Source · CQC inspection

Dental Hospital

Provider Royal Liverpool and Broadgreen University Hospitals NHS Trust Type NHS Healthcare Organisation Region North West Last inspected 17 Jan 2019

Overall rating: Outstanding  View full CQC report

Domain ratings

Five CQC key questions
Safe
Good
Effective
Outstanding
Caring
Outstanding
Responsive
Requires Improvement
Well-led
Outstanding

Earlier inspection findings

pre-2024 framework · 15 must-do 27 should-do

Must-do actions (15)

Legal requirements based on regulation breaches identified during inspection.

Must-do action 1 of 15
Must do
Well-led
The trust must ensure that all incident systems and processes are effective and fully implemented.
Regulation: Regulation 17(1)
⚠ There was evidence that incidents were not always being reported and investigated in a timely way in line with trust policy and national guidance. Initial reviews of serious incidents had not always taken place in a timely manner and there was evidence that incidents were not always being reported in …
Must-do action 2 of 15
Must do
Well-led
The trust must ensure that all incidents that meet the criteria for duty of candour have this applied in line with legislation.
Regulation: Regulation 20(2)(4)
⚠ We found a number of incidents reviewed during the inspection where the trust was not fully compliant with duty of candour legislation. It was also unclear if the trust audit reflected the requirements of being open as it looked at incidents that were avoidable and unavoidable not unintended or unexpected. …
Must-do action 3 of 15
Must do
Well-led
The trust must ensure that all information that is used for monitoring performance is accurate and up to date.
Regulation: Regulation 17(2)(a)
⚠ The trust had not always collected, analysed, managed and used information well to support all its activities. This was because information that was provided to CQC before, during and after the inspection had not always been accurate. Information that was used to monitor performance or make a decision could not …
Must-do action 4 of 15
Must do
Effective
The trust must ensure that all application for Deprivation of Liberty safeguards are made in line with trust policy and legislation.
Regulation: Regulation 11(1)
⚠ Staff did not always understand how and when to formally assess and record whether a patient had capacity to decide about their care. We found that capacity had not always been documented when it should have been. There were times when a capacity assessment had not been undertaken before deprivation …
Must-do action 5 of 15
Must do
Safe
The hospital must ensure there are sufficient numbers of qualified, competent and skilled staff in the emergency department to maintain a safe level of care, taking into account best practice and national guidelines in relation to the number of registered nurses on each shift, paediatric nursing provision and paediatric basic life support.
Regulation: Regulations 18(1)
⚠ The department did not consistently deploy enough staff with the right qualifications, skills, training and experience to keep people safe from avoidable harm and to provide the right care and treatment. There were high vacancy and turnover rates for both registered nurses and medical staff. There were no paediatric registered …
Must-do action 6 of 15
Must do
Safe
The hospital must ensure there is effective assessment of patient’s pressure risk and undertake all that is reasonably possible to mitigate any such risk.
Regulation: Regulations 12(1)(2)(a)(b)
⚠ Services had not always completed and updated risk assessments for patients. We found that risk assessments such as those for falls or pressure ulcers had not always been completed where required. The department did not adequately assess or respond to the risk of service users and there was an inconsistent …
Must-do action 7 of 15
Must do
Safe
The hospital must ensure the proper and safe management of medicines and use of premises including secure storage in line with current legislation.
Regulation: Regulations 12(1)(2)
⚠ Medication and controlled drugs were not always securely stored or prepared in line with trust policy, national guidance and legislation. Medicines were not always stored safely within the department or prepared in a suitable environment. For example, we found staff preparing medications on a nursing counter which had not been …
Must-do action 8 of 15
Must do
Safe
The hospital must ensure that substances that are hazardous to health are locked away safely, particularly on gerontology wards were patients have a cognitive impairment.
Regulation: Regulation 12(2)(b)
⚠ The service had suitable premises and equipment but had not always looked after them well. This was because we found substances that were hazardous to health that had sometimes been left in unlocked areas, meaning that patients or members of the public could access them, particularly on gerontology wards where …
Must-do action 9 of 15
Must do
Safe
The hospital must ensure that risk assessments for patients, such as falls, pressure ulcers and patient observations are completed and updated in a timely manner.
Regulation: Regulation 12(2)(a)
⚠ The service had not always completed and updated risk assessments for patients. Out of 26 records, we found that risk assessments such as falls or pressure ulcers had not been completed on six occasions and that patient observations had not been taken in a timely manner on six occasions.
Must-do action 10 of 15
Must do
Safe
The hospital must ensure that there are sufficient numbers of staff with the correct level of training to recover patients in endoscopy, particularly when they have had a local or general anaesthetic.
Regulation: Regulation 18(1)
⚠ The trust had not ensured that there had been sufficient numbers of suitably qualified staff available in endoscopy to recover patients. We had concerns that patients who had undergone general anaesthesia would not be recovered in line with guidelines from the Association of Anaesthetists (2013); Immediate Post Anaesthesia Recovery, which …
Must-do action 11 of 15
Must do
Safe
The hospital must ensure that patient records are kept securely at all times so that patient confidentiality is maintained.
Regulation: Regulation 17(2)(c)
⚠ Staff kept detailed records of patient’s care and treatment, but had not always ensured that patient records had been stored securely. This was because patient record trollies had been left unlocked on most ward areas that we visited and that patient records had been left at patient bedsides in ward …
Must-do action 12 of 15
Must do
Effective
The trust must ensure that mental capacity assessments are fully completed when required, particularly before applying for a Deprivation of Liberty safeguard for patients.
Regulation: Regulation 11
⚠ Staff did not always understand how and when to assess whether a patient had capacity to decide about their care. We found that capacity had not always been documented when needed, meaning that it was unclear if this had been fully assessed. The service had not operated an effective system …
Must-do action 13 of 15
Must do
Safe
The service must ensure that controlled drugs are stored securely in line with trust policy, national guidance and legislation.
Regulation: Regulation 12(2)(g)
⚠ Controlled drugs were not securely stored in line with trust policy, national guidance and legislation.
Must-do action 14 of 15
Must do
Safe
The service must ensure that patients who are prescribed antibiotics have a review date and end date recorded.
Regulation: Regulation 12(2)(g)
⚠ Antibiotic medication were not always reviewed in line with trust policy and best practice guidelines. Antibiotic review dates and end dates were not always recorded in line with trust policy and best practice guidance.
Must-do action 15 of 15
Must do
Responsive
The service must continue to take action to address the waiting times for paediatric dentistry.
Regulation: Regulation 9(1)(b)
⚠ The waiting list for the dental paediatric department was excessive. The referral to treatment (percentage within 18 weeks) compliance for October 2018 was 41.9%. This had worsened since October 2017 when the compliance was 54.7%.

