Source · IMB Annual Report
Lowdham Grange
AI-generated report summary HMP Lowdham Grange experienced a challenging reporting year (Feb 2022 – Jan 2023) marked by significant contract transition and refurbishment works. This led to a deterioration in safety, increased self-harm and assaults, and a decline in staff morale and prisoner engagement. Despite some positive healthcare developments like a new wellbeing centre, services remained below community standards, compounded by staffing shortages.
Year: 2023
Published: 31 May 2023
Type: Prison · Cat B training
Population: 860
Recommendations: 14
Key concerns
Positive findings
Safety statistics
| Indicator | This year | Previous |
|---|---|---|
| Deaths in custody | 0 | — |
| Self-harm incidents | 606 | 527 |
| Prisoner assaults | 131 | 124 |
| Assaults on staff | 61 | 79 |
| Use of force | 264 | 278 |
| Drug finds | 181 | 143 |
Positive findings
AI-generated summaryThe Board noted several positive aspects including no deaths in custody, a good standard of catering, and the effective management of the segregation unit by dedicated staff. Relationships with local health and social care services developed well, and a new wellbeing centre is operational. There was also the recruitment of a mental health matron. The Board was pleased that no cases of passive or concerted indiscipline occurred during the year.
Key concerns
Safety in the prison has deteriorated, and notes that this is the second year running that such a judgement has been made.
Increased number of prisoner-on-prisoner assaults, an increase in prisoner self-harm, and the significant number of weapons finds.
An underlying economy of drugs and other substance misuse is likely to increase the negative impact of gang cultures at the prison, making prisoners feel less safe.
The lack of any meaningful education programme and the limitations in providing full-time work and structured on-wing activity have led to a significant reduction in purposeful activity and to prisoners continuing to spend long periods locked in their cells.
Healthcare services have continued to be under great pressure throughout the period. Prisoners’ physical and mental health have been given due attention, but the Board considers it to be at a lower standard than that available in the community.
The mental and emotional wellbeing of prisoners remains a significant concern because of the effect of prolonged periods of time spent by prisoners in their cells.
The shortages of healthcare staff and the removal of the night staffing cover have increased the risk to the wellbeing of prisoners.
The failure to provide an adequate number of offending behaviour and drug treatment programmes, restricted full-time work opportunities and a limited education service has compromised the overall progression of many prisoners in their sentences.
The Board continues to request that priority be given to holding coroners’ inquests for deaths in custody to provide bereaved families with an understanding of the circumstances of the deaths of their relatives.
The Board believes there should be a renewed focus and energy on reviewing the sentences of indeterminate sentenced (IPP) prisoners, as this recommendation from the Justice Select Committee was not accepted.
The Board feels that the amendments to the Parole Board rules, which came into force in July 2022, are denying opportunities for prisoners who are seeking transfer to open conditions or moving towards release.
To find a speedy solution to ensure that reliable remote video-calling is provided for prisoners at HMP Lowdham Grange. This service has been completely unreliable since it was introduced and has caused many remote calls to be cancelled, causing distress for prisoners and their families.
To give renewed emphasis to the development of a national system of storage and retrieval of prisoners’ property when prisoners are moved between prisons. The issuing of a revised framework in August 2022 has brought no change, and greater efforts are needed to find a national solution to this problem.
The impending contract changes appeared to have a damaging effect on the morale and attitudes of prison staff on the wings and houseblocks.
Prison officers appeared to be spending more time inside the wing offices and they were less visible on the landings. Consequently, they had much less interaction with prisoners and various prisoners have complained of staff appearing disengaged.
The Board is disappointed that some of the major faith festival or observance days were overlooked by prison management during the year.
Some prisoners are still held in the unit for extended periods of time... at least three prisoners have not been transferred to secure mental health facilities during the 14-day window
the segregation unit is not the appropriate place for long-term detention because of the national shortage of beds in secure hospitals
alcohol treatment engagement is lower in HMP Lowdham Grange when compared with similar establishments and it is not appropriate, especially because the brewing of hooch remains at high levels
Recommendations
To strengthen the collaborative working arrangements with the Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust and its commissioners in order to ensure that the levels of service provided in the prison correspond with the services available in the community. The Board also refers to its concerns about the shortages of healthcare staff in the prison and in particular the lack of night healthcare cover.
Recommendation 10
To ensure that staffing levels and resources are brought up to and maintained at the required level to operate the full regime effectively and improve safety within the prison. The Board observes that a more effective regime of searching for drugs and prohibited items, which includes all staff, visitors and contractors, will improve safety and reduce risk in the prison.
Recommendation 11
To lead in the development of a strengthened working relationship between all prison staff and the members of the Board, which is based on mutual respect for their respective roles and which enables the IMB to fulfil its statutory duty.
Recommendation 4
The Board continues to request that priority be given to holding coroners’ inquests for deaths in custody to provide bereaved families with an understanding of the circumstances of the deaths of their relatives.
