Source · Scotland · Fatal Accident Inquiry

Dr Sara Lilian Macrae

Scotland · FAI Health Reference: [2024] FAI 49 Published: 9 Dec 2024 Sheriff: Sheriff Alison Stirling Sheriffdom: Lothian and Borders View PDF
Court recommendations Identified
Responses identified 0
8-week deadline 3 Feb 2025
Section 28 status Non-response notice published

Recommendations

Addressed to
NHS LothianNHS Scotland
(i) When staff in a secure mental health ward are presented with evidence that a patient has vocalised suicidal ideation and demonstrated means to complete suicide by presentation of a ligature, urgent action to search that patient’s room and person for any other potential ligatures ought to be taken. In addition, consideration should be given to placing the patient on constant observations or invoking a “Clinical Pause” to evaluate the safety issues which exist and produce a plan of intervention to address the issues identified. (ii) The medical records of a patient should be accessible across different Health Boards regardless of the Health Board in which that patient is treated to ensure the treating Health Board has the patient’s full medical history available to inform fully the most appropriate care and treatment plan for the patient. (iii) Meaningful implementation and ongoing audit (including external audit of the person centred audit tool) of the Serious Adverse Event Review action plan relating to Dr Macrae’s death should continue. (iv) TRAK should be developed to introduce a function to alert clinicians to potential risk factors such as previous suicide attempts as soon as they open the patient’s notes.
Under section 28 of the 2016 Act, each recipient of a recommendation must respond within 8 weeks. The window from publication ran to 3 February 2025. See how we track responses.

Section 28 responses

Non-response notice published
Non-response notice: Lothian Health Board

Form 6.3
Notice
SHERIFFDOM OF LOTHIAN AND BORDERS at EDINBURGH
Court ref: EDI-B207-23
NOTICE
UNDER THE INQUIRIES INTO FATAL ACCIDENTS AND SUDDEN DEATHS ETC. (SCOTLAND) ACT 2016
IN THE
INQUIRY INTO THE DEATH OF
Dr Sara Lilian Macrae
Court ref: EDI-B207-23
The determination of the sheriff in this inquiry was issued on 17
th
December 2024.
The sheriff made the following recommendations:
(i) When staff in a secure mental health ward are presented with evidence that a patient has vocalised suicidal ideation and demonstrated means to complete suicide by presentation of a ligature, urgent action to search that patient’s room and person for any other potential ligatures ought to be taken. In addition, consideration should be given to placing the patient on constant observations or invoking a “Clinical Pause” to evaluate the safety issues which exist and produce a plan of intervention to address the issues identified.
(ii) The medical records of a patient should be accessible across different Health Boards regardless of the Health Board in which that patient is treated to ensure the treating Health Board has the patient’s full medical history available to inform fully the most appropriate care and treatment plan for the patient.
(iii) Meaningful implementation and ongoing audit (including external audit of the person centred audit tool) of the Serious Adverse Event Review action plan relating to Dr Macrae’s death should continue.
(iv) TRAK should be developed to introduce a function to alert clinicians to potential risk factors such as previous suicide attempts as soon as they open the patient’s notes
The Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service has not received a response from Lothian Health Board within the time limit prescribed in the Act (being the period of 8 weeks beginning with the day on which the respondent received a copy of the determination in which the recommendation was made).

The SCTS search index reports 1 response, but supplies no public response page URL that this system can verify. This is an unresolved source-linkage gap, not evidence that no response was made.

Determination details

Reference
[2024] FAI 49
Published
9 December 2024
Sheriff
Sheriff Alison Stirling
Sheriffdom
Lothian and Borders
Date of death
7 August 1964
Location
Royal Edinburgh Hospital
Cause of death
1a. External compression of neck 1b. Hanging.

Navigation

About FAIs

Fatal Accident Inquiries are held under the 2016 Act before a sheriff. They are mandatory for deaths in custody and at work. The sheriff may make recommendations under s.26(1)(b); recipients must respond within 8 weeks under s.28. See the methodology page for detail.

More on FAIs

Sources