Should-do actions (27)

Recommended improvements to enhance service quality.

Should-do action 1 of 27
Should do
Well-led
The trust should ensure take measures to put in place an achievable financial strategy.
Should-do action 2 of 27
Should do
Responsive
The trust should ensure that complaints processes are effectively managed.
Should-do action 3 of 27
Should do
Well-led
The trust should ensure that risks are fully mitigated and systems understood by staff.
Should-do action 4 of 27
Should do
Effective
The hospital should take measures to promote health, prevent and identify illness in its early stages.
Should-do action 5 of 27
Should do
Safe
The hospital should adopt control measure to make sure the risk to patients without call bells in the walk-in-minors area is as low as is reasonable possible.
Should-do action 6 of 27
Should do
Safe
The hospital should ensure that premises are clean, secure and properly maintained, the appropriate standard of hygiene should also be maintained.
Should-do action 7 of 27
Should do
Responsive
The hospital should design care and treatment with a view to achieving service users preferences and meeting the individual needs of patients, such as those living with dementia.
Should-do action 8 of 27
Should do
Caring
The hospital should ensure the privacy of its patients including those in the emergency triage area.
Should-do action 9 of 27
Should do
Safe
The hospital should ensure that staff are ‘bare below the elbow’ when delivering patient care to make sure that the risk of infection being spread is reduced as much as possible.
Should-do action 10 of 27
Should do
Safe
The hospital should ensure that oxygen cylinders are stored in line with best practice guidance and trust policy.
Should-do action 11 of 27
Should do
Safe
The hospital should ensure that call bells are immediately available to all patients so that they are able to call for assistance when needed.
Should-do action 12 of 27
Should do
Well-led
The hospital should ensure that initial reviews for all serious incidents are completed in a timely manner, in line with trust policy and national guidance.
Should-do action 13 of 27
Should do
Well-led
The services should ensure that all areas of performance are identified and that improvements are made in a timely manner.
Should-do action 14 of 27
Should do
Well-led
The services should ensure that actions are implemented on the risk management system so that risks are further reduced or eliminated.
Should-do action 15 of 27
Should do
Responsive
The hospital should consider ways to improve patient flow, making sure that patients are managed in areas that meet their needs.
Should-do action 16 of 27
Should do
Safe
The hospital should consider ways in which to make sure that all agency nursing staff receive local inductions and that evidence for this is kept.
Should-do action 17 of 27
Should do
Safe
The service should ensure that action plans are in place to improve compliance for mandatory training, for medical staff.
Should-do action 18 of 27
Should do
Safe
The services should ensure that patients own medications are checked on admission as part of the medicines reconciliation process and in line with the trusts medicines optimisation strategy.
Should-do action 19 of 27
Should do
Safe
The services should ensure that all serviceable equipment has a legible, recorded asset number on it.
Should-do action 20 of 27
Should do
Responsive
The services should ensure policies and procedures include all areas used to hold patients for a prolonged period of time whilst waiting for beds.
Should-do action 21 of 27
Should do
Well-led
The services should review staff awareness of the incident reporting procedure.
Should-do action 22 of 27
Should do
Safe
The services should review mandatory training rates for medical staff.
Should-do action 23 of 27
Should do
Well-led
Service leads should implement a system to monitor safety performance across community services.
Should-do action 24 of 27
Should do
Effective
Service leads should continue to develop more accurate and through means of monitoring and measuring effectiveness in terms of patient outcomes and performance indicators.
Should-do action 25 of 27
Should do
Well-led
Service leads should continue with plans to formalise clinical supervision for staff within the community respiratory and heart failure teams.
Should-do action 26 of 27
Should do
Safe
The services should provide additional training so that staff are aware of how to access all the patient information they need to plan care.
Should-do action 27 of 27
Should do
Well-led
Service leads should consider how governance systems can be improved to better support community services.

Location details

CQC ID: RQ614
Local authority: Liverpool
Region: North West

Inspection report

Type: Inspection report
Date: 17 January 2019
Rating: Requires improvement
Actions: 15 must-do 27 should-do
AI-extracted 3 Jun 2026