Government response
While formal responses were received by the Board about all of these issues, very little progress has been made. For example, the government did not accept the recommendation of the Justice Select Committee to resentence IPP prisoners; and the matter of prisoners with severe mental health disorders is still under review. In the matter of delayed inquests, the Board was informed that inquests for deaths in custody prior to 2021 would be prioritised and completed by May 2023. During the reporting year, two of three delayed inquests were conducted, one of which concluded with HM Coroner issuing a prevention of future deaths notice in January 2023.
Recommendation 5
The Board believes there should be a renewed focus and energy on reviewing the sentences of indeterminate sentenced (IPP) prisoners, as this recommendation from the Justice Select Committee was not accepted.
Government response
While formal responses were received by the Board about all of these issues, very little progress has been made. For example, the government did not accept the recommendation of the Justice Select Committee to resentence IPP prisoners; and the matter of prisoners with severe mental health disorders is still under review.
Recommendation 6
The Board feels that the amendments to the Parole Board rules, which came into force in July 2022, are denying opportunities for prisoners who are seeking transfer to open conditions or moving towards release. The Board would like to see the opinions and recommendations of prison and probation staff being given due consideration when such decisions are made.
Recommendation 7
To find a speedy solution to ensure that reliable remote video-calling is provided for prisoners at HMP Lowdham Grange. This service has been completely unreliable since it was introduced and has caused many remote calls to be cancelled, causing distress for prisoners and their families.
Recommendation 8
To give priority in the matter of resourcing the probation services with regard to pre-release management and to support for prisoners after their release back into the community.
Recommendation 9
To ensure that high-quality and innovative programmes of rehabilitation, mental health provision, education, skills development and self-improvement are available for all prisoners. This must include defined standards and the minimum number of programmes to be delivered.
Government response
Positive formal responses were received on all these issues. However, little progress has been made, with the exception of the FLO training request.
Recommendation 10
To give renewed emphasis to the development of a national system of storage and retrieval of prisoners’ property when prisoners are moved between prisons. The issuing of a revised framework in August 2022 has brought no change, and greater efforts are needed to find a national solution to this problem.
Government response
Positive formal responses were received on all these issues. However, little progress has been made, with the exception of the FLO training request.
Recommendation 11
To deliver a fair and consistent regime that gives all prisoners opportunities to progress through their sentences through the provision of high-quality and innovative programmes of rehabilitation, mental health provision, education, skills development and self-improvement. The regime should also include prisoner-led initiatives and structured on-wing activities supported by prison custody officers (PCOs) and other staff.
Government response
No formal responses were received on any of these issues, apart from verbal assurances given in respect of adjudications. Even so, the Board has noted that the number of prisoners attending their adjudications fell away by the autumn and prisoners reported that they had not been told of their hearings and/or had not been able to attend for reasons related to the prison regime. With regard to the need for high-quality support and learning programmes to help prisoners progress through their sentences, education provision has been at a very low level throughout the year and prisoners who required level one in numeracy and literacy to obtain jobs could not access courses.
Recommendation 12
To strengthen the collaborative working arrangements with the Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust and its commissioners in order to ensure that the levels of service provided in the prison correspond with the services available in the community. The Board also refers to its concerns about the shortages of healthcare staff in the prison and in particular the lack of night healthcare cover.
Government response
No formal responses were received on any of these issues, apart from verbal assurances given in respect of adjudications.
Recommendation 13
To ensure that staffing levels and resources are brought up to and maintained at the required level to operate the full regime effectively and improve safety within the prison. The Board observes that a more effective regime of searching for drugs and prohibited items, which includes all staff, visitors and contractors, will improve safety and reduce risk in the prison.
Recommendation 14
To lead in the development of a strengthened working relationship between all prison staff and the members of the Board, which is based on mutual respect for their respective roles and which enables the IMB to fulfil its statutory duty.
Applications to the IMB
| Category | Current | Previous |
|---|---|---|
| Accommodation (including transfers) | 45 | 38 |
| Canteen/Money/Pay | 23 | 17 |
| Healthcare/Dental | 18 | 10 |
| Other | 14 | 22 |
| Property | 38 | 15 |
| Rule 45/Segregation | 5 | 4 |
| Safety/Violence | 6 | 5 |
| Total | 170 | 127 |
| Visits/Phone Calls | 9 | 6 |
| Work/Education/Courses | 12 | 10 |
Related inspections & investigations
Safety 1
· Respect 1
· Activity 2
· Release 2
Safety 2
· Respect 2
· Activity 1
· Release 2
David Loch · Other non-natural
Raymond Wallace · Other non-natural
Adam Diesa-Green · Other non-natural
Uziel Mendoza-Sillerico · Natural causes
Stephen Metcalfe · Other non-natural
Anthony Binfield · Suicide (from 2015) | State Custody related deaths
Nigel Saunders · State Custody related deaths
Other reports for Lowdham Grange
Population 660
· Self-harm 922
· Concerns
Population 837
· Self-harm 821
· Concerns
Population 808
· Self-harm 844
· Concerns
Population 880
· Self-harm 528
· Concerns
Population 885
· Self-harm 480
· Concerns
Population 885
· Concerns