB threat, sharing this intelligence and developing knowledge with local crime partnerships. Alongside this, HMPPS is providing prisons with tools to improve the way data is used in risk identification. A Safety Diagnostic Tool (SDT) was rolled out across the prison estate last year, which enables staff to see detailed information on safety issues, from establishment level to individual level. The Challenge, Support and Intervention Plan’s (CSIP) are also being used to manage those who pose a raised risk of being violent and provides a framework centred around the individual and their specific needs to help them manage and move away from violent behaviours. The SDT is being used in prisons alongside CSIP to help identify those who may benefit from proactive case management and to prevent violence happening as opposed to waiting for a person to act violently before action is taken. HMPPS has also refreshed its partnership with the Samaritans that supports the Listeners scheme through which selected prisoners are trained to provide emotional support to their fellow prisoners. This support mechanisms can benefit those prisoners who are feeling frustrated rather turning to acts of violence. Reducing violence and making the prison safer is a top priority of HMP Gartree and the local Safety Function has been re-organised to ensure there are clear accountable lines and responsibility. Funding has been provided as part of the Enhanced Security project, including an increase in active dogs and handlers, as well as x-ray body scanners to be installed to detect drugs from entering the prison and help reduce any associated violence within the prison. In June 2020 a search of some residential units involving Dedicated Search Teams from other LTHSE prisons took place at HMP Gartree where weapons and illicit items were recovered. Additional supportive action such as this will remain an option in future where intelligence and risk assessments deem it appropriate. In addition, the improvement in staffing referred to above and the introduction of Key Workers being identified as a priority by the prison will help increase safety and reduce violence by providing more dedicated time to support individual prisoners and better management of their time in custody.
Governor / Director In progress
11 Will the Governor continue to ensure that monitoring and quality assurance checks of all ACCT documents are carried out by a dedicated safer custody custodial manager, and that all documentation is of the required standard and all post-closure reviews are undertaken? Governor / Director
12 Will the Governor keep reviewing ways to improve processes and procedures in looking after prisoners’ property, as issues with property are still being reported? Repeated
Response
Locally, a dedicated Reception staffing group has been created at HMP Gartree to improve the handling of property. The processes for handling property, such as cell clearances has also been improved with a stronger message to staff to ensure property is treated with care and respect.
Governor / Director In progress
13 Will the Governor continue to identify ways to improve engagement between the Board and SMT, to enable positive interaction for the benefit of all? This includes routine notifications which are outlined in the memorandum of understanding between HMPPS and the management board for the Independent Monitoring Boards, dated December 2019. Repeated Governor / Director

Related inspections & investigations

16 Jan 2023 HMIP · Unannounced Safety 3 · Respect 3 · Activity 2 · Release 3
PPO fatal incident Martin McDermott
PPO fatal incident Nicholas Halling · Natural causes
PPO fatal incident Jordan Nuttall
PPO fatal incident Ian Kerr
PPO fatal incident Anthony Aldoescu · Other non-natural
5 May 2016 PFD Ahmedreza Fathi · State Custody related deaths; Suicide (from 2015); Hospital Death (Clinical Procedures and medical management) related deaths

Other reports for Gartree

2025 Published 3 Jun 2026 Population 664 · Self-harm 457 · Concerns
2024 Published 28 May 2025 Population 558 · Self-harm 288 · Concerns
2023 Published 14 May 2024 · Self-harm 266 · Concerns
2022 Published 10 May 2023 Population 593 · Self-harm 242 · Concerns
2021 Published 25 May 2022 · Self-harm 223 · Concerns

Report details

Establishment
Gartree
Type
Prison · Cat B
Report year
2020
Published
18 March 2021
Responsible body
HMP Gartree
Recommendations
13
MoJ rating (2024/25)
3 — Good

Population

Population636
Operational capacity648
CNA (designed for)708 90%

Source links