James Alexander Robert Forbes
Recommendations
out in section 26(4) of the Act, the following recommendations might realistically prevent other deaths in similar circumstances: i. The Chief Constable should develop and introduce guidance for Police Scotland service advisors with the objective of minimising the scope for the misrecording of information reported by telephone by members of the public, for example by requiring service advisors, where the nature and circumstances of the call allow, to repeat potentially important information such as the location of an incident to the caller, so that the caller has an opportunity to correct any misunderstanding or misrecording of that information. ii. The Chief Constable should develop and introduce guidance to clarify: (a) the circumstances in which an attempt should be made to contact a person who has called the police to report a concern for person issue, in order to check and confirm the information which the caller reported, before bringing enquiries arising from the call to an end; and (b) who should be responsible for attempting to make such contact.
Section 28 responses
Response pendingNo response has been identified on the case landing page yet. The 8-week response window is still open.
Determination details
- Reference
- [2026] FAI 51
- Published
- 18 September 2026
- Sheriff
- Sheriff Principal Andrew Miller
- Sheriffdom
- Grampian, Highland and Islands
- Date of death
- 15 January 2024
- Location
- Elphinstone Court, Aberdeen
- Cause of death
- 1(a) Multiple blunt force injuries 1(b) Fall from height