Source · Prevention of Future Deaths

Daphne Cherry

Ref: 2017-0080 Date: 13 Mar 2017 Coroner: Katy Skerrett Area: Gloucestershire Responses identified: 1 / 1 View PDF

Concerns exist regarding care home staff's ability to identify and appropriately escalate medical concerns, including when a medical review is needed.

Date 13 Mar 2017
56-day deadline 8 May 2017 est.
Responses identified 1 of 1
Care Home Health related deaths

Coroner's concerns

AI summary
Concerns exist regarding care home staff's ability to identify and appropriately escalate medical concerns, including when a medical review is needed.
View full coroner's concerns
In the circumstances it is my statutory to report to you: (1) Whether staff at the Care Home are able to identify when a medical concern should be escalated and a medical review sought. Gloucestershire Coroner' $ Court, Corinium Avenue_ Barnwood, Gloucester, GL4 3DJ Tel 01452 305661 Fax 01452 412618 and The 22nd due duty

Responses

1 respondent
Care UK Private Sector
5 May 2017 PDF
Action Taken

Care UK has taken actions including training the home manager, deputy, and unit leaders in early recognition of deteriorating patients, delivering training to all staff, introducing daily meetings and walkarounds to discuss residents, and CQC has acknowledged the implemented changes. (AI summary)

View full response
Dear Ms Skerrett, Daphne Cherry deceased - Prevention of Future Deaths report We write further to your letter of 15 March, 2017, and in particular the Prevention of Future Deaths report issued following Mrs Cherry's Inquest. As you know, Care UK had already put in place a number of changes following Mrs Cherry's death but welcomes the opportunity to consider further improvements. We note that you are concerned whether staff at Sandfields Care Home are able to identify when a medical concern should be escalated and a review sought. The actions we have taken are as follows. As a preliminary point, Sandfields employs a number of registered nurses and there is always at least one on duty at any given time. As the Coroner will be aware, nurses undergo extensive professional training which would cover recognition of the clinical symptoms exhibited by a deteriorating resident. Care UK has nonetheless taken further action both to supplement this professional knowledge of our nurses, and also to train the rest of the Sandfields staff (including those who are non-clinically trained) in recognising deteriorating residents. The home manager, deputy home manager and the home's unit leaders have all undergone training in 'Early recognition of the sick and deteriorating patient', which has been provided by the Care Home Support team based at Gloucestershire Care Services NHS Trust. In essence, they are an NHS service funded jointly by Health and Social Care, and they provide education and training to care homes across Gloucestershire. They work closely with key stakeholders in the sector, including the CQC and CHC. We enclose a link to their website, should the Coroner need any further information:

We are awaiting further dates for training sessions to be released by the Care Home Support team, and as soon as they have been made available then all shift leaders will be booked onto upcoming sessions. We expect the dates to be released in the next couple of weeks. Alongside this, and in order to augment the training, the unit leaders have been specifically tasked, in conjunction with the Care UK governance team, with cascading the principles of the Cate UK Commun,ty Pannenhops LJm,ted - Registered In England No 2644862 Registered Office Connaught House. 850 Th& Crescent COlc:nester Business P811<. Colchester, Essex C04 90B

