Luton Dunstable University Hospital
NHS / Health Body
Action Planned
Luton and Dunstable University Hospital are commissioning a further report from an independent general neurologist to assess whether the individual clinician's practice regarding NICE guidelines on epilepsy referrals fell outside the threshold of reasonable practice. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mr Smith Inquest touching the death of Aimee Sarah VARNEY Inquest held on 19th May 2014 at Coroner's Court; Ampthill Thank you for your Regulation 28 Report; dated 2nd June 2014,in response to the death of Aimee Varney: The Trust has considered the following matter of concern:
1) That the NICE (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) Guidelines for referring patient with suspected epilepsy to specialist tertiary centre were not followed_ The Medical Director is responsible for ensuring every new NICE guideline is allocated to the relevant speciality. The appropriate Clinical Audit and Effectiveness Committee (CAEC) Lead, the Finance and the Clinical Director all receive copies for discussion and dissemination. As for all NHS bodies there are occasions where the hospital cannot immediately comply with NICE guidance_ This can be due to resources and requires negotiation with our commissioners to fund, for example, high value new drug therapies_ The allocations are recorded on central database managed by the Clinical Quality Department also record whether the relevant speciality has declared the guideline to be non-applicable, applicable and implemented or applicable but the Trust is non-compliant: A Risk Register is kept of all guidelines the Trust is not able to immediately comply with; this is regularly monitored to ensure the relevant changes are made as soon as possible. Individual_Clinicians have ready access to the relevant NICE guidelines via the Hospitals Intranet: can also gain access via the NICE website WWW nice Org_uk/quidance ooenge Qu": Luton and Dunstable University Hospital "c V Pitli:u: Pleliu N- Fcunja QX NH JiVel s18 They They Toa [
However it must be emphasised that are guidelines, not tramlines that the treating clinician must rigidly follow. NICE state health and social care professionals are actively encouraged to follow our recommendations to help them deliver highest quality care_ Of course, our recommendations are not intended to replace the professional expertise and clinical judgement of health professionals, as they discuss treatment options with their patients_ There will be individual patients where the treating clinician uses their own judgement and does not follow the absolute guidance_ In this particular case the expert report was prepared by a clinician with special interest in epilepsy, from specialist centre_ Their report may not reflect what is considered acceptable practice by general neurologist; with general neurology practice, that is managing patient with epilepsy: For this reason we are commissioning a further report, from an independent general neurologist; to get assurance that the individual clinician's practice did not fall outside the threshold of reasonable practice_ hope you are reassured that the Trust has appropriate systems for the logging and disseminating of NICE Guidelines
1) That the NICE (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) Guidelines for referring patient with suspected epilepsy to specialist tertiary centre were not followed_ The Medical Director is responsible for ensuring every new NICE guideline is allocated to the relevant speciality. The appropriate Clinical Audit and Effectiveness Committee (CAEC) Lead, the Finance and the Clinical Director all receive copies for discussion and dissemination. As for all NHS bodies there are occasions where the hospital cannot immediately comply with NICE guidance_ This can be due to resources and requires negotiation with our commissioners to fund, for example, high value new drug therapies_ The allocations are recorded on central database managed by the Clinical Quality Department also record whether the relevant speciality has declared the guideline to be non-applicable, applicable and implemented or applicable but the Trust is non-compliant: A Risk Register is kept of all guidelines the Trust is not able to immediately comply with; this is regularly monitored to ensure the relevant changes are made as soon as possible. Individual_Clinicians have ready access to the relevant NICE guidelines via the Hospitals Intranet: can also gain access via the NICE website WWW nice Org_uk/quidance ooenge Qu": Luton and Dunstable University Hospital "c V Pitli:u: Pleliu N- Fcunja QX NH JiVel s18 They They Toa [
However it must be emphasised that are guidelines, not tramlines that the treating clinician must rigidly follow. NICE state health and social care professionals are actively encouraged to follow our recommendations to help them deliver highest quality care_ Of course, our recommendations are not intended to replace the professional expertise and clinical judgement of health professionals, as they discuss treatment options with their patients_ There will be individual patients where the treating clinician uses their own judgement and does not follow the absolute guidance_ In this particular case the expert report was prepared by a clinician with special interest in epilepsy, from specialist centre_ Their report may not reflect what is considered acceptable practice by general neurologist; with general neurology practice, that is managing patient with epilepsy: For this reason we are commissioning a further report, from an independent general neurologist; to get assurance that the individual clinician's practice did not fall outside the threshold of reasonable practice_ hope you are reassured that the Trust has appropriate systems for the logging and disseminating of NICE Guidelines