training to the shift leaders. This is to ensure that staff are brought up to speed as soon as possible, and not simply waiting for the further Care Home Support training dates. Unit leaders will meet with shift leaders on a one-to-one basis to take them through the principles. These meetings are to have taken place by 15 May, 2017. Once this phase is complete, one of the unit leaders will also be responsible for training the remaining care home staff. This process will be completed by the end of June 2017 and will capture fill staff working in the home. The principles will also be reinforced on an ongoing basis as part of individual staff supervision. The net result of the above actions is that all staff within the home will have received training in recognition of deteriorating residents by the end of June 2017. We have not limited this process to clinical staff, as we consider it is important that fill_staff are able to recognise an unwell resident and understand what to do. In terms of the training itself, it includes an escalation numbering system to alert staff to the seriousness of the resident's condition, otherwise known as the 'National Early Warning Score', (or 'NEWS'). This provides an algorithm by which six physical parameters are measured and given a score. The overall score then provides staff with a clear indication as to what type of response is required to each clinical scenario, so whether this is a call to the 111 service, a GP or an ambulance. The training also incorporates understanding "SBAR" - i.e. Situation, Background, Assessment and Recommendation. This is an action list used as an aide memoire for staff relating information to 111/GP services. Sandfields keeps a copy of the list next to the telephones so that it prompts staff when they are speaking to other medical teams. It encompasses: S - Situation (a concise statement of the problem) B - Background (pertinent and brief information related to the situation) A - Assessment (analysis and considerations of options - what you found/think) R - Recommendation (action requested/recommended - what you want) We recognise that it is important to also monitor the efficacy of training and knowledge- building, and this is the responsibility of the home manager and deputy home manager. One of them will be on duty at any one time, including evenings and weekends. There is therefore 24/7 management coverage. As we mentioned above, there is also always a nurse on duty. In order to check that staff are responding appropriately to resident's clinical needs, it is their responsibility to discuss unwell residents with the manager or the deputy during daily meetings and walkarounds. This includes an outline of the clinical presentation, and the actions taken by that member of staff in response. If it is during the weekday core hours, then staff should approach the manager to discuss a resident. If it is during the evening or early hours of the morning then they should escalate to the nurse in charge who, in turn, is expected to contact the on-call manager if unsure about what to do. At weekends, the on-call manager telephones the home to discuss unwell residents in order to ensure appropriate actions have been taken. This process provides effective scrutiny of the staff's decision-making, and reinforces any learning points. It is effectively an ongoing audit process, to ensure safe care to residents. It is not an additional step in the process which might cause delay as staff have to check with us before taking action. It is about oversight of the decisions that have been made by staff, and if there is an emergency then they are expected to contact the appropriate services without delay.

In addition to the Coroner, we have also been liaising with the CQC in relation to the changes which have been made within Sandfields. In particular, we outlined those changes described above and we received correspondence in response from our local CQC inspector, Vicky Dale, on 4 May 2017, stating that: "/ have made a note ofyour comments and can see that action has been taken to ensure staff are skilled and competent to recognise and escalate concerns when a person's health deteriorates and that processes have been implemented to support the staff training and expected standards ofcare." We are therefore confident that we have implemented a robust series of improvements, which will result in staff understanding and responding to the clinical needs of an unwell and deteriorating resident.

Report sections

Investigation and inquest
On the 1/3/2016 commenced an investigation into the death of Daphne Cherry: The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on the 9th March 2017. The conclusion of the inquest was a narrative conclusion: medical cause of death was 1A bronchopneumonia and gastric erosions and bladder cancer:
Circumstances of the death
Daphne Cherry was a 83 year old lady with significant medical history including diabetes, hypertension and dementia. She had been a resident at a Care Home in Cheltenham since February 2015_ At the beginning of February 2016 she had suffered an episode of diarrhoea and vomiting: Thereafter her appetite decreased: On the 17/h February she was diagnosed with urinary tract infection, and her GP prescribed antibiotics. That prescription was further extended on the 19th Over the weekend of the 20th and 21s February 2016, staff at the care home were aware that Daphne was suffering an infection, taking antibiotics, and that her fluid intake was lower than her recommended level. Staff and family members were encouraging her to take sips of water. However when her fluid intake continued to decline staff did not escalate the matter, and no medical review was sought until after 6am on Monday February. Paramedics attended, and Daphne was transferred to hospital where a severe kidney injury was diagnosed. She was severely dehydrated, and appropriate treatments were instigated Daphne's condition steadily deteriorated and she passed away at 23.15 hours on the 22n February 2016 The post mortem has identified natural cause, bronchopneumonia as the final factor that caused Daphne's death, in the context of gastric erosions and bladder cancer The likelihood of Daphne developing bronchopneumonia was increased to her age, the fact that she had developed an infection, and that she had sustained an injury to her kidneys. There are several possible causes for the latter injury including a lack of fluids, an infection, and the medications Daphne was taking:
Action should be taken
In my opinion action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you have the power to take such action.

Similar PFD reports

Shared signals

Related inquiry recommendations

Similar themes

Report details

Reference
2017-0080
Date of report
13 March 2017
Coroner
Katy Skerrett
Coroner area
Gloucestershire

Responses identified

Responses identified 1 of 1
All listed responses identified

Organisations named in PFD reports are normally expected to respond within 56 days. Deadline: 8 May 2017 (estimated).

Sent to

Care UK

